The One Reality
If I could see the same gold
in a bangle or in a necklace,
what prevents me from seeing
the one reality in all its grace?
Perhaps the mind and body
cannot trace the path through silence.
If I mistook a rope for a snake
but, through knowledge, came to know
that there had never been
a reptile to fear,
what prevents me from seeing
reality as it truly is?
Perhaps the mind and body
have yet to learn to be at ease.
If I could see the same water
in the ocean, in the waves, and
in the clouds,
I could see Brahman in a crowd
and recognise it instantly.
The waves may subside,
the clouds may disperse,
but I remain limitless—
the one, indivisible Self.
Like every other discipline,
this, too, requires practice;
this, too, requires mastery,
this too, needs faith, and bravery.
For some of us, believing is seeing, and not the other way round. I enjoyed this personalized take on the Advaita Vedanta. It appealed to my philosophical bent. Well written, supratik.
(If I may make a very minor suggestion for your consideration: in the very last line, perhaps add the conjunction ‘and’ before the word ‘bravery’, to give it a little more punch in keeping with the faith required to see the world through the eyes of your excellent poem.)
I will respond soon. Thank you.
I wasn’t able to edit the reply. So increasing the number of comments. Not my intention.
Thank you, Shywolf for your thoughtful response and for the suggestion. I agree that adding “and” before “bravery” might lend the final line greater emphasis.
As for believing being seeing, I would gently argue that Advaita Vedanta invites us to go beyond both belief and perception. Belief may shape what we see, but Advaita asks us to question the very identity of the one who sees. It does not ask us to accept a metaphysical truth merely on faith; rather, it encourages inquiry, discrimination, and direct realisation. Multiple things we see are not true, e.g. the blue of the sky, the mirage in a desert, the horizon, the sun rising and setting. Advaita Vedanta takes us from the outside to the inside. Nowhere does it talk about theory. It is based on reasoning.
The central insight of Advaita is that the apparent separation between the individual self and the ultimate reality, Brahman, arises from ignorance of our true nature. We tend to identify ourselves with the body and mind, overlooking the consciousness in which all our experiences arise. The journey is not so much about believing in oneness as it is about recognising what has always been one.
Of course, this is a philosophical position, not an empirically established conclusion, and other schools of thought interpret the relationship between the self and ultimate reality differently. But what I find compelling about Advaita is that it asks us not to believe blindly, but to investigate deeply—to move from intellectual understanding to direct insight.
Perhaps, then, the real courage lies in questioning the assumptions through which we see the world, and the bravery in discovering that the truth may be far closer to us than we ever imagined.
A deeply philosophical poem, neatly written, that seems to suggests anxiety about not being able to comprehend the ultimate reality of the universe, but I may be wrong as I am not familiar with Hindi religion and philosophy.
Kind regards.
Thank you, Luigi for reading and commenting. I am glad you liked it.
Your poem Subratik is deeply contemplative reflection on the universal and very human struggle to experience oneness. Formal philosophy might dissect the technicalities of the metaphors, the emotional core; especially the insight that the mind and body must “learn to be at ease” is incredibly profound and relatable. It is a solid piece of personal art.
My one contention: Blending the Gold ornament metaphor with the Rope-Snake metaphor as if they work the same way. In traditional Indian philosophy, they represent entirely different levels of manifestation.
10/10 on this read, irrelevant of my contention.
Kevin.
Thank you, Kevin for such a thoughtful reading of the poem and for raising a philosophical objection that deserves more than a passing response.
I understand your contention about the gold-and-ornament metaphor and the rope-and-snake metaphor. They do operate differently in Advaita Vedanta. The gold and its ornaments illustrate the relationship between substance and name-and-form (nāma-rūpa): the necklace, bangle, and ring are distinguishable in appearance and function, yet none possesses an independent substance apart from gold. The rope and the snake, on the other hand, illustrate adhyāsa—superimposition—whereby something is mistaken for something else under conditions of ignorance. The snake is not a transformation of the rope; it is an erroneous perception of what is actually there.
Yet I wonder whether their difference necessarily makes their juxtaposition philosophically untenable. Perhaps the two metaphors illuminate different dimensions of the same fundamental inquiry: what is real in itself, and what is attributed to it by the mind?
The gold metaphor invites us to look through multiplicity towards the underlying reality. The rope-snake metaphor asks us to question the very validity of our perception of multiplicity. One examines the relationship between an underlying reality and its apparent forms; the other exposes the error through which the mind mistakes appearance for reality. They are not identical illustrations, but their distinct functions may complement one another.
From the standpoint of Advaita, Brahman is not merely the material out of which the universe is fashioned, as gold is fashioned into ornaments. Nor is the universe simply a mistaken perception in precisely the same sense that the snake is a mistaken perception of the rope. The analogy has its limits. Advaita speaks of māyā and avidyā to account for the appearance of plurality without granting it an independent, ultimate reality. The world is experienced, and its practical reality cannot simply be dismissed; what is denied is its independent existence apart from Brahman.
This distinction matters to my poem because I am not attempting to construct a formal philosophical argument in which every metaphor corresponds to a single technical category. I am using these images as invitations to introspection. When I ask why I cannot recognise the same Brahman in you that I recognise in myself, I am not suggesting that another person is an illusion in the ordinary sense. I am questioning the consciousness that turns difference into absolute separation.
Perhaps the deepest obstacle to oneness is not the existence of distinctions, but our tendency to mistake distinctions for ultimate divisions. A bangle is not a necklace; a rope is not a snake. At the level of appearance, these differences matter. But the philosophical question is whether what appears different must therefore be ultimately separate, and whether the mind, conditioned by names, forms, and identities, can apprehend a reality that is not confined by them.
And this brings me back to the line you so perceptively appreciated: the mind and body must “learn to be at ease.” For me, this is not an incidental emotional observation. It is central to the inquiry. The intellect may understand non-duality, but the embodied self continues to react through fear, desire, attachment, and the instinct to defend its boundaries. To understand oneness conceptually is one thing; to cease experiencing oneself as fundamentally isolated is another. The former is an insight of the intellect; the latter requires a deeper transformation of understanding.
I therefore accept the distinction you draw between the metaphors, while remaining open to the possibility that their juxtaposition can serve a poetic purpose beyond their individual technical meanings. Philosophy asks us to make distinctions with precision; poetry sometimes brings distinct ideas into conversation to illuminate a truth that neither image, taken alone, fully conveys.
Thank you again for engaging with the poem at both levels. Your contention has helped clarify something important to me: the aim is not to erase the difference between appearance and reality, but to understand what kind of reality difference possesses. That, I believe, is one of the enduring questions at the heart of Advaita Vedanta.
Wow, a 10/10! Humbled.
Supratik