From the UKAuthors Collection
I am; am I?
By Elfstone · Originally published 5 July 2004
Written in one of my more introspective moments, I am aware that this is not a "comfortable" poem. I hope some of you may find something worthy in it.
I am; am I?
I have no reflection;
I am the image
Life’s mirrors spurn.
I am the isolated existence;
I have no anchors,
No binding force.
I am the empty life;
A husk of searching
Inside a shell of loss.
I am in stillness;
I live the silence that is
The absence of life.
I have no warmth;
I am that chill which is
The absence of feeling.
I am survival to no end,
That which continues
Aimless, unrelenting.
I am life without a point;
I have no direction;
I have no dimension.
I am un-noticed.
I am blighted.
I am desolate.
I am;
am I?
© Elfstone 28/4/04
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Re: I am; am I?
Mutual regards from myself to an ally, with a shared passion of what can never be proffered inside a Cartesian vacuum suggested as matrix. Now I might also suggest Bishop Berkley, but I suspect exposure been already!
When done philosopher!
Respect Jasper
Re: I am; am I?
You have described to me the actual way I feel a lot lately. It is uncomfortable It's also me......Erma
Re: I am; am I?
I think we all experience this kind of surreal feeling at times throughout our lives Elf, I like this, but I prefer your more atmospherical poetry, I enjoy the journeys of the Isles you often take us on.Love Val xx
Re: I am; am I?
Jasper many thanks for reading and commenting. Your phrase "inside a Cartesian vacuum suggested as matrix" has lost me I'm afraid (I'm not the brightest button in the box!) and I've never heard of Bishop Berkley. Nevertheless - I appreciate you taking the time to respond. Elfstone.
Re: I am; am I?
Erma thank you for commenting. I was aware that this poem was not 'easy reading'. I extend my sympathy if this does reflect your feelings. I can only hope that being aware that others feel very similar things at times will be of some comfort. I wish I could offer you more in terms of "there is a happy ending", but sadly that's beyond me. I sincerely hope that your situation improves soon. Elfstone.
Re: I am; am I?
Val, as ever my sincere thanks for reading and commenting. I realise that my "Scotland is beautiful" poetry (is that too trite?!?) is easier on the ear/eye/mind, but as I've said before I don't decide on a subject for a poem; it is just there in my mind all of a sudden. Writing this type can be therapeutic too which has to be a good thing I think.
(PS have you read my other submission today - 'Scotland' - it might be more to your liking.) Elfstone.
Re: I am; am I?
Trevor you have such insight. I'm sure that is why your own poetry is always of such a high standard and thought provoking in the best way.
"Even depression is better than meaninglessness feelings, being at least a relationship."
hmmm, I'm going to go away and chew that one over!! :-) My grateful thanks for your thoughts - as always very useful. Elfstone.
Re: I am; am I?
This is so honest it hurts...many people go there and come back...L x
Re: I am; am I?
Leila your comments have struck a chord with me: poetry is a way of saying things that I have never been able to say in conversation. Poetry is at times soul-searingly honest and I think that is probably why it can be so rewarding, draining, painful and exhilerating to write. Thanks for reading this and leaving a comment. Elfstone.
Re: I am; am I?
Hi Elfstone,
This is a truly honest write, brilliantly expressing that empty place that many, including myself, sometimes find ourselves,
regards
Mystic
Re: I am; am I?
Honest - yes I hope so and painful too - see my reply to Leila above.
Many thanks for commenting Mystic - your praise is touching. Elfstone.
Re: I am; am I?
Jasper I've just had an email from UKA telling me that you have made this a 'Hot Story'. Very many thanks - I am most chuffed! Elfstone.
Re: I am; am I?
I think it has all been said--many will relate to this sadly.
Gerry.
Re: I am; am I?
Hi elf. Yes, this is certainly introspective, but what the hell. Poetry is itself introspective, and writing is an act of introspection, and also an act of catharsis. Better out than in, as they say. here is a buddhist meditation which encourages people to reflect on all the connections that there are in one's life, how so many people are connected to each of us in so many ways, that we often don't appreciate. Then I do wonder about your choice of words 'no end' 'aimless' etc.I think, wquite hoinestly, so what? so what if life is, if everyone;s life is, to some extent, aimless? Why shouldn't it be? who says meaning is any great shakes? why are we conditoined to think it is? Woops, sorry, rambling. Meaning, I think, is what you create for yourself, simply by living your life. Anyway, you expressed in so few words the angst that is so often felt, thise introspective moments when we wonder why we're here, what it all means, etc etc. Perosnallly I just don't think those are questiions worth asking, worth spending time over; because it just makes for unhappiness, because there are no answers. I liked it, it was brutal in its honesty, full of feeling, and left an open ended question at the end. The answer to which is, I would think, no, you're not.
Re: I am; am I?
Thanks Gerry - I'm grateful to you for taking the time to comment. Elfstone.
Re: I am; am I?
I actually enjoy feeling this way on melancholic occasions, when life is shades of lavenders and greys and I need to slit open the phoney outer layer that I proffer to people all week long. Emptiness can be a good feeling, drifting aimlessly, heavy sigh, no end (except if it's laundry) can sometimes feel bigger and more wide open in my head than "deadlines" "goals" "projected aims". But more than this, I love the way you have shaped all these feelings into a poem that acts like a universal cry for the downtrodden and tired at heart. I got on your little rocket ship of woe and had an enjoyable flight, thank you!
