From the UKAuthors Collection

Why?

By Elfstone · Originally published 8 November 2004

Last week's Workshop poem (because not all of you read in the Forums).

Why?

“She needs to see you”
my aunt said.
(Why? -
she won’t come to see me.)
I didn’t ask in the end,
I will find out soon enough,
- que sera, sera.

The phone call wandered
round my aunt’s garden
and mine,
our shared passion,
her shared knowledge.
Then there was that
intrusion,
that barb in the
gentle flow of words,
“She needs to see you”.

Always she intrudes,
always that discomfort,
always that bitter reminder,
always the thread pulled.
I am haunted by her;

Why?

© Elfstone 31/10/04

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

Emerald

Re: Why?

Hi Elfstone, I liked this poem, and how you conveyed to the reader, the two-edged guilt, that often accompanies family relationships. Just one point - in the first stanza I found the que sera sera bit slightly obscured the poem. Just my opinion, because I did actually find this poem enjoyable and interesting to read.

Emma:)

Bradene

Re: Why?

Fantastic poem Elf.. I think many will identify with this feeling too. We all have someone in our lives who seem to have this effect on us. Someone who intrudes whether it be physically or emotionally at the most inopportune moments.. I think you captured this beautifully. Love val x

Elfstone

Re: Why?

Thanks Val! You know there is a good old Scottish saying - "God gives us friends and the Devil gives us relatives" and I often think that is true :-) Many thanks for that 10 too. Elf.

Elfstone

Re: Why?

Emerald many thanks for reading this and leving a comment- I'm glad you enjoyed it. I take your point about "que sera,sera" but this was a workshop poem - and we were given a very challenging set of instructions: the poem had to contain:
1) A news item.
2) Something that happened to you this week.
3 Something you were told in conversation.
4) A line from a song.
- and also have in it: A question; A quote; Something (in brackets).
So 'que sera, sera' was the song line I chose - I thought it fitted in fairly well with that sense of inevitability in the poem. (I didn't manage to incorporate a news item - one thing too many!!) Thanks again for your interest. Elfstone.

Elfstone

Re: Why?

Dargo many thanks for that rating. Because you hadn't left a comment there was no e-mail notification, and I've been too busy to be in here much recently, so apologies if you thought I was ignoring you. It is much appreciated. Elfstone.

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…