no sense
no relevance
the world is falling apart
so are the words
heads have united
to destroy the space
out of their minds
the lines have fallen off track
there’s no meaning no purpose
no mark of kindness
clumsy cleverness
no room for foolishness
3 responses to “No Sense”
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Supratik,
I have read two of yours so far, and I want to say something about them together rather than one at a time, because I think they belong together.
“No sense” is the outside coming apart. “Ashamed to Death” is the inside being audited. They are not two separate poems, they are two halves of the same argument, and I am not sure you have noticed that you wrote them that way. Your own line about consciousness being used to seize the outside rather than conquer the inside is the thesis sitting underneath both. If you ever put them on a page together, in that order, they would do something neither manages alone.
On “No sense”. Three lines do double work and they are why it holds. “heads have united” reads as heads of state and as minds, and “out of their minds” closes the pun two lines later without announcing it. “the lines have fallen off track” is poetic lines, rail lines and front lines at once. And “no room for foolishness” is the best ending available to you. Kindness and meaning are the losses a reader expects. Foolishness is not. The fool is the one licensed to say the true thing, and losing him is the sharper grief. Do not touch that line.
Where it is weaker, the poem says the words are falling apart and then behaves impeccably. Grammar intact, syntax orderly, twelve tidy lines. I would not fracture the whole thing, that would be a worse poem, but one line breaking under the weight would close the gap. The candidate is “clumsy cleverness”, the only line not doing double duty and the only place the diction goes abstract. “no relevance” I would look at too. It is the flattest line in the poem, relevance being a critic’s word rather than a poet’s, and it sits second, where a reader is still deciding whether to trust you.
On “Ashamed to Death”, I think it is the better poem, and the title is doing more than it lets on. It borrows the shape of bored to death, the idiom we use for a slow and unremarkable killing, and that is precisely the death the poem describes. Waiting, not choosing.
Inside it, the ladder is everything: ashamed as a human, doubly ashamed as a man. The first shame is available to anybody. The second costs you something, and it names who does the waging. And the ending refuses the easy exit. Not choosing to end it but waiting is a far harder position to hold than despair, and you state it without once raising your voice. The comma splice at “as a man, I wouldn’t choose” is the only rough joint and it sits exactly on the turn, so it reads as thought running on without a breath. Leave it.
One thing I would push back on, gently. A reader might call this hatred of humanity. It is not. Hatred puts you outside the thing, and a man who truly despised our species would feel no shame about it, because he would not count himself in. Shame only works if you belong. You are indicting a group you cannot resign from, which is the harder and more honest position, and it is what makes the poem worth reading twice.
I should say where I am reading you from. I spent a good part of my working life in the places these poems are describing, first in uniform and then building things in post-conflict areas. What stays with you is not the destruction so much as the very clever stupid people arranging it. So when you list the countries, I am not going to argue with you. I saw enough of the arithmetic to know how it is done and who pays.
Thank you again for what you gave Rhythm 0. This is me trying to pay in kind. You have a vast list of submissions here and I am looking forward to reading my way through them.
One last thing, offered as a quip rather than a doctrine. What used to undo me out there was the women, the children and the animals. I could never make that arithmetic work. Where I have landed since is that we are all serving a sentence here, and the length of it is the punishment. The child who goes early got a short one and is already out, back in the universe and enjoying the whole of it. The rest of us evidently did something appalling somewhere down the line, which is why we are still here, waiting to die, as you put it. So “Ashamed to Death” is not a condemnation. It is a tariff.
And it is why I would rather be here, trading words that mean something, than anywhere else online. Writing is the only therapy I trust, because it makes you analyse a thing instead of merely feeling it. Better than the dribble, at any rate.
I hope this finds you well.
KJS
KJS, your response has left me thinking—not merely about No Sense and Ashamed to Death, but about something I wrote nearly a decade ago. And I have a feeling you may find it strangely relevant to what you have just said. Ashamed to Death by the way is not a poem, it is a thought I need to carry with me for as long as I leave, it’s a guilt and a shame at the same time.
The poem is called “Sense on Leave.” [https://ukauthors.com/legacy-work/33327/]
Reading your response, I realised that perhaps these poems have been circling the same territory for years: what happens when intelligence becomes detached from wisdom, consciousness turns outward instead of inward, and the ability to destroy develops faster than the ability to understand what we are destroying.
There is a line near the beginning of Sense on Leave:
“In the pursuit of Intelligence, the Intelligent become fools.”
And suddenly, after reading your comments about the fool in No Sense, I wondered whether that line had been waiting all these years to meet your reading of the newer poem.
You spoke beautifully about “no room for foolishness”—about the fool being the one still licensed to say the true thing. In Sense on Leave, I seem to have arrived at the other side of that thought: intelligence itself becomes foolish when it loses sense.
