A very old poem updated
A piece of me dried up
Shrivelled away
like early rose buds.
Claret ears caught napping
by late spring frosts.
they say old soldiers do that
I will not miss it.
Ignore now the whining
of headmistress voices
that burrowed through walls.
Extracted drops of golden
Elixir de Compassion
from my hard heart.
Stolen by capricious thieves.
Taken under false pretences
to claim as their own.
Bits of me have died before.
Layers of love’s cat-like lives
flaking and falling away
leaving onion tears that quickly dry.
Few go though life never losing one.
Some have every layer torn free
by others’ weaknesses
or their own.
leaving them as brittle fallen leaves.
Most shed sadness a few times
embracing the fresh flesh beneath
and die with unused layers.
Such is love.
I have layers left.
And I plan to use them wisely.
others weaknesses,
do you need an apostrophe here?
maybe cut a few adjectives here and there and don’t touch the last line and the penultimate.
Thanks Nic
I will follow your advice already just thinking about removing ands it look better
Not sure about the apostrophe
i put it in as an after thought
I’ll probably remove it when I do the editing
Much appreciated comment xx
I think it looks better now. Checked out the apostrophe it’s in the right place now.
Thanks again, Nic
you’re welcome
Love’s cat-like multiple lives.
Cat-like Love’s lives.
just another suggestion and you perhaps need to explain a bit the soldier part, I thought it was about soldiers taking a nap while snowing and dying from hypothermia.
Thanks Nic
I think this needs a total revamp. The soldier seems out of place after I moved it from the third to fifth line. That didn’t work. He may have to go.
I explained it in a little more detail to BHI (below) I hope this clarifies why I confused things
keep it here I want to see what you did but I also think that a poet like you, a good one, should try to write more blocky style at least in drafts, this helps a lot to avoid anything unnecessary, in general long sentences/lines suddenly in any poem do not have a good effect or as good as the poet thinks. one must bear in mind that a reader is used to the layout being as careful as possible. you have three lines as I see right now that are too long. you either follow their canon or arrange it according to Leaving onion tears that quickly dry. you set a rule, no line must be longer than this one. In my opinion always this is a beautiful poem with great potential and you can edit it to perfection.
Good advice!
I have replaced the soldier line to 3 where it was originally. I think it makes sense now even though it’s still clunky. I added brackets so it’s like an afterthought.
However, there is more to do. Shortening or splitting the long lines will be necessary as you said.
I’ve updated it. I’m curious to know if the changes work.
well apart from what I think it is a typo )1st line(
it is the best version I’ve read so far, smooth and with style!
Thanks Nic
Typo fixed and changed also
It is much better but I am not satisfied but it needs almost a complete re write I think
I’m going to think about that
A piece of me has dried up;
shrivelled away
like early rose buds.
Claret ears caught napping
by late spring frosts.
they say old soldiers do that
I will not miss it.
Ignore now the whining
of headmistress voices
that burrowed through walls,
extracting drops of golden
Elixir de Compassion
from my hard heart,
stolen capriciously,
taken under false pretences
to claim as their own.
Bits of me have died before.
Layers of love’s cat-like lives
flaking and falling away
leaving onion tears that quickly dry.
Few go though life without losing one.
Some have every layer torn free
by others’ weaknesses
or their own,
leaving them as brittle fallen leaves.
Most shed sadness a few times
embracing the fresh flesh beneath
and die with unused layers.
Such is love.
I have layers left.
And I plan to use them wisely.
it’s a great poem, you definitely have gold here, sorry for my little edit.
Thanks Nic
I like your edits and I will make the changes you suggested
Thanks again x
This is a strange one, G. I wasn’t sure where you were going with this until you got to the second part, but then it did not seem to follow what you had written in the first. Also I did not get the “soldier” bit; do they shrivel away, are they caught napping? This maybe just my lack of background here. The “layers” and the “onion” is a clever device, but too forced and obvious in this context . I would try for more subtlety in conveying the passage between one love and another.
“Some have every life torn free by others’ weaknesses” – are those lives freed or are they “taken away”?
Sorry, my editorial mode went into overdrive here.
bhi
Hi B
This is not very good I must admit. I wrote it a long time ago and I think I put the words down as they came into my head. Clearly this needs a total revamp.
The first half is about caring and helping people with their problems and then having it thrown in your face later (or something like that. People can be cruel without meaning to be)
The second of course is about the toll love takes on us particularly when things go wrong.
I think I will have to remove the soldier bit. In the original was after the second line–
A piece of me dried-up the other day.
Shrivelled away.
Old soldiers are said to do that.
Like claret ears of too-early rose buds…
I moved it because it didn’t seem to follow but this confused things.
I’m going to go over the whole thing today if I get time between dog walks
G
This is now gold.
Thanks B. You and Nic were a big help
Guaj, people either appreciate others reaching out or they don’t. Last two lines are great. We should all use ours wisely.
Very perceptive CW you exactly ‘got’ this poem. Thanks
After all the sensible comments and changes, what could I add? Just that it followed on from the other love poem – thanks for this.
Thanks D