
A third one is seldom needed when two people meet again
through one of those rare coincidences
that life almost never repeats.
Yet he entered the compartment, sat down by the window,
and looked outside as though the passing world
belonged to him alone.
The train kept its own time,
as life does.
Without the third one
the man and the woman would have had much to say,
although no one knew whether the stranger by the window
was even listening.
Beyond the glass reddish poplars drifted by,
the turf-grey of alder bushes,
mirroring irreversibility.
The white flowering of blackthorn hedgerows
brightened the fields.
New seedlings rose from the dark earth.
Field paths wound gently across the hills,
leading towards heightened places,
towards a loveliness
resting in the silent growth of the land.
From time to time, patches of dark forest
crossed the window like sudden fears
in the face of chance.
Inside the compartment
time seemed unwilling to move.
Without the stranger they would have spoken.
Years of silence might have dissolved
into a single afternoon.
Instead, his silence entered before his words.
It settled quietly between them
until every sentence became hesitant,
and every thought returned to itself.
Only years later did the question remain.
Why did no one remember his face?
Was he young or old? Fair-haired or dark?
Or had he entered without ever belonging
to the journey at all?
There was something about him,
both familiar and strangely foreboding,
as though he carried the remembrance
of all that cannot be recovered.
The stranger, too, looked into the rushing spring;
into the flowering hedgerows, the new seedlings,
the winding paths, the fields disappearing
towards the horizon.
He seemed to watch in silence
not the landscape itself, but time
passing through it.
“Forty years ago today
it would have been his birthday,”
The man said at last, lifting his eyes
from the work he had carried with him.
And looked at her.
“Yes,” she answered softly,
because the third one was there.
Evening gathered against the window
Wisps of mist rose from the fields,
announcing the approaching night.
Their reflections grew fainter and fainter
until they themselves seemed little more
than passing shadows.
Perhaps another word might still have been spoken.
Perhaps the long separation might have found its answer.
But silence had already chosen
its place between them.
When the train reached its destination,
they rose, lifted their bags,
and stepped onto the platform.
Only two people
left the compartment.
This is a deeply atmospheric and psychologically resonant poem about coincidence, memory, loss, and the irreversible passage of time. Its greatest strength lies in the third figure, whose identity remains deliberately uncertain. He functions almost like a symbolic presence—perhaps memory, death, regret, or the lost person whose absence has shaped the relationship between the man and woman. The landscape is beautifully integrated with the emotional movement: the “reddish poplars,” “new seedlings,” flowering blackthorn, and dark forests become metaphors for renewal, fear, and irreversibility. The recurring contrast between movement outside and stillness within is particularly effective.
The revelation—“Forty years ago today / it would have been his birthday”—reframes everything that precedes it and creates a powerful emotional aftershock. The final image, “Only two people / left the compartment,” is haunting precisely because the stranger’s existence remains unresolved.
At times, the poem could be tightened by reducing repeated references to silence, time, and landscape. Nevertheless, its restraint, ambiguity, and cinematic quality make it highly compelling.
Best
Supratik
OMG!!! Yukta!
Firstly wonderful to see you back. This poem was incredibly atmospheric, thoroughly enjoyable to read but the ending!…
The ending brought me out in goosepimples. The accompanying picture was perfect.
If we get the option we once had of taking some poems into favourites, this will be first in the queue for me.
There was great skill in the way the train’s rhythm matched and intercepted the outdoor vista which mirrored the inner thoughts. I’m not sure if I am making sense but this is what came over for me. The mystery, the ordinariness, the unspoken words and thoughts, the emotions of all three.
A masterpiece in my opinion.
One I will read again and again.
fab!
Alison