From the UKAuthors Collection

Replays!!

By Elfstone · Originally published 1 October 2004

This may interest the sports fans among you. It was written as an Assignment for my writing course and therefore had to be in quite a calm style, but honestly there are times when I could fling bricks at the TV!!

Endless Replays! . . Replays! . . . Replays! . . . . . . . Replays!

Replays ad nauseam! Watching ‘live’ rugby games on television these days has become something of an endurance test and for once this is not just because of the poor quality of Scottish back play. It seems to me that, over recent years, the increasing tendency for outside broadcast editors to ‘play with the buttons’ during the game has reached the point where it is interfering seriously with the viewer’s enjoyment .

Five years ago I became sufficiently disgruntled with this state of affairs to write a letter to the BBC, explaining in reasonable terms just how annoying these interruptions were becoming. I received a very polite, but totally noncommittal, reply thanking me for my letter and assuring me that my comments would be passed on to the appropriate people. Now five years down the line, I find myself shouting at the television in utter frustration at so often not knowing what is happening on the pitch!

Convinced that these interruptions were becoming more frequent, and longer, I decided to do a bit of research. My findings are based on reviewing some recent Autumn’s games and comparing those results with older games. They do indeed confirm my suspicion that replays are taking over!

In recent games around 12% of the live game time has been taken up with replays; viewers ‘lose’ that time. Imagine going to Murrayfield and having your eyes forcibly closed for 12% of the time, at arbitrary moments decided on by someone else; would anyone find that acceptable? What is worse is that many of the items replayed were not in themselves particularly outstanding in terms of the result of the game or the quality of the rugby .

A detailed breakdown of the November 2001 game between Scotland and New Zealand makes this abundantly clear. There were only 3 tries in that game and yet no fewer than 36 replays! Viewers missed 10 min. 50 sec. of ‘live’ action! These statistics are borne out by a very similar situation in the delayed 6 Nations game between Ireland and England played in September 2001. I won’t quote the complete statistics; suffice it to say that there were 35 replays in the 80 or so minutes and that they totalled a whopping 11 min. 13 sec. of ‘lost’ time for the viewer, in what was a crucial game (England going for a Grand Slam). During that the viewer missed, amongst other things, 4 lineouts, the start of 2 scrums and no fewer than 7 penalty kicks, or parts thereof.

For comparison I went back some years to the oldest of my home-made videos: the Scotland/ France game in the 5 Nations in 92. The difference is striking; half the number of replays at 17, and only 3 min. 27 sec. of ‘lost’ time, almost a quarter of the replay time in current broadcasts.

Even more remarkable are the statistics from my ‘oldest’ video, the commercial recording of ‘that’ game between the Barbarians and the All Blacks at Cardiff Arms Park in 1973. There were six wonderful tries scored, in a game which is often described as the finest ever televised. Those six included the early try, finished by Gareth Edwards, which is regarded by many as one of the finest tries ever scored. Were we bombarded by replays? Look at the statistics: six tries, seven replays and only 2 min. 38 sec. ‘lost’ time! Each try, bar one, was replayed once, while the kicker set up the goal kick, so there was no interference at all with watching play. (It was the Gareth Edwards try which was given a second replay, but that, it seems, only because of an extended injury treatment break.) Watching this game, did I feel deprived in some way by the lack of replays? Did I feel that I was missing out on vital information or a better understanding of the game? Indeed not! It was a joy to watch an uninterrupted game!

Speaking personally, I enjoy watching set piece play; powerful play between well matched forwards is very exciting to watch. I do not want to miss a line out or scrum by being forced to watch a replay of a poor pass or turnover ball. I would not suggest for one moment that cameras should linger ghoulishly on the agonies of a badly injured player, but I would prefer to know who is injured and, if possible, to what extent, especially if it happens to be a crucial player for either us or the opposition. A middle distance shot with the right commentary would keep the viewers informed.

For most of the time during modern replays there is no way of knowing what is going on because, (and this compounds greatly the problems caused by those replays), commentators are now commentating on what is happening on the monitor rather than telling us what is happening on the pitch. Commentaries in a live game should keep the viewer informed at all times with regard to what is actually happening in the game at any given moment and that is no longer the case.

Looking back at that 1973 video made it very clear that a good, informed and informative commentary, coupled with good camera work, is all that is needed for the viewer to fully enjoy a televised game. There are occasions when a replay is justified, for instance a try can be shown again while the kicker sets up the goal attempt. Indeed in the case of doubtful tries a second showing from a different angle can be very worthwhile. However, for the majority of the replays we now have foisted upon us, the correct place is a review programme or the half time /full time slots.

Another source of irritation which became clear while doing my analysis for this article, (and perhaps an issue for separate research), was the amount of time wasted on lengthy shots of players’ faces, the faces of members of the management/coaching teams in the stand and faces of people in the crowd. None of these are important enough to be put in place of the action on the pitch. Add all of those in and viewers are losing a lot more than 12% of live game time.

Wholesale use of replays has become a source of huge frustration in recent years. It seems that O.B. editors are using the replay facility just because they have it, rather than because events in the game warrant it. For those of us who cannot, for whatever reason, travel to be at a game in person, ‘live’ television needs to be exactly that - ‘live’; in other words we should see what is happening on the pitch, at the time, all the time; if not, what we see is being dictated simply by the whim of the editor, or by the need to be seen to use the technology - very much a case of the tail wagging the dog . . the tail wagging the dog . . . the tail wagging the dog . . . .

© Elfstone 2002

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

ritawrites

Re: Replays!!

oh yeah, you telling me! sometimes I want to go and strangle the TV -- great stuff! :)

Elfstone

Re: Replays!!

rita, thank you so much for reading and leaving a comment. It is actually a subject which gets me very hot under the collar and it seems to get worse each season.
I thought this one wouldn't attract much interest, but I just wanted to test the water with it so to speak. I'm pleased that you found it worth reading. Elfstone.

Wrybod

Re: Replays!!

Elf'
'ooray, 'ooray, 'oo,bloody ray (I gave it 10) because it sums up my attitude completely

THEY ARE MORE CONCERNED WITH THE PRESENTATION THAN WHAT THEY ARE TRYING TO PRESENT.

My worst hate is so called "tension music" behind newsreaders. The man is saying...
"Seven marines were killed today when.......
and at the same time in the background.....
De dumm dumm dumm De dum dum dum De.....

I tend to stay with BBC to avoid advertisements but they are now just as bad with Trailers trailers trailers trailers trailers, the same ones over and over again

Thank manufacturers of sets for the mute button.

I could go on but feel that perhaps I'm hogging the reply space...........

Something for the forum perhaps?

bob

Elfstone

Re: Replays!!

Goodness Bob I thought this submission had disappeared off the edge!! It was so different from my usual thing that I didn't expect much interest and I was right. :-)) It is good to know that someone shares my views. We are just about into the Autumn Internationals (first one two weeks today against Australia) and I just know it will be as bad or worse. Many thanks for the 10 rating and taking time to read all of this. Elfstone.

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…