A haiku-like verbless poem for the poetry challenge
A thousand Hail Mary’s at midnight.
A mushroom cloud.
Silence.
Fiction · Poetry · New Voices
Published
A haiku-like verbless poem for the poetry challenge
A thousand Hail Mary’s at midnight.
A mushroom cloud.
Silence.
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Most effective! You’ve fit a whole lot of alliteration into few words – the repeated m and s. Also love the internal rhyming of thou(sand) and clou(d) . Then we have the (m)HUSH(room) followed by a hugely isolated
Silence.
All great poetic techniques. Verbless poem success, I’d say. Well done, shywolf! moi, bel 🙂
Thank you, bel. You have an eye for detail which greatly informs your comment and I very much appreciate it.
Shy 🙂
Perfect, Glen. Concise and to the point, not a wasted word.
But pray tell me: what is the reaction of those who are not of the Catholic persuasion? 🙂
(Only joking my friend).
Best, Luigi
Thank you, Luigi, for your generous comment. As for the reaction of those who are not of the Catholic persuasion, that’s a good question (even in jest). I suspect their reaction would be similar to those on an airplane about to crash: that’s when they act on what they truly believe.
Glen
Unlike the first two commentators. I am having a headache as a result of reading this. If I take your title as a summing up of the aftereffects of a nuclear attack, I have a problem coming to terms with the idea of people still physically able to make their way to a church to pray. I also find the second line superfluous as you have already let us know we are or were at the onset of a nuclear winter. If, alternatively, I interpret your poem as the depiction of a sequence of events leading to a nuclear winter, that is, a gathering of people praying, then the explosion followed by silence, the Hail Mary’s would seemed to have failed. As prayers have been known to fail to alter the cause of events throughout history, perhaps this is the point you are making?
In my opinion, Gerald, your last interpretation is the correct one but only Glen can tell us.
On the point that you make about people physically unable to make their way to church after a nuclear attack, don’t forget that after the Hiroshima and Nagasaki cataclism there were survivors. Here is a quote from Time magazine:
“For the survivors of those ruined cities, the coming of the bomb was a personal event before it was a global one. Amid the death and destruction, some combination of luck or destiny or smarts saved them—and therefore saved the voices that can still tell the world what it looks like when human beings find new and terrible ways to destroy one another.”
Fifty plus years on, Luigi, with nuclear bombs being many times more powerful than those dropped on Japan, the question is: would there be any survivors? Also I wonder if there would there be silence after the detonation of a nuclear bomb? Would there not be a howling nuclear wind and the sound of collapsing buildings coupled with explosions caused by fires and short-circulating at various installations all round the world? Perhaps the silence would be in the deafened church-goers’ ears as they slump, shaking their fists at the Almighty, over the backs of the pews?
I read this haiku-like three liner as visionary given the current state of nuclear tension that exists today. It is set, in my take on the read, in a dangerously close future time. So I can accept that those of any religious persuasion ( we’d have to hear from shy on why only Catholics) across America, Canada, S Korea, Guam and Japan would be gathering to pray for heavenly intervention and world peace.
As for this poet’s decision to use silence as the aftermath, that again is from his perspective and he has every right to it. I thought it brilliant from a Native’s own historical reference ( their voices have been totally silenced) and is corroborated by the response of a survivor in this documentary film which I believe was first released in 2016. http://realscreen.com/2016/08/02/nhk-world-prepares-for-small-steps-from-hiroshima/ . A woman is asked about her first impressions/what stood out for her AFTER the bomb had fallen. She said it was the eerie, utter silence. Not a sound anywhere. Or words to that effect.
Back to add more to this conversation! Why is midnight specified for all those Hail Mary’s? If you think about the geological clock, man only comes into existence at ten minutes BEFORE midnight. So the big twelve-o would place all of us on the verge of extinction. Wouldn’t it?
For me, all these clues I mention suggest a lot deeper meaning in shy’s message than it would appear on the surface.
We must not lose sight of the fact that Shywolf has entitled his poem “Nuclear Winter.” Midnight is a reference to the Doomsday Clock. In the light of the present state of affairs, we are about two and a half minutes from a global catastrophe which will bring about a nuclear winter. However, a single “mushroom cloud”, despite being several times bigger than those dropped in 1945, would not be enough to cause a nuclear winter. It would take a full scale nuclear war. The cooling effects of a nuclear winter would not be immediate but the breakdown of normal life would, mainly in the Northern Hemisphere. Life would continue but in a degraded state, whole populations suffering famine, extreme cold and disease. Few people, if any, would survive until the nuclear winter passed and then they would have to endure rising temperatures owing to the destruction of the earth’s stratosphere.. Silence was experienced by survivors in the immediate epicentre of the detonations over Japan. Present day bombs would be too devastating for miles around for anyone to experience ‘silence.’ Far from wishing to detract from the power of this short poem, I would like the poet to make it clearer – it’s either about a single Hiroshima-type bomb (except there was no praying beforehand as it wasn’t expected), or it’s about the ONSET of a nuclear winter.
It’s about a single hydrogen bomb which represents all hydrogen bombs, dropped in an all out nuclear war and the ensuing (although not immediate) nuclear winter.
Thank you, Nemo, for this lively discussion. It really made me think hard about my poem and the choices I’ve made as its author. It’s also helped clarify in my mind what as well as how it means.
They wouldn’t be gathering for prayer, they’d be praying in place wherever they found themselves at midnight. The choice of prayer was arbitrary on my part, chosen for purely artistic reasons. I didn’t mean to single out Catholics. The prayer in the context of this poem is the final act of desperation of people about to die.
