Any moment might be our last. Everything is more beautiful because we’re doomed. You will never be lovelier than you are now.
Homer, The Iliad
Edit by Nicoletta Poulakida, ‘il miglior fabbro’
(Notes at end of poem)
I
Uproot the dead for they define the future,
Crucible of the present has this extension:
Spirit housed in a carnal instrument,
Great Achilles hidden in a community of women,
Dressed as a compliant girl at his mother’s behest,
The fate of a minor goddess narrowly avoided,
Yet Amazonian Penthesilea lived, fought, strove till death;
She merges with all who are indomitable,
Mixing past with present, present with future time.
Conscripted by fate to restore the bridal state,
Achilles, in double-breasted mail, wields a perfect blade,
Cuts flesh from its woven nerve and bone;
Mortal wounds sundering the expanse of hope.
An exalted, plebian army mounted,
Spies confer on how to animate the mission:
Hang all traitors in the court of last resort,
A brief no level of argument can reverse,
Kings folded into the void of martial judgement,
Kneeling sisters of mercy unnoticed, unheard, untouched.
No diversion alters the animal imperative,
Achilles’ blade derives meaning in death,
Guides purpose to its transcendent throne;
Blade of procreation rests for a separate trial,
Errant pleasure to replace the mortal realm:
A wound that will not heal till love unravels,
A delicate clasp that upholds the domestic knot,
Lives in time’s storm over the mortal form.
II
Conquest turns to ownership of the body politic:
Obsequious courtiers adjust all necessary documents;
Writs that uphold the transfer of power,
Conflicts expeditiously resolved,
Analysis a preoccupation of bloodless times.
Warrior has one concern in life’s kingdom,
Achilles reveals nothing that betrays force,
Would not allow the will a testament of ambivalence,
Nor retreat to thwarted desire projected on his unwed state.
Tidal powers reign over his expediency,
Lust one more spoil of war:
Life a series of aggrandizements,
What can be known of no heart-rending consequence,
Jostling of armor, tearing of flesh, gloriae in bello self-explanatory.
Half-immortal in a human shell,
Even this gift fraught with despair:
What voyage lies on the other side,
Unwinds blind-sided by the still unknown?
Achilles will die in an epic’s shadow,
What’s left untold folds in a startling light.
Honour deeper than blood defines destiny:
Patriarchy shadows the known globe.
Memory forged in deprivation,
Mental gravity distorts perception:
Flattening the crescent mind,
Two-dimensional portraits abound.
No one steps free of their life alive.
III
Horses and airborne weapons fly,
Amazons occupy the queendom of sisterhood,
No thought of domestic servitude;
Troy’s skyline a monstrous façade,
Achilles petulant when rebuked,
Friendship the core of the mortal reactor:
Trust enlarges human scope,
Allegiance squares human design,
Sex so anticlimactic if faith reveals.
Linked in pursuit of human goals,
Transfigured in radiant alliance.
Returning home radiates adventure,
More lessons delivered as if reborn:
Taught, re-taught the spooling narrative;
The dead overrule the present as if alive,
Another myth to secure the multitude,
More beliefs framed in the gallery of the sacred,
Experienced in the furnace of trembling needs.
How else can displacement thrive?
Warriors have long left the arid plains;
Fear hosts the last supper of legal bonds,
Chiseled into a world few would do without.
Achilles has no presence in vast, calculated terms,
Amazon and Centaur flee as inspiration burns,
The present hazes over the dead’s return:
Armies of ghosts approaching citadels,
What Achilles and his decorated shield left untold.
gloriae in bello glory in war
In Greek mythology, Achilles was a Greek hero of the Trojan War and the central character and greatest warrior of Homer’s Iliad. His mother was the immortal nymph, Thetis, and his father, the mortal Peleus, was the king of the Myrmidons. Post-Homeric sources claim that in order to keep Achilles safe from the war, Thetis hides the young man at the court of Lycomedes, king of Skyros. Achilles is disguised as a girl and lives among Lycomedes’ daughters. While visiting the court of Lycomedes in search of Achilles, Odysseus sees through his disguise and convinces him to join the Greek campaign at Troy. At the beginning of the Iliad, Achilles leaves the field of battle following a dispute with Agamemnon, the Greek leader, over possession of a female slave. Achilles urges one of his closest friends, Patroclus, to fight in his place. Patroclus dons Achilles’s armor–except for his ash spear, which only Achilles can wield–and goes into battle as a direct substitute for Achilles. Thinking he is Achilles, the great warrior Hector kills Patroclus. Upon word of the death of Patroclus, Achilles finally agrees to fight with the Greeks. As the story goes, an enraged Achilles puts on the armor and kills Hector–significantly with the ash spear–directly outside of the gates of Troy, and then dishonors Hector’s body by dragging it around tied to the back of a chariot for nine consecutive days. In later accounts, he is said to have also faced and killed Penthesilea, a queen of the Amazons, who wins his heart in death.
