From the UKAuthors Collection

In The Garden

By Kipper · Originally published 29 October 2004

A self explanitary appreciation of one of lifes pleasures.

Mary Mary heaven knows,
this is how our garden grows.
With forty shades of greens and hue,
and all the spectrum colours true.

There's flowers here that grow so tall,
and shrubs in pots of brown and green.
And then there's others sweet and small,
who wave their arms just to be seen.

Some crave the sun - and rain desire -
they dance and sway in heavenly breeze.
But some to shade and damp aspire,
yet quietly they try to please.

In summer's glare and winter's cold,
where else can we be nearer than.
In verdant spring and autumn's gold,
natures treasures and greater plan.

With butterflies and bees all humming,
and myriad insects all around.
And water down the cascade running,
to lift the soul with natures sound.

And if for you a greater being,
guides us through in glory's name.
No better place exists for seeing,
his work, his joy, each day the same.

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

MrBlueFace

Re: In The Garden

<b>Kipper, Hello. I’m brand new on here - this is my first crit on UKA... hope you find it helpful.

a Mary Mary heaven knows, (Mary, Mary)
a this is how our garden grows.
b With forty shades of greens and hue,
b and all the spectrum colours true.

a There's flowers here that grow so tall,
b and shrubs in pots of brown and green.
a And then there's others sweet and small,
b who wave their arms just to be seen. (Flowers don’t even have metaphorical arms, do they?)

a Some crave the sun - and rain desire -
b they dance and sway in heavenly breeze.
a But some to shade and damp aspire, (But is rather harsh - “though” maybe?)
b yet quietly they try to please. (Do flowers try to please - surely pathetic fallacy here?)

a In summer's glare and winter's cold,
b where else can we be nearer than.
a In verdant spring and autumn's gold, (the than lines needs to be third for this to make proper sense, I think)
b natures treasures and greater plan. (nature’s)

a With butterflies and bees all humming, (Butterflies don’t hum. Or do they?)
b and myriad insects all around.
a And water down the cascade running, (Best line in the poem methinks)
b to lift the soul with natures sound. (nature’s)

a And if for you a greater being,
b guides us through in glory's name. (If glory = God then Glory)
a No better place exists for seeing,
b his work, his joy, each day the same. (His work, His joy - use capitals for God)

I have outlined the a-b scheme of your verses... Now, I’m a chap who doesn’t really give a fig for rhyme schemes and poetry formats but if you are going to employ them I think you ought to be consistent. Verse 1 (stanza one to the purists) has a different scheme to all the other verses.

Your end-of-line punctuation is very good and does help one to read the poem.

Hope that is ok - Cheerio.

Regards, MBF.</b>

Kipper

Re: In The Garden

Hello MBF
Thank you for your crit. You clearly took some time with it, and you made a good point about the first verse. I am aware of it; indeed it its original form all the verses were as the first stanza. In effect they became rhyming couplets; not what I wanted, so I rearranged them to what you see now. Except that is for the first verse, which defied all attempts to convert. So I left it and hoped that no-one would notice. I should have known better. Not consistent as you say - but is consistency a yardstick that writers must always adhere to?
Thank you for commenting, but may I ask one thing? Did you like it? You didn't say, and in the end that's all that counts. (I think !)
Kipper

Kipper

Re: In The Garden

Hello again MBF
I intended to say that you made 'some' good points, but in explaining how V1 came about I forgot all the other points you made. Some were corrections and others were more to do with interpretation. I didn't agree with everything you said but there are some usefully points to ponder.
Thank you again for the time you spent on me. If you do that with everyone, you are going to have a busy time here on UKA.
May I close by welcoming you to the community.
Michael

MrBlueFace

Re: In The Garden

Michael, Hi

Good to meet you.

Thank you for your welcome; much appreciated.

I tend to choose only a few pieces to make a decent crit on, otherwise just a quick "good work". I know my pieces need decent crit so I try to help others. I don't have too much time so I can't do that with every piece I would wish to I'm afraid.

You say you don't agree with all my points. Of course not! It is your work - you keep/change what you will. I don't think I have ever agreed with all of anybody's crit on my work - but as long as it was helpful that is fine by me.

As regards your questions:

Thank you for commenting, but may I ask one thing? Did you like it? You didn't say, and in the end that's all that counts. (I think !)

Do I like it? Yes and no. I thought your writing needed to be a little less "sentimental" - e.g. the pathetic fallacy argument but, overall, I thought you composed the verses well.

However, as regards the subject... You have written a lyrical interpretation of a garden but, though I enjoy gardening itself, I am not really into such poems. Also, being a long-standing atheist and converting to some degree of anti-theism, I cannot share your last verse. However, I did like the way that (most unusually) the first line of that last verse left for some degree of movement.

Not consistent as you say - but is consistency a yardstick that writers must always adhere to?

Ah! Absolutely not; I agree. However, in the case of your poem the one different verse does look odd because of the tight formulation of all the verses (that included). If it were more changing or free verse, no problem but just one out of place looks rather strange I believe.

Thank you for your replies and best wishes.

James.

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…