The alehouse stood low beneath a roof of reed and blackened straw, with smoke creeping ever beneath the rafters, for the hole above the hearth drew ill that night. Rain beat softly against the shutters, and from without came now and again the sucking sound of a horse’s hoof in the mire.
We sat about the board nearest the fire: Wat the miller, Hugh atte Brook, old Maud Bell, and Father Anselm, who had come, he said, but to warm his hands.
I believed him not.
The ale-wife set before us a black loaf, onions roasted in their skins, and a little dish of salt. Her ale was thick and brown, newly brewed and somewhat sour, yet none complained.
Wat drank deep and wiped his mouth upon his sleeve.
“Three nights,” quoth he.
No man answered.
He looked about the board.
“Three nights since Hob Carter went into the wood. And this morn he cometh again, with neither cloak nor shoon upon him, and asketh why his wife weepeth.”
Hugh gave a little laugh, though there was no mirth in it.
“Mayhap he lay drunk beneath an hedge.”
“For three days?”
“Men have done worse.”
“Not in frost.”
At that old Maud lifted her head.
She was a small woman, bent nearly double, with skin brown and wrinkled as a winter apple.
“Frost toucheth not all that walketh abroad o’ nights.”
Father Anselm’s cup struck hard upon the board.
“Hold thy tongue, wife.”
Maud looked at him.
“I have held it these seventy year, father, when priest or lord bade me. ‘Tis a wonder it hath not rotted in my mouth.”
Wat laughed then, but softly.
The priest crossed himself.
“Thou speakest of things thou understandest not.”
“Nay,” said she. “I speak of that which thy books have taught thee to forget.”
A log brake in the hearth. Sparks rose among the smoke.
I said, “Hob hath been questioned.”
All turned toward me.
“What saith he?” Hugh asked.
“He knoweth not where he hath been.”
Wat leaned closer.
“That is not what my Joan heard.”
“Thy Joan heareth much.”
“And most of it true.”
I drank before answering.
“Hob saith he followed a light amongst the trees. Thereafter he remembereth a horn.”
At this Maud made a small sound in her throat.
Father Anselm heard it.
“What?”
“Naught.”
“What horn?”
She looked into the fire.
“A long horn.”
Wat ceased smiling.
The rain seemed louder against the shutters.
I said, “He spake of no such thing.”
“Aye, he did,” said Maud. “Though mayhap not unto thee.”
I felt anger then, for I had spent the day hearing whispers cease whenever I entered a house.
“What else hath he said?”
Maud’s eyes came slowly to mine.
“That riders passed him.”
Hugh muttered, “Jesu.”
Father Anselm said sharply, “No man shall name Jesu’s blessed name in fellowship with such foolery.”
Maud paid him no heed.
“Riders,” she said again. “Many riders. More than he might number.”
Wat whispered, “The King’s men?”
“Nay.”
“Welshmen?”
“Nay.”
“Then whose men?”
Maud took her cup between both hands.
“No man’s.”
For a while there was only the crackle of the hearth.
Then Hugh laughed.
“Herla.”
The word changed the room.
Even the ale-wife, who had been scraping a pot near the hearth, stopped her hand.
Father Anselm rose half from his stool.
“Enough.”
Hugh stared at him.
“I but named an old tale.”
“Then let old tales lie.”
Maud smiled without showing her teeth.
“They lie till men wake them.”
The priest’s face reddened.
“There is no King Herla. No host of dead men rideth these woods. Such things are snares of the Fiend, made to turn simple folk from God.”
“Then thou believest there was something?” Wat asked.
Father Anselm looked upon him fiercely.
“I said no such thing.”
“But if it be the Fiend—”
“I said enough.”
I set down my cup.
“Hob saw a man amongst them.”
No one moved.
I wished then I had not spoken.
Maud said, “Whom?”
I looked toward the fire.
“My brother.”
Wat breathed out slowly.
Father Anselm stared at me.
“Thy brother hath been dead these twenty year.”
“So men say.”
“Thou thyself hast said it.”
“Aye.”
Maud’s gaze did not leave me.
“Did Hob know him?”
“No.”
“Then how knew he his face?”
I had no answer.
Outside, somewhere beyond the alehouse wall, a horse whinnied.
Every man at the board turned his head.
Then came another sound.
Far off.
So faint I thought at first it was the wind moving in the chimney.
A single note.
Low and long.
A horn.
Wat’s cup slipped from his fingers and spilled ale across the board.
Father Anselm rose.
“God shield us.”
Old Maud did not stir.
“Nay,” she whispered.
Her eyes were fixed upon the shuttered window.
“Not God.”
The horn sounded again.
Nearer.
Good work,
You sold the scare before anyone names it. Horse first — ordinary. Then the horn, far off, then nearer. That’s the whole trick: the room already knows the difference between weather and a summons.
Anselm reaches for the familiar brand. Maud doesn’t. She’s the one who’s seen this product before. Wat dropping the cup is the receipt.
Reminds me of the horns people actually feared — not a hunter’s toot, not a kirk bell. The old Scottish gathering calls, and older still the carnyx: that upright bronze throat with a boar’s head the tribes used to make a field sound like it had grown a voice. Gauls, Britons, the north. Meant to unman you before the charge arrived. Priests named God. The old women named the other inventory.
KJS
Good work indeed! I was thoroughly engrossed in it.
This passage creates extraordinary tension through restraint, ambiguity, and carefully chosen details. It opens with the stark fragment, “My brother,” immediately creating curiosity, while “Wat breathed out slowly” conveys unease without explicitly naming it. The archaic dialogue—“Thy brother hath been dead these twenty year”—establishes the historical setting naturally, while “So men say” introduces the first disturbing uncertainty. The brief exchange that follows deepens the mystery: the speaker admits that he himself declared his brother dead, yet refuses to confirm that he is. The question, “Then how knew he his face?” becomes the passage’s central enigma, and “I had no answer” wisely leaves it unresolved.
The shift from dialogue to sound is particularly effective. The horse’s whinny initially appears ordinary, but “Then came another sound” prepares the reader for something unexplained. The fragments “Far off,” “A single note,” “Low and long,” and “A horn” slow the scene down, allowing suspense to accumulate almost imperceptibly. Wat’s cup slipping from his fingers provides a small but vivid physical manifestation of fear.
The contrast between Father Anselm’s “God shield us” and Maud’s whispered “Not God” is chilling. Her stillness and fixed gaze suggest recognition rather than surprise. Finally, “Nearer” is devastating in its simplicity: the unseen threat has moved closer, leaving the reader to imagine what is coming.
The denouement of this horror story is revealed in the preface, as KJS rightly observes. The tale of the Wild Hunt shares striking visual and thematic elements with the Horsemen of the Apocalypse, foretelling doom. Superstitious talk would have taken place in a tavern in Middle English; an attempt at which does not really work here, in my opinion. Nevertheless, a good try; Hob’s mention of seeing his dead brother seems to me a red herring.
Sup and Chaucer!
You’ve managed to put the story across without overloading the reader with eye-twisting archaic spellings and it held my interest.
Is this going to be a short story or something much longer, Art?
I love reading but I’m not sure I could manage lengthy tracts in a 1000 year-old style.