Read 30 comments →
◆
some say the name means “he who brings pain and misery to the people (of a city /state /region)”
i’ll read again. (from what I know it was his mother that hid him at that court not Peleus)
It’s the terrible ambivalence we experience toward the playing out of the human will that interests me. Thanks for reading such a long piece. (Edit)
wrong hero then. i never felt Achilles was ambivalent about anything. he knew what he wanted. others tried to protect him Peleus his mother. what is interesting is the patroklos centaur part of his life. that’s the juice of his lifestory
I meant to say the ambivalence of our perspective on the human will in action rather than his attitude toward himself. Lack of clarity on my part.
the fact is that we have the best of Centaurs (superlative) upbringing Achilles and probably his little friend Patroklos, Chiron. amazons and centaurs represent female and male, at war. war of the sexes. we have Achilles dressed as girl to avoid war because his mother foresaw his death. these are the main ingredients of our perspective not kings or military men not cities to be conquered. the root is the psychological aspect of a war between the sexes. the transition from epos Iliad to epos Odyssey, the male epos and the female. overall the dead have nothing to do with it.
because they never died.
Achilles died. or not? is he dead? nobody is dead. we are all in Hades. we should not be calling each other dead it’s impolite.
The death I’m thinking of is the death of cultural history due to neglect i.e. these entities are vivid presences even now unless we allow them to die in our lives by not reading and learning and reflecting on these foundation myths. It’s the ambivalence I feel toward these figures that I find intriguing. The Odyssey is a massive poetic “machine” of the highest order which I wouldn’t dare go near in a poem. And for sure, “they never died” for the fortunate.
there is absolutely nothing to learn from Achilles. useless ****** he was. even Chiron failed.
correction: we have a lot to learn from the tragic fate of Achilles but we cannot learn anything about a true warrior he was someone who could not control his temper. he was a hedonist protecting the secret that kept him invincible to win win win and fornicate ever after. he is an anti-hero.
who failed? apart from his parents his tutor Chiron also failed. was it their fault or was he just a bad apple
if there is a worm in the apple no matter what you do it is spoiled. he was spoiled by his mother had a mortal father /the worm
what was she thinking? why would the fates allow someone that immature to remain alive? that’s no ‘justice’ no he should die and have the chance to become a mature soul.
hmm
i edited my reply above.
yeah.
Everything is more beautiful because we’re doomed.
doomed as dead that cannot die indeed. the can only live as dead.
as Sophocles said “the luckiest are the Unborn, second best in luck are those who die young” bad translation sorry but it will give you an idea.
Achilles is the biggest fail of a nanny Centaur.
That may be, but the question for me is to what degree does he represent the reality of the “warrior” or dare I add, “the man of action” however compelling such a figure might be.
handsome yeah, not that bright, big ego, a narcissist, proving he is invincible with all the tricks his mother did. her precious son.
Ector was better than him in so many ways. the human warrior without immortal tricks. not supernatural.
i trolled your comments right? sorry. i try anything to make people wonder
wtf did they teach us?
I think the poem has more or less that position. It exhibits cruelty to a high degree. The way Hector’s father got to him is quite telling.
dear Ross
it was his mother that had great expectations for her son and he was mommy’s boy. do we see other warriors whose mothers followed them to Troy? i don’t recall anything**
this obsession of a female for her male child
this is the root of the war of the sexes that even Chiron cannot make right the best of the Centaurs. what did she do? she took her son from the biggest Centaur to dress him as a girl? mother in laws in modern days. and mommy’s boys.
etc etc
here is one of the prophecies
Another prophecy was that Achilles would not die until Hector died. Hector was the older brother of Paris and the second greatest warrior after Achilles. There was no one who could kill Hector but Achilles. Achilles knew about this prophecy and for 9 years of the Trojan War, he dragged his feet. He was invincible in war but did not kill Hector. Then in the 10th year of the war, Hector mistook Achilles’ best friend Patroclus as Achilles and killed him. Patroclus was wearing Achilles’ armour and nobody recognized him. It wasn’t really Hector’s fault but it was destiny.
here is more from Quora
Achilles could not decide. His mother, Thetis kidnapped him and disguised him as a girl and gave him to the King of Scyros to foster. The King of Scyros had a daughter Deidamia who kept the girls fostered with them as dancing girls. Achilles being as graceful as ever, fit in easily as a dancing girl. Thetis married Achilles to Deidamia in secret and Deidamia conceived a child named Neoptolemus (or New War.) However, Achilles was discovered in this disguise by the clever Odysseus who had come with Diomedes to Scyros. He was told that the reason his mother hid him Scyros was that it was prophesied that if Achilles went to the Trojan war, he would not return alive. Thetis was terrified of this fate for her son. However, the prophecy also said that the Trojan War would be the only vehicle through which Achilles could live his destiny
** she certainly was monitoring her son all the way to his death. trying this and that but nothing worked. i am currently investigating Thetis. to be more precise***.
the world needs poems and discussions such as this.
bold spirits matter.