Re: I am; am I?
Many thanks for this very interesting response skeeter. I had no idea that this was Buddhist in any way, but then I rarely have any idea what my poems are about while I'm writing them and even less idea how others will read them. It constantly astonishes me the way people here respond to what I have written.
As to your comment "Meaning, I think, is what you create for yourself, simply by living your life." I'm no good at discussing/arguing philosophy or metaphysics, but I think I disagree with that. Much of what we are, what we become, is dictated by other people who give is our life experiences, good or bad. So if you like, meaning is largely influenced by external factors over which we have no real control. Up-bringing plays an enormous part in that and we none of us have any choice in our up-bringing.
I'm not at all sure what your 'answer' to my 'question' means. Another way of putting the last line would be "I exist; do I exist?" Is your answer saying that I don't? Hmmmmmmm.
Anyway I am very grateful for you taking the time to post this. Elfstone
Re: I am; am I?
PS Skeeter. You might like to read my poem "In the Beginning" if you haven't already done. It is another view of lack of control, helplessness, malign external influences and the power of up-bringing. Elf.
Re: I am; am I?
Sabrina thanks very much for your response. I'm pleased that you enjoyed this poem and your interpretation of it is interesting. I understand completely what you say about the need for, and pleasure in, what I would call 'slack time', away from the rigours of work; having time to do whatever takes your fancy with out having to answer to bosses, colleagues and so on. Having just been through a fairly dreadful two months at work I'm doing eactly that right now and it is very refreshing. This poem was not about that. It is about something deeper and more lasting underpinning everything else. I didn't see this as shades of lavenders and greys [I think I could cope with lavenders and greys :-) ] this was, for me, deepest black. Elfstone.
Re: I am; am I?
"do whatever takes your fancy without having to answer to bossess..." Actually, I meant more "I am nothing, I am worth nothing, therefore I can just "be", after trying to pretend in front of concerned citizens" I left the blackness behind, but it still swirls around my ankles every now and again. It consumed my Aunt and last week she stood with her head held high in front of a train. Finally at peace. No condolences necessary, we bury our dead in secret, nobody cries. You are correct when you say that we are the sum of our experiences and what people do to us. I cannot summon the energy to be angry anymore so I surrender. I am nothing, so everything can pass through me and I can even squeeze something enjoyable out of it, even if it is macabre. You do not realize how victorious and triumphant the words to this poem are to me. My cousin, my Aunt's son, would enjoy them immensely but he is now a nonhuman (he would like that appellation)but he is still capable of blinding anger. You would never recognize the bubbly innocent energetic little boy in the hollow eyes and vacant mask of his now self. He lives in the deepest black. I have only visited there. I regret the flippant tone of my first comment as the boldness of your poem deserved honesty. The place it calls from has an address that is difficult to locate but once found can attach to and suck dry a human soul.
Re: I am; am I?
It may not be a 'comfortable' subject but I think pieces like this offer comfort to those who feel like this in the knowledge that they are not alone.You have written the honest truth, baring your soul - I congratulate you on managing to do this so eloquently, I find it very difficult to write when I'm in this mind set. An excellent, well thought out piece and very thought provoking.
Re: I am; am I?
Hi elfstone: I think I probably misunderstood the last line. I took it to be a rhetorical reply to the previous three lines, so i thought you were saying: 'I am pointless, without meaning....am I not?' So my reply meant to say, no I don't believe you or your life is pointless, without meaning, etc. Hope that clears it up. And I WILL look at 'In the Beginning'.
Re: I am; am I?
Thank you for your kind comments Shangri-la. If people have taken comfort from this then I am well satisfied. I find writing in this mind-set can be relatively easy and therapeutic; it is writing 'happy' poems that I find hard, but we're all different, [thank goodness!! :-) ] Elfstone.
Re: I am; am I?
Goodness me, I certainly didn't think you were being flippant - just interpreting my poem in a different and interesting way. It seems you have not had your sorrows to seek recently, but as you prefer no condolences I will respect your wishes and offer none. I hope you can accept my honest sympathy though.
"You do not realize how victorious and triumphant the words to this poem are to me." I can only say that I felt no triumph, no victory writing this, but I am happy to accept that that is your interpretation, and I am delighed that you (and several others it seems) have seen something of value in this poem.
Sabrina I also have to thank you very much for making this a Hot Story - I've just had an email from UKA telling me. I am honoured! Elfstone.
Re: I am; am I?
I liked this poem very much, especially this stanza:
I am the empty life;
A husk of searching
Inside a shell of loss.
Re: I am; am I?
Silent, I always value your comments - thank you for this. Elfstone.
Re: I am; am I?
How can you say so much with so few words, Elfstone, such deeply identifiable meaning here, which goes far beying the surface read. I like the short lined layout...more atmospheric about the wondering in this fabulous piece, Zydha
Re: I am; am I?
Hi,Zy! I had not expected any more comments on this one although the read count does keep creeping up. I have to confess I was very surprised at the response to this - one of my bleakest poems and yet it has had more reads, comments and ratings than any of the others. I'm chuffed of course, but a bit mystified. Many thanks for stopping by here and for such a lovely comment - you know I value your opinion. :-) Elfstone.