On the theme of hunger: two perspectives on I and “I” : (a recycled poem)
This I dined last night at Nobu
Tonight it’s Zuma (just before Harrods on the right).
Thin paps full of nothing
A rounded belly distends from this “I”.
This I started with a Dawhinnie
Saying “A Chateau Lafitte, ’68, for later?”
Dust and drought have dried the throat of this “I”.
This I sucks on a cigar, orders cappuccino
And comments on the chocolate pudding:
“Call the police. This should be illegal!”
The chill night comes curling its noose, chokes
the breath of this “I”.
This I and this “I”?
This I is
and
this “I” was.
a trippy poem
hmm
Definitely a poem that requires contemplation. I have read it three times and each time I see it another way. Significant words. Intriguing words. I shall be reading it again.
Allen
Words cleverly used. I like the layout of the last strophe. I guess we are all trapped in the several versions of the self as also in time. I would have invariably written This I and That I, but a second reading helped me concur on This. Intelligent work.
I have read this poem once and believe the meaning is clear without further analysis. The preamble, though, is misleading. It may well be the perspectives of I and ‘I’, two distinct personalities, but the theme needs to be redefined. It is obvious from the poem that while I is enjoying a very satisfying meal, ‘I’ is suffering from what the dictionary describes as “The discomfort, weakness, or pain caused by a prolonged lack of food “, i.e. hunger.
The theme changes significantly and could either be called ‘nourishment’ or ‘appetite and hunger’.
I would suggest that the line ‘This I and this “I”?’ is redundant as the ending summarise the contrast.
I thought ‘I’ and ‘I’ were used effectively to differentiate the two lived experiences; likewise the two types – ordinary and italics. So, to me, it worked fine; and how many of us have not reflected on this disparity at some time?