From the UKAuthors Collection
The Night the Music Died
By Elfstone · Originally published 28 June 2004
My first attempt at a short story (I have been a poetry person so far).
She cried herself to sleep that night, not that anyone knew. One of the disadvantages of living alone - there was never anyone there to see or care about her distress. She had gone through the motions of a normal Friday evening - there was no swimming club because of the problems with the hot water system at the pool, but she had gone to the gym and trudged through her usual workout, even though her heart wasn’t in it. Physical exercise usually worked as a good anti-stress treatment, very important in her job. Striding out on the treadmill her body would go into autopilot mode and her mind simply emptied. Something about the repetitive rhythmic movement prevented thinking and it was usually a cleansing, relaxing experience. This time the twisting, churning thoughts wouldn’t go away.
She had often thought - and it came back to her now - that a private sorrow in a public place is a strange thing: there was such a dichotomy between the inner turmoil and the outward calm. All these others were going about their workouts oblivious to the misery she hid inside and boy! was she good at hiding misery! She had been brought up to hide and not just misery. She had been well and truly taught that feelings were not for public display. So she sat on the exercise bike pedalling away mechanically and suffered silently.
Her mind was lost in memories of rehearsals and concerts. Twelve years the Orchestra had been in her life. It was her baby; she had set it up, nurtured it, run it, conducted it, composed and arranged music for it. It was open to any pupil who was prepared to travel to the rehearsals on Tuesday nights and for most of its life all the Secondary schools in the county were represented along with several of the Primaries. In the beginning it was a small group, about thirty or so players, but it had grown and at its biggest, 75 players had performed at the annual concert. Over the years many of the kids had moved on to the Senior Orchestra and although she always felt a bit peeved at the loss of her best players, it was good to think that the training they had gained in her Orchestra had played its part in preparing them for that step up. Anyway there were always new young players ready to join and start the cycle all over again.
As she moved from the bike to the treadmill and started striding out, images of individual players came to her . There had been too many to remember them all, too many to count in fact. She really had no idea how many kids had been part of the orchestra over the years, but some individuals stood out. What was it about french horn players? They were always characters and the memory almost raised a smile. Her own finest pupil had been one such. Unusually he had stayed with the orchestra when he passed the audition for the Senior one and his presence in the back row allowed a kind of banter at rehearsals that taught the younger players much. Nothing to do with music of course, but then, orchestras - especially children’s ones - are not just about music.
Power walking at 4.5 miles per hour did nothing to wipe away the hurt. The sense of loss simply would not abate. The Orchestra had gone through a bad patch in the past year or so. Difficulties in a couple of the schools meant that the supply of string players from those schools had almost dried up. It was one of those situations over which she had no control or even influence, but which affected the orchestra badly. It had caused her much heart ache to see her Orchestra so impoverished, but a small group had kept going and she had always believed that the Orchestra would rebuild itself when the string situation was sorted out. That now seemed to be happening. Not that it would be a quick process; the damage done would, she knew, take anything up to 5 years to repair. Learning to play an instrument was not a quick process, a fact which caused problems from time to time in this world where everything is expected to be instant. However she knew that the Orchestra would recover, or thought she did, until this afternoon.
She had only started using the elliptical trainer two or three weeks ago and it was very hard work. Sweat poured down her face as it always did when she was exercising hard. Briefly she wondered if the sweat would disguise tears but dismissed the idea. In any case tears wouldn't make a blind bit of difference. She could cry but then when she stopped crying things would be exactly the same; nothing would have changed; she would still be facing the end of her Orchestra. The blow had come out of the blue. The season had started well with good numbers of woodwind and especially brass and, inevitably, a very small number of strings. So long as she kept them interested and enjoying rehearsals the group was viable and it was the kernel from which the orchestra would grow back to what it had once been. The string situation in the schools affected had been resolved and, although it would be a slow process, numbers would now increase. The group as it stood, full of young and inexperienced players, was making a surprisingly good sound. So things were looking up. When the brass instructor came into her classroom that afternoon she had no inkling of what was about to hit her. The instructor’s decision to withdraw all the brass players from the orchestra, to set up a brass band on Monday nights, with an instructor from a neighbouring school, was completely unexpected. The implications were however immediately obvious to her, and truly drastic. Pupils could not be expected to come out to rehearse on two nights each week; that just wouldn’t happen and with none of the brass players there on Tuesdays, what was left was not a viable group; too few in number and too odd a combination of instruments. The Orchestra was finished.
