
I’m ashamed to be born
as a human being,
doubly ashamed to be born
as a man, I wouldn’t choose
to end my life,
but I’m waiting to die.
Fiction · Poetry · New Voices

I’m ashamed to be born
as a human being,
doubly ashamed to be born
as a man, I wouldn’t choose
to end my life,
but I’m waiting to die.
You must be logged in to post a comment.
I think your poem aptly describes the angst of many a man, Supratik. I have an understanding of your words (that I accept might not be the one in your mind) and it causes me to suggest that there are women too who might to drawn to feel this way. Also, I consider that in a way it is a ‘get out’ notion, if you will: Does the chaos ‘we’ have brought, not deserve rehabilitative efforts to rectify and heal it? Or, do we leave the mess for eons, writhing in pain, waiting for someone, something, to come along and put it out of its misery?
Having said that makes me think too, that my understanding of your piece is very negative. Forgive me. 🙁
Allen
Good observation. I don’t judge, not even those who do. Thank you.
I wasn’t judging you, Supratik. If I was judging anybody it was myself!
As we are all part of the whole then we all share in the guilt, shame and depression of the history of misdeeds. So I fully understand where you thoughts are coming from, and I defend your right to have your own thoughts and feelings.
I do feel, myself, as a comment in contrast, that there is another part of the whole who do good deeds, have good thoughts, help others, practice giving love (to themselves and others.) Our media delights in telling us of negativity; telling us things to make us fear. What we need more than anything is balance – in all things.
Cordially,
Allen
Thank you. Yes, losing balance doesn’t help. I don’t know what does. If all kinds of worthless growth and development comes to a complete halt, if people get locked up in their confined place somehow, and still see the stars rising in the sky, the flora and the fauna flourishing will then people have a room for some introspection.
I’m a bit puzzled by this piece, supratik. Why should you – or anyone else – be ashamed of being a human being or man? Even the world’s worst characters such as Hitler, Mobutu, Pol Pot, Stalin, Idi Amin and Mugabe didn’t decry themselves, so artistic people like yourself are an antidote to evil.
What would you sooner be born as? You’ve got infinitely more chance of making your mark on Earth as you are, rather than as a tigress or ewe etc.
Best wishes,
Steve
But I am ashamed, Steve. I’m sure I have my reasons, but human beings are the most notorious monsters on earth that need to perish as a species. Looking at violations of a nonagenarian and a six month baby, I am ashamed of my gender and wish that women of the world cut their vagina to end giving births to terrorists, rapists, war mongers. Human beings are the worst of all evolutionary processes.
Only a sense of shame, utter shame and guilt could perhaps deliver us as a race, but the irony is we are still proud to be a human being, there seems to be not an iota of shame for what we’ve done, and what we will continue to do.
Steve, it’s my personal view, asking for a reason I think would belittle it more than anything else, like supporting any unconscious soul. It’s time to wake up and sink on our knees, throw away everything we have to make global peace and harmony our only, only raison d’être.
We need to die of shame. Such a monster of a species we are, such monsters.
I think it’s time when the subjugated gender should sacrifice their organs or sterilized themselves to prevent the earth from being poisoned further; it’s also time for the farmers to stop ploughing in order to end exploitation and vulgar growth once and for all. I don’t have any hope in resurrection and transformation. We have misused the consciousness that differentiates us from all other sentient beings, we are conscious on the outside alone, we don’t seem to be conscious on the inside.
well I don’t think that such a sacrifice will help women etc or the planet. we Greeks have a saying: the devil has many feet.
you don’t want to ever read a single passage from a book talking about the Inquisition and the things they did to both males and females. or what evil Amazons did when they raided villages to young girls. females are able to be equally disgusting. for example [ ……..wrote a couple of examples but deleted them for the sake of hope ] evil is not a matter of our gender. it’s genderless.. that’s why it can affect everything.
trust me. we can spend days talking about evil acts and somebody will appear and add a new story that will horrify us even more.
and I understand why you feel this way. it’s really THAT bad in this world
It truly is that bad. The sad part is that we don’t realise it. We are different from all other sentient beings because of consciousness, but we have exploited it the wrong way, to seize or capture the outside, not to conquer the inside. I would have loved to be proud of being a human being, but I am not, no, I am sorry, I would have been proud to be a man, no, I am not; I don’t have any hope left apart from correcting myself, that’s all. In people, in the civilised, uncivilised worlds, in humankind, I don’t look forward to anything at all. China, the Us, the UK, Russia, India-Pakistan-Bengal, Iran-Iraq….chhi chhi chhi (it’s an expression of utter disgust and shame in my language…)
first of all nobody can provide solid proof that this is the only world
so a big IF emerges, If there are other worlds they could be better than this one or worse, at least some of them could be either. If this is the only world then evil things happen and as time goes by all sentient beings eventually confront, live, experience or commit something evil.