*** indeed they meet in Troy 358 verse in Greek text she appears –
that’s the only thing we can learn from this useless dude
that mothers must never be control freaks of their sons lives or destinies.
check this and think
When Themis (goddess of Justice), however, revealed that Thetis was destined to bear a son who would be mightier than his father, the two gods gave her to Peleus, king of the Myrmidons of Thessaly. Thetis, unwilling to wed a mortal, resisted Peleus’s advances by changing herself into various shapes. But, assisted by the wise centaur Chiron, Peleus finally captured her.
Justice Reveals Thetis etc
then
Chiron assists
Chiron up-brings
mortal male captures a goddess goddess refuses to believe she will eventually mourn for her child.
it’s deeper Ross.
So, start writing. (“Useless dude”….hilarious)
things to take into account.
Homer gives a detailed description of the imagery which decorates the new shield. Starting from the shield’s centre and moving outward, circle layer by circle layer, the shield is laid out as follows:
The Earth, sky and sea, the sun, the moon and the constellations (484–89)
“Two beautiful cities full of people”: in one a wedding and a law case are taking place (490–508); the other city is besieged by one feuding army and the shield shows an ambush and a battle (509–40).
A field being ploughed for the third time (541–49).
A king’s estate where the harvest is being reaped (550–60).
A vineyard with grape pickers (561–72).
A “herd of straight-horned cattle”; the lead bull has been attacked by a pair of savage lions which the herdsmen and their dogs are trying to beat off (573–86).
A picture of a sheep farm (587–89).
A dancing-floor where young men and women are dancing (590–606).
The great stream of Ocean (607–609).[5]
The Shield of Achilles can be read in a variety of different ways. One interpretation is that the shield represents a microcosm of civilization, in which all aspects of life are shown. The depiction of law suggests the existence of social order within one city, while feuding armies depict a darker side of humanity. The imagery of nature and the universe also reinforce the belief that the shield is a microcosm of Greek life, as it can be seen as a reflection of their perception of the world. Also, the sun and the moon are shown shining simultaneously, which some consider representative of a general understanding of the universe and awareness to the cosmological order of life [6] and as such, its akin to a mandala of antiquity.
for now i cannot find Thetis in Troy. update indeed she appears in Troy. verses 358 – 431
That is an absolutely beautiful use of the shield. I only remember it from Auden’s poem ‘The Shield of Achilles’ in which he contrasts the shield with the depraved world of the English slums.
so why would mommy’s boy a coward driven by sexual instinct afraid of death
dragging his feet carry this shield? he wasn’t the best specimen of humanity not even with all the ambrosia on his body
i mean Hector was indeed worthy of such a shield. yet Achilles (the one who brings pain and misery to people a mommy’s boy who has no self-control) is the one who does own it
did Homer actually try to say something not to us but to Gods?
“Did Homer actually try to say something not to us but to Gods?” Wow! I love that.
some claim here that Homer is in Tartarus because he revealed everything to humans.
read https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Myth_of_Er.
I know these points except for the fathering of a child by Deidamia. Your interpretation of male “castration” is very informative. That’s the sort of thing my professor would talk about. You would really have enjoyed talking to him. He was brilliant.
and who did he try for nine years not to kill
In Greek, Héktōr is a derivative of the verb ἔχειν, ékhein, archaic form *ἕχειν, hékhein (‘to have’ or ‘to hold’), from Proto-Indo-European *seĝh- (‘to hold’).[4] Héktōr, or Éktōr as found in Aeolic poetry, is also an epithet of Zeus in his capacity as ‘he who holds [everything together]’. Hector’s name could thus be taken to mean ‘holding fast’.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meander_(art)
if his father hadn’t learned the secret from Chiron how to hold Thetis
how to hold her fast he would never have been born.
a very tragic mommy’s boy surely he must have known more maybe i should be more lenient
i mean his mother made him a narcissist
try walking in Achilles sandals.
and here one can catch the whiff of Odyssey
Returning home radiates adventure,
More lessons delivered as if reborn:
thanks for mentioning me and I hope you read it to Dominique and she also thought it was a good edit (which you made better with your own voice).
cheers!
I’ll try to read it to her. The role of history, the dichotomy of human nature and the ambiguity of motive are my themes. You were able to help me focus these themes in regard to Achilles. Thank you, Ross.
Made another edit of the poem and the explanatory note.
yes you’ve been editing i am not sure that Achilles would be happy with all those nines now, although i cannot see a better way to divide the poem in equal parts and it’s still too long for one part only. what would you do if you had to produce 20 lines for Achilles? what would you cut?
I like the ironic aspect of the 3 multiple which brings to mind:
The Babylonian starlight brought
A fabulous, formless darkness in;
Odour of blood when Christ was slain
Made all platonic tolerance vain
And vain all Doric discipline.
WBY
i suspected that