The water in the shower was never as hot as she liked and anyway she would have given anything for a deep hot bath. Showers were just for getting clean. There was something comforting about baths and she desperately needed comforting. The instructor knew that the move to a Monday night brass band would signal the end of the Orchestra, was very apologetic, but quite determined. The decision had been made and she could see that the instructor was clearly not going to go back on it. She was completely stunned as she grappled with that dreadful wash of unavoidability, that compulsion to deny what had happened, that feeling of wanting to go back 5 minutes just so that it wouldn’t have happened, that sickening certainty that it had happened and could not be undone. She had actually said very little as the news sank in, her standard response to anything very painful: say nothing, curl up inside, go away and hide, shut the door, weep in private. “Go to your room and don’t come out until you’ve mended your face”, she could hear either - both - of her parents saying to any hint of tears in her much younger self. “No one wants to know you when you’re unhappy,” she remembered an ex-boyfriend saying once. So she just sat there almost completely mute as the instructor “left her to think about it”. What she wanted to do was shout at the departing figure, “Think about it? What is there to think about? You’re killing my orchestra!! It hurts!! Pain doesn’t need thought!”, but she had long since learned that no one gave a damn about her hurting. If the truth be told, no one else would care a twopenny toss about the Orchestra being disbanded either. She doubted if anyone would even notice, aside from the kids themselves for a short while. People nowadays availed themselves of what was on offer and when it was no longer there, simply forgot about it and moved on to something else. Maybe it had always been so, but it seemed to her that, more and more, our throwaway society affected not just polythene bags and tin cans.
Trudging round Tesco she found herself buying foods she wouldn’t normally touch, without really thinking about it - and all of them bad for her weight problem. Just then a healthy diet wasn’t in her thoughts. What was going through her mind was what on earth she would say to the kids the next time she saw them; how best to deal with the painful business of explaining to them what was happening. The instructor wanted “no resentment”, to maintain their “good professional relationship” and she knew inspite of her pain that she would do exactly that - be professional. She would smile through her gritted teeth; she would be polite and calm and reasonable. That was what people had come to expect of her. She was a passed master at the swan syndrome - not in the sense of being beautiful, she was never that, but in the sense of seeming serene, unruffled on the surface, coping with anything that was flung at her. Underneath, out of sight, the webbed feet of her emotions were paddling frantically . She knew she would stand in front of her players and make some nonsense speech about it being for the best; some waffle about possibly restarting the Orchestra at some unspecified point in the future. She knew full well that that would never happen, especially if the brass band was successful, but couldn’t be that open, that blunt with the kids; professionalism would win, as it always did, at the expense of honesty.
As she paid for her shopping it occurred to her that there was also the whole business of winding up the accounts to sort out . The orchestra had its own bank account. The Friends of the Orchestra - parents of the players - had been very supportive over the years taking care of the ‘Kit Kat’ break in each rehearsal and much of the administration surrounding the annual concert. They had managed to accrue a few hundred pounds over the years and now there was the very difficult question of what to do with that money. Putting it into her ‘retirement fund’ was not an option! Then again there were the many sets of music and several boxes full of the special music stands and Concert folders with the Orchestra’s logo on the front which, for all but one night of the year, gathered dust on the shelves in her department. What was she to do with them?
She drove home with the dull, heaviness of inevitability hammering at her. It had happened; it wouldn’t, couldn’t un-happen. Eating all the comfort foods she had bought brought her no comfort at all - her Orchestra was folding and food didn’t take the edge off the hurt. Self recrimination cut in, as ever, and she began to try to find something she should have done differently, a way she could have avoided this. Eventually the pointlessness of the exercise did manage to get through her confusion and she made an effort to drag her thoughts on to a happier plane. Could she phone someone? What for? - to talk about trivialities? - she knew she just couldn’t indulge in small talk tonight; or to tell what had happened and then be told she would get over it? She had been told that more often than most people had hot dinners. It was something that people said - said ostensibly to provide comfort, she knew, but it seemed to her that it was said more for the comfort of the people saying it than the listeners. What people don’t understand of others’ feelings they find embarrassing and, being embarrassed, they want a way out. “You’ll get over it”, was almost always said as the precurser to a change of subject. In a way it was true of course, life goes on, but she had come to believe that we never ‘get over’ anything - we just learn to ignore the bad things that happen to us. Time may well be a great healer, al la the cliché, but it doesn’t remove the scars. Nothing does.
Unusually, she switched on the TV without knowing what was on - she was normally very choosy about what she watched. In fact she wasn’t really watching it. Her eyes were vaguely focused on the screen but nothing much was registering on her. One glass of red wine on a Friday night was normal, sometimes she had two. The third glass from which she was now sipping was fairly exceptional and part of her knew it wasn’t really helping. Her intellect told her that alcohol is a depressant but the rest of her didn't care. Is this how people become alcoholics - they hurt too much and stop caring? She also knew that it was a muscle relaxant and hoped it might unwind her enough to let her sleep. Sleep wouldn’t change anything either, but it would be an escape, for a while, from the relentless grinding of her mind.