The older poem is much more crowded and perhaps more unruly than No Sense. It moves through vehicles, classes, frozen thoughts, poisoned melancholy, weapons, hunger, hired anger, starvation, terror, and finally those fragile things that still dare to survive—green leaves and rainbows. I can see now that I was perhaps trying to describe a world in which destruction had become sophisticated while everything capable of healing had become almost embarrassingly powerless.
And then the final lines:
“The world that was born years ago
With a lot of care
Is all set to be destroyed with intelligence,
On sabbatical smokes hibernates the sense.”
Perhaps that is why your response prompted me to retrieve this poem. You said that writing makes us analyse a thing rather than merely feel it. I think that is exactly what happened to me, though I did not necessarily know it when I wrote this ten years ago.
I also find your distinction between hatred and shame particularly compelling. I don’t think I have ever quite thought of these poems as hatred of humanity. If anything, they may be attempts to remain part of the indictment—to say, I am implicated too; I cannot stand outside this mess and point a finger.
And your final thought about Ashamed to Death being “not a condemnation. It is a tariff” is going to stay with me. That is a wonderful way of putting it.
So, before you travel too far through my rather alarming list of submissions, I would be genuinely interested in what you make of this one. It was written about ten years ago, but after reading your response, I have the curious feeling that it has just caught up with the other two.
I would particularly like to know whether you see the connection between the three poems—or whether I am constructing a connection retrospectively that was never really there.
Either way, I suspect the conversation has become more interesting than the poems themselves.
And yes—I’m rather enjoying this trading of words too.
Best
Supratik
Supratik,
Before anything else, know how fortunate you are that this survived. A good deal of mine went as ashes. What is left are fragments and smoke trails I can no longer read back, and the parts I miss are not the big lines but the small in-the-moment details, the ones that carried the whole sentiment at the time and have since faded out of me. Much like life and recall as we get older, and the baggage we set down along the way. We drop things without knowing which ones were priceless. Ten years on you can still open Sense on Leave and meet the man who wrote it. That is not a small thing at all.
To your question. I think you are probably doing a bit of both, and I do not think it matters. Some of the link will be retrospective, because that is what reading your own old work does to you. But the material underneath it is not invented. What connects the three is not architecture, it is a preoccupation you have never quite managed to put down, and a preoccupation shows up as a pattern whether or not the writer went looking for one. Ten years apart is not a sequence. It is evidence.
The epigraph is where I saw it. “In the pursuit of Intelligence, the Intelligent become fools” reads to me as the earlier form of the fool in No Sense. In 2014 the fool looks like a verdict passed on other people. In No Sense the fool has become a role, a licence, the one still permitted to say the true thing. Whether that is a development or simply the same place arrived at twice by different roads, I could not say, and you are better placed to judge it than I am.
On the poem, offered as one reader’s response and ten years late, so take it lightly.
What lands for me is the concrete. Icebergs upside down smirking at the mountains. The sky with its innumerable teeth. Ponds under brown fatigue. Those I can see, and seeing is what makes a reader complicit, which I think is what you are after.
The part I sat with longest is the middle, with hunger, hired anger, stagnation, starvation. My grandmother had a saying that has never left me: hunger makes good kitchen. Six children, both wars, and a nurse besides, so she sat with a great many people at their last moments and said she saw the same chapters in all of them. Four words, and the whole weight of a life behind them.
So I came to your list with her in my ear, and my first instinct was to want it more particular. That instinct comes from where I was standing rather than from any rule about poems. Out there nobody says starvation. They say the specific thing, which is a name, a queue and a number of days. The abstractions tend to belong to the people arranging it, because a word with no picture attached has no address either.
Then I read your line again about horror and terror having scrapped every other impotent word from the dictionaries, and I am no longer sure I was right. My grandmother is the argument against me. Those words are not drained in themselves. They are drained in the mouths of people who have not paid for them, and they carry perfectly well in the mouths of people who have. If you put them there knowing exactly what they do, then the poem is working a level above my objection to it, and I would rather concede that than insist.
The line that carries it for me is “Creativity lies in the destruction of life.” Flat, unornamented, no help asked for. I might have let the poem stop nearer to it, but that is only my taste for endings that arrive early, and the last stanza clearly matters to you.
On remaining part of the indictment rather than standing outside it and pointing, we are of the same mind entirely. That is why I can read this without any resistance.
And your remark that Ashamed to Death is not a poem but something you have to carry. Yes. That is the difference between a piece you wrote and a piece that is still writing you. Six lines was the right size for it.
As for the tariff, I hold it loosely. It has the advantage of being unfalsifiable, which makes it a poor theory and a serviceable comfort, and on the days the arithmetic starts up again I will take the comfort and not examine it too closely.
I will keep reading. If the pattern is really there I expect I will find the others that belong to it, and I will tell you what I make of them, wrong or otherwise.
Hope this finds you well.
KJS