I’ve experienced some pretty bad things, the last thing I would ever feel is shame, but yeah shame on the individuals that abused a child and one of them beat me too so bad that I was dizzy for days.
No we the victims of this f-ing world do not feel shame. We feel rage. and we will one day take the biggest revenge ever starting with the Creator of this world, who could have stopped at least a tiny percentage of evil more than hesheit may already have stopped, was there room for more good? there wasn’t? hmm in this case it’s not us that should feel any shame, one thing leads to another, there was a comment of mine I think on Alison’s work.. if you don’t mind long comments I can post it. thanks
update: I submitted it as an article, would I want the person that could have killed me while beating me as a child to be saved had he been in danger when he was a toddler? Maybe but if he has done it to other kids too, definitely not. Please read my article and you’ll understand why I am saying such things.
We are trying to help each other by sharing opposite points of view in terms of our response to the atrocities that surround the world. I say opposite because I don’t think rage can help, I have gone through many grueling exercises to control my rage, rage is of no use, in my opinion, the opposite of mercy, it is twice cursed. My response to be born as a human being and as a man is utter shame. I feel like Sita, asking the mother-world to divide so I can bury myself in her lap for good.
This is a difficult one for me. The atavistic nature of human beings tends towards cruelty and darkness, but the veil of civility which is imprinted onto us from birth tempers that, allows us to appreciate, to love, to create and much more. The answer is not to kill ourselves but to attune ourselves to the needs of others and also the ecosystem of which the earth is a part. We need to inspire and be inspired.
Bhi
Thank you for your response. The poem didn’t propose to kill anyone, it’s a truthful confession which makes the writer utterly shameful of being born as a human being and as a man.
I am not totally against civilisation, but I don’t have any confidence in civilisation anymore. Sorry. I think it answers your question of the veil of civility, which, in my opinion, has caused damage to the world and to the writer, hence the need to unveil and be truthful is urgent.
I think there needs to be a movement where women would stop breeding and farmers ploughing. Let this civilisation that is based on what it is based come to its long-awaited closure. In the interim, let us also write about the milk of human kindness.
I am quite embarrassed that it’s difficult for you, but I cannot say what I want to say to make things easy for you and for the majority of people who think like you.
There’s no need to be embarrassed; It is I who should be embarrassed that my intellect is not sufficient to unravel your poem. My mistake to say” kill ourselves”; my intention was that we should not wait for or welcome death, but rather agitate to break down what is wrong and build what is right.
No, we cannot change anything. We simply cannot. What you say makes for a good writing. For years and years we have been only writing on how to change things, but while doing we are a big zero, let’s face it. We need to be ashamed of ever coming into this world and ruining every bit of its sublimity, abundance, affection, unconditional love.
Look at the way a leaf is made, with such symmetry and brilliance, look at the way a dawn breaks, dew drops, and look at the way a three-month old child gets raped, a nine year old, raped by her father who then offers to marry her, look at the way we are still fighting with each of our neighbours, look at the way we have scratched the world, we have divided and divided and divided, and still we need to be proud of who we are???? Sorry.
We need to do something drastic to bring the human beings into consciousness words, mere words are not working.
Hmm – no need to be ashamed – unless you are complicit in mans misdoings. These are a spur to rise above and seek after righteousness.
Rick
Of course, I am, of course I am. I know I am, just because I know I am doesn’t make me a better person than those who don’t know, do you understand it? But for heaven’s sake don’t make it trivial by saying no need to feel ashamed, let’s move on kind of think. I think it’s better not to say anything rather than saying something banal. Of course, I have reasons to feel ashamed, if there’s no shame, no atonement, no change is possible. I’d like to stop concerning with you on this. I don’t want to talk to those who think there’s nothing to be ashamed of unless one finds himself committing the same mistake. The subject in question is not like a let’s move on kind of a thing for heaven’s sake?
It’s okay Rick.
I feel your pain…and hopelessness.
It is such a private thing that,once expressed, conjures up all sorts of different feelings in the readers.
I am a woman but I also find it very hard to be here now. There is a great sickness permeating humanity and it’s got nothing to do with any virus.
Alison x
Thank you. No change is possible without a feeling of overwhelming shame. Rage certainly doesn’t help, shame does. However, this is how I think. I would like to correct myself if I see rage, or the idea of revenge is able to bring about any ‘real’ change in the way we think. Our behavior changed for a while (through repentance, guilt, and shame) when we saw the man bleeding and being crucified to death and yet seeking forgiveness for the ones who were killing him in public.