We all take criticism of our work in different ways. Sometimes we thank the critic and sometimes we are cut to the quick by brutal honesty.
If I say your poetry’s great
Please don’t reciprocate
Just say what you think
It won’t cause a stink
I will not shout or berate
If you find my wit makes you weary
If you think my poems are dreary
If my purple prose
Gets right up your nose
Then say so no need to be leery
An honest opinion’s worth much
Though it feels like a kick in the crotch
If given false praise
I’ll ne’re mend my ways
And be lost and way out of touch
Then next time we meet out on the street
Say hi and ask how it goes
In answer to that
I’ll call you a twat
And punch you right on the nose
(Yes I know the last stanza is imperfect. I have to leave something for the critics!) 🙂
Regarding critiques; one has to be aware of the motivations for criticism. Some are genuinely trying to help iron out a wrinkle here or there in one’s work and others are more intent on boosting their ego at the expense of the writer whose work they are criticising.
I have a few mentors whom I trust, they offer dispassionate advice that is welcome and helpful. Most, unfortunately are not so well motivated but seem to derive perverse pleasure from lording it. But hey ho 🙂
“Most, unfortunately are not so well motivated”…
Shut up. Seriously. Shut the fuck up. If you think that most people are doing that, then fuck off away from the site.
What on earth are you going on about? This was listed in comedy. I do not appreciate foul language. May I suggest you take your own advice and go away?
Pronto, this was not intended for you, but for CoolH, with whom Mac has an ongoing feud, sadly. Personally, I liked your pome, made me smile 🙂
Mac, do please try to temper your…er…temper and keep these outbursts in private messages, where they belong. It’s really not fair to post comments like that on someone’s sub. If you have a prob with CH, please can’t you confine yourself to PM’s?
But he just comes on here and whinges about other members who haven’t actually done anything wrong. The only time he ever comments on other people’s work at all is like here for example, where he uses Tony’s poem as an excuse to whinge about nothing at all. The man’s an arsehole.
Yup Cool it was written as a tongue -in-cheek piece and has clearly been misunderstood by some. but, as you say, hey Ho! 😉
I don’t think anyone’s misunderstood the poem, Tony. The point is that Coolhermit has used your poem simply as an excuse to whinge about people who haven’t done anything wrong. It’s not the first time he’s done this. And that’s the only reason he’s commented on your work in the first place, because he doesn’t normally comment on other people’s work at all.
I don’t mean to go on about it, but he talks such pompous shite and has no interest in anyone’s work but his own. I won’t let him get away with it.
OK I understand now ArchiemacI didn’t before. I was a bit shocked at the language used that’s all. I think now the least said the soonest mended. Peace.
There is a lot of truth in your poem, Tony, and it is a pity that it has been used as a punching bag by two opponents who it has now become clear weren’t really responding to your message which is quite clear.
Also, many authors whose work has been praised feel obliged to return the compliment and so the flattery goes on.
As for personal feuds, they unfortunately exist; I have been ostracised by one person for a remark I made, in a PM I may add, which IMO was misunderstood. The result is that we both ignore each other’s contributions.
But as the saying goes: hey Ho!
Hi Ionicus,
Such is life mate I misunderstood, too, so I bear some blame. I prefer to draw a veil. I will certainly not be ostracising anyone over it though. Life’s too short for such crap!
Keep ’em coming mate. 🙂