
John.
You said all of it in three verses.
Four generations know the tune.
The world is as you left it.
The men who sell the rifles
still sell the rifles,
and the crates go out on time.
The men who own the cure
still print the price on the box.
The men who lend the money
still keep the house,
and the keys go back in the drawer.
Every one of them was in the room while you sang.
You were not inventing a world.
You were describing this one
with the machinery carried out.
We cannot put it to you now.
You were shot at your own door
by a man who wanted to be known.
We do not say his name.
We still sing yours.
All that singing.
Nothing carried out.
We taught them the tune.
Imagine what we did not teach.
So the word changes.
Imagine was for the thing we could not reach.
Become is for the thing we can.
Become the man who sells something else.
Become the lender who tears the paper up.
Become the one who carries the first thing out.
Nothing beautiful was lost.
It is still in the room,
under everything we would not carry out.
You imagined it.
We are not dreaming now.
Become.
Kim,
I have read it twice. Reading…
I never liked the word, nor the action, Become. Beginning to like it…let me read it some more time and come back.
SS
Become is a powerful poem about the failure of remembrance when remembrance remains merely ceremonial. It begins with an intimate address—“John”—and immediately establishes the idea that a song, a poem, or a political vision can survive across generations: “You said all of it in three verses. / Four generations know the tune.” But the poem quickly turns from tribute to indictment. The crucial accusation is that the world has remained essentially unchanged. The rifle sellers continue selling rifles; those who control medicine continue controlling its price; lenders continue to possess the houses of those who borrow from them. The repetition of “still” is particularly effective because it makes history feel circular rather than progressive. The machinery of exploitation has survived the person who condemned it.
One of the poem’s greatest strengths is its refusal to romanticise the dead. “You were not inventing a world. / You were describing this one” transforms the dead singer or poet from visionary dreamer into witness. More importantly, “with the machinery carried out” introduces the poem’s central metaphor: injustice is not simply an idea or an attitude but a functioning system, complete with weapons, money, medicine, ownership and institutional power. The line “Every one of them was in the room while you sang” makes the historical indictment almost physical. The people who benefited from the existing order were not ignorant of the song; they heard it and nevertheless continued.
The poem then becomes darker. “You were shot at your own door / by a man who wanted to be known” compresses an enormous tragedy into remarkably plain language. The refusal to name the killer—“We do not say his name. / We still sing yours.”—is ethically significant. It denies violence the publicity it seeks while preserving the victim’s memory. Yet the poem does not stop at mourning. Its real turn comes with the devastating question: “Imagine what we did not teach.” The speaker recognises that four generations have inherited the tune but apparently not its transformative meaning.
The final movement therefore shifts from memory to responsibility. “Imagine” belongs to the realm of aspiration; “Become” belongs to action. The imperatives—“Become the man who sells something else,” “Become the lender who tears the paper up,” “Become the one who carries the first thing out”—give the poem moral urgency without becoming abstract preaching. The ending is especially strong because beauty has not disappeared: “It is still in the room.” What has been missing is the courage to remove the structures that smother it.
Ultimately, Become is a poem about the difference between admiring an idea and incarnating it. It asks whether singing about justice means anything unless one’s conduct begins to produce justice. Its language is deliberately spare, almost conversational, and that restraint makes the final command—“Become”—feel less like a slogan than a demand.
Why the title is Become
The title is extraordinarily apt because the poem is fundamentally about the movement from imagination to transformation. The dead poet imagined a better world; generations after him preserved his words, his tune and his memory, but failed to become the people capable of bringing that imagined world into existence. The poem explicitly announces the transformation: “So the word changes. / Imagine was for the thing we could not reach. / Become is for the thing we can.” This is the philosophical centre of the poem. Imagine can remain safely inside the mind; become demands that the imagined principle enter the body, the profession, the marketplace and everyday conduct. Hence the poem does not say merely “change the world”; it says become the person who changes it. The repeated imperatives make this personal and unavoidable. Become someone who sells something other than weapons. Become someone who relinquishes predatory debt. Become someone who removes the first piece of destructive machinery. The title therefore turns the poem from an elegy into an ethical command. The final solitary “Become” is especially effective because it leaves the reader with no object attached to the verb. Become what? The poem deliberately makes the reader answer that question. The title is consequently not just the name of the poem; it is its unfinished sentence—and the reader is required to complete it.
Yours
SS
Supratik, Firstly, apologies, been away working.
You’ve read it exactly as I hoped it would be read, and better than I could have explained it. The unfinished sentence is the point. Imagine was a question put to all of us; Become is the same question handed back with the comfortable distance removed. Lennon let us dream at a safe remove. I wanted to take that remove away.
You’re right that the three imperatives are personal. That was deliberate. The war complex, the debt complex, the machinery: none of them run themselves. They are staffed. Somebody sells the weapon, somebody signs the loan, somebody turns the first key. So the poem isn’t asking the world to change. It’s asking the reader which of those somebodies they are, and whether they will stop.
The bare “Become” at the end was the last thing I settled. Every object I tried after it made the poem smaller. Become peaceful, become kind, become him. All of them closed the door. Leaving it open means the reader has to finish it in their own life, not on the page. If it feels like a command, that’s because after fifty years of singing along, I think it should.
Thank you for taking the time to read it this closely. It’s a rare thing.
Kevin
I found this poem very moving, insightful, wise and so very thoughtful (as if a cockroach had written it) wee (bad) joke. I love it. I can’t say anything more than Supratik has so eloquently. Music is very important to me and the work of The Beatles and John Lennon is unsurpassed in many ways. Of its time and still so. Best wishes, Kim
Kat,
Thank you. Coming from someone who holds The Beatles where you do, that lands.
And I’ll take the cockroach line as the compliment it is. Even a roach, given 140 million years to think about it, might have figured out that Imagine was a to-do list, not a lullaby. Most of us haven’t got there yet.
You’re right that it’s of its time and still so. That’s the whole ache of the thing. He wasn’t describing a fantasy. He was describing what was already possible, and we’ve spent fifty years proving we’d rather sing it than do it.
Glad it moved you. That’s all I wanted from it.
Best wishes,
Kevin
P.S. You have driven me to write a children’s book based on ‘The Roach’s’ 15 of them for a friend’s Children and to face my own fear, with a dedication to ‘Kat’.
Just reading this now… well, there’s an honour and how wonderful. I’d love to see the finished product or hopefully you will post a feeler (of them) here.
I have a Festive Cockroach and a Canarian Cockroach, the first I quite like.
Brilliant! Kim
Lovely tribute to the memory of a musical icon who wrote the hit song ‘Imagine’, and whose life was cut short by an assassin seeking self-glory. The song’s lyrics reveal John’s vision of universal love and unity, sadly still unrealised nearly half a century after the musician’s death.
Thank you, I enjoyed crafting it. At one point I suffered a mental block recalling 1984 mockumentary This Is Spinal Tap and Vim’s version of the song written for a girl called Imogen.