(Your interpretation adds a richness to the poem which, as a author, I am immensely grateful for, and which makes posting here a very rewarding experience. Thank you.)
Shy
Well, after all these back and forth long ‘explanations’ of what each thinks/means the question is, does the author want any suggestions on changes he might want to consider making? After all, that’s what we’re here for, right? It’s your poem, Shy. I do know you’ve always been open to hearing what others think might be missing/ might help clarify/make a piece more effective/powerful. That doesn’t mean, necessarily, you’ll act on any suggestions you receive, for , again, it’s your work and for you to decide.
I remain open to any suggestions for improvement and challenges to the rationale behind my artistic decisions. I always give them my serious consideration and then decide which to implement/address, which not to. The back and forth over this poem has been a fruitful one for me because it helped me clarify what I mean and how I mean it. Therefore, I’m grateful to Nemo, you, and Luigi for this lively debate and the resulting suggestions.
Shy
The silence would be the silence of a winter without life after all the sound and fury of a nuclear war had dissipated and extinction ensued.
Yes, the last interpretation is the correct one concerning the futility of prayer as a metaphysical power capable of changing world events. In this poem, it is an act of desperation on the eve of certain death. Thanks for sharing that quote, Luigi, I found the line ‘…the bomb was a personal event before it was a global one.’ to be especially relevant to the poem: the bomb is very personal to those thousand people.
Sorry for the headache, Nemo, but I do appreciate your concerns. I will try to address them as best I can, hopefully clarifying those details which caused them. The image I wanted to convey was that of a thousand people (representing mankind) praying where they are at (home, school, church, etc), out of desperation, as a nuclear war is launched. It would be a similar reaction, I would imagine, as that from a plane full of people about to crash. The second line is a singular mushroom cloud representing multiple mushroom clouds in a nuclear war, annihilating the thousand people, and the silence at the end is the nuclear winter which ensues. Thank you for your comment and giving me the opportunity to clarify.
Clever use of few words. Short, not sweet. This no verbs business certainly produces an intensity.
Rachel 🙂
Intensity is what I was going for. Thank you for your comment, Rachel.
Glen
Thank you, Gothicman, for your astute observation and intriguing interpretation. I think you’ll get a chuckle out of this quote from one of my favorite movies, The Battle of Britain:
‘Senior civil servant: Churchill puts great faith in radar.
Air Chief Marshall Sir Hugh Dowding: It’s vital, but it won’t shoot down aircraft.
Senior civil servant: Ha… well I must say you don’t, exactly exude a spirit of optimism.
Air Chief Marshall Sir Hugh Dowding: God willing we will hold out minister.
Senior civil servant: I see. So I tell the cabinet, that you’re trusting in radar and praying to God, is that right?
Air Chief Marshall Sir Hugh Dowding: [chuckles] more accurately the other way round. Trusting in god and praying for radar.’
😉
It might look as though I’m a snarling dog who won’t be parted from his juicy bone but I’m persisting with my comments as this poem, in my opinion, is not the finished product and it raises in me the desire for greater clarity. In your mind, perhaps, there is clarity because you know what you mean, though you should not have had to explain what you meant. The poem is either about events leading to a nuclear winter or it’s a description of a nuclear winter after the nuclear war. At the moment it’s trying to be both which is why it’s still giving me headache and making me write this.
I will attempt to make my points once more, Shywolf, though I feel as though I’m wasting my time.
1. As long as the title remains unmodified as ‘Nuclear Winter’, I expect the poem to be a description of a nuclear winter, not events leading to one. I therefore do not expect to find people praying to ward off something that has already happened.
2. It would take the spread of the dust of more than one mushroom cloud to exclude the rays of the sun from maintaining the Earth’s temperature. Unless “A mushroom cloud’ is amended you cannot expect a literal reader’s intellect to accept the fudge that a single mushroom cloud really means a multitude of mushroom clouds.
3. The Earth has endured the equivalent of nuclear winters before, healed itself and survived. There would have been enough happening for there to be the presence of noise. I take the word ‘silence’ to mean the absence of noise. In the event of a nuclear winter brought about by a nuclear war, even if the whole of mankind were wiped out, the planet would not be silent. There would still be noise coming from the seas, the oceans, the wind, volcanoes and earthquakes to name but a few sources of noise. To stretch the word ‘silence’ to mean a nuclear winter and thereby through what you assume would be total extinction of mankind and therefore its ability to hear sounds anymore is a misuse of language too far. It smacks of ‘And the rest is silence’ and is a rather oversimplified way of trying to convey what a nuclear winter would be like. The fact that survivors experienced silence in the immediate environment following a nuclear detonation fifty-two years ago does automatically mean that there would be an all invasive silence during a nuclear winter.
4. However, and it’s a big however, the word ‘silence’ does work most effectively, (though I’ve not detected any indication that your readers have picked up on it), if we take it to refer to the response of the addressee of the people’s prayers but what amendments to the poem and its title would be necessary to achieve that more logical outcome I cannot at present think of.
5. ‘Prayers at midnight’ would suffice, by the way. All-encompassing.
I have read your points of contention, Nemo, and thank you for them. You’ve given me a lot to think about and I shall do just that. I appreciate the investment of your time in this matter, as well as the challenge to the rationale behind my poem (and its title). Perhaps I shouldn’t have to explain what I meant, but as a poet, the exercise does my mind a lot of good. Thank you, again, for reading and commenting.
The ramifications of thinking brought on by your poem have “inspired’ one of mine, the first in 12 months, so I’m grateful what I’ve gained from reading it.
I look forward to reading your poem.