Somewhere in the middle of a programme about Hitler, - or was it garden makeovers? - tears started to flow without any warning. She sat there, alone, in her sitting room weeping. The tears flowed and flowed and went on flowing. Her weeping was almost silent, just hot bitter tears flooding down her face. All the failures of her life - and there had been many - seemed to parade themselves before her, chewing on her vulnerability; a brutal reproach for lack of achievement; a cruel litany of wasted time and effort; a mocking, heartless pageant of all the might-have-beens that normally lay hidden, cluttered behind the closed doors of her life.
She wept, knowing that it would change nothing. She wept in grief and a mourning that no one would understand. She wept for the certainty that no one knew she wept. She wept, knowing that anyone who did know would only be surprised or puzzled or embarrassed, or all three. She wept, knowing that things would be as just sore when she eventually stopped weeping. She wept in helplessness and hopelessness. She wept for the death of her Orchestra.
She cried herself to sleep that night.
© Elfstone 27/6/04
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Re: The Night the Music Died
Dear me! the silence is deafening; a vote of no confidence I think. Oh well, I'd better stick to poetry. :-(( Elfstone.
Re: The Night the Music Died
Hi Elfstone this is the kind of story that I can get lost in, getting caught up in the emotions of the character. She obviously leads a very structured life and the Orchestra has become so hugely important as you say her 'baby', a telling line. I think the story unfolds well as she moves around the gym and the last paragraph is excellent. I think i would cut out the first line and start with...one of the disadvantages .... reason being you end with the weeping. Also don't know if we need a sentence with a reason why a brass orchestra is being established ?? as there are funds built up for the current orchestra. You get across very well of how alone she feels. Sorry this is probably not the type of comments you were hoping for but being a poet it's the best I can do...L x
Re: The Night the Music Died
Hi Elfstone. Just to say I enjoyed your story very much. I felt the depair and desolation at the end. I think we've all reached that point that she reached at the end of the story - for all sorts of different reasons for us getting to that point. I think that poetry will always get more comments and hits than short stories simply because of the amount of time people have to read 'x' number of words. I often struggle for time to stay seated long enough to read and comment on a piece of 2.5k+ words, whereas I can probably read and comment on 2/3 poems in the same timescale. Don't despair and keep writing short stories - this is one of the best I've read on this site - you moved me greatly with it.
Now then, bonnie weeee lassie. How are your Scottish anthology poems going? Wait 'till you see my one called 'The Highlander' - it's an old one of mine which (I think) I've been able to improve a lot. I reckon that only an Anglo/Irishman with a Scottish soul could have written a poem like it. Take care now Elfstone. Catch you later.
Roamin' in the gloamin' wi' a lassie by my side...
Re: The Night the Music Died
Ahhhh Leila this is exactly what I was hoping for - and had given up hope of getting - someone telling me what is right or wrong about the story. I have a little confidence with regard to my poetry, but none about story telling. I'll go back and look at the thing with your comments in mind and perhaps rewrite. I am so grateful to you for taking the time to read and especially for commenting. Elfstone.
Re: The Night the Music Died
Shacks I am so grateful for you comments and of course you are right to chide me gently about the time factor! I myself was out of this site for nearly a month due to pressure of work and have only started reading again in the last week. I realise that it is a big commitment reading this number of words and I am very grateful to those who do.
I suppose I was just feeling very vulnerable about this, as it is my first attempt at anything other than poetry and as all my poems (so far!) have received comments - and mostly favourable - I thought the silence here over the last 3 days meant the story was no good. You and Leila have cheered me up no end!! :-)) I am delighted that you saw something good in the tale.
I have e-mailed 5 poems to Ruadh and await further instructions!! When do I get to read 'The Highlander'?
Lang mae yer lum reek, Shacks and thank you. Elfstone.
Re: The Night the Music Died
Hi Elfstone. I really meant it when I said that it was one of the best stories I'd read on UKAuthors.
Great that you've already sent your poems to Ailsa. I'm on the verge of sending mine - I just can't stop twiddling with them at the moment because I'm desperate to get them as good as I can get them. I'm submitting 5 poems and 4 have a definite Scottish theme.
My old mum is looking forward to hopefully seeing my 'Scottish' poems in print because she has a strong memory of her grandad, the wild Scotsman who came on a mission south of the border all those years ago.
Fingers crossed that we are both able to get our poems published in this anthology. I look forward to seeing yours.
If you don't mind, I'd love to email you my poem 'The Highlander' before I submit it to Ailsa. I'd be greatful for your considered opinion. I rate you highly as an honest, knowledgeable critic of poetry and I'd value your comments. This poem is perhaps one of my most meaningful poems from the point of view of the race-memory of my soul, that I have ever written.
Take care now Elfstone.
Catch you later.
Re: The Night the Music Died
I'd be honoured to receive it! I'm at my leisure tomorrow evening, if you can get it to me by then. Elf.