From the UKAuthors Collection
Upon My Soul
By Ionicus · Originally published 7 June 2004
Not long ago an intriguing question was raised wich did not attract much response.
I took it to be tongue in cheek and my comment is made in the same vein.
A young Greek philosopher
was deep in concentration
pondering on a question
worthy of consideration.
Is the soul XX, or is it XY?
She mused with pertinence.
I am afraid that this poser
was met with indifference.
I think that we should offer
some opinion on this topic
for to ignore the debate
would be somewhat myopic.
I know that ancient thinkers
were hot on the spiritual
and discussed at great length
the soul of an individual.
They recorded their wisdom
in various learned tomes,
but did they see the matter
in terms of chromosomes?
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Re: Upon My Soul
Hmm... don't know the answer to this one The soul, the soul, let me see...They do say things like 'she had a man's soul trapped in a woman's body' and so forth, so maybe it's an open debate. But if you don't believe in your soul, does that make it less male/female? Nice poem, fun to read,
Re: Upon My Soul
THE QUALITIES OF XX AND XY ARE NOT THE QUALITIES OF MASCULINITY AND FEMINITY!!!!
Sexual instincts are based on the XX and XY but not on masculinity and feminity which are two of the most important qualities of the soul!
The whole matter is really simple up to this point.
The soul is not affected by chromosomes, the soul affects chromosomes! The soul is not divided in two different sexes!
It gets deeper and complicated from now on, so I'd better stop.
Greek young philosopher.
;)
Re: Upon My Soul
correction: 'femininity'
Re: Upon My Soul
No use asking me, dear Skeeter.
I am an ignoramus when it comes to philosophy.
I only make throwaway remarks that are open to all sorts of interpretations.
It was fun for me to write this piece as it was for you to read.
Many thanks.
Re: Upon My Soul
Dear Nicoletta,
I assume that your comment was directed at Skeeter's observations, because I did not make any reference to gender.
I confess my ignorance on this subject but surely things are never that simple.
If, as you say, the soul affects the chromosomes are we to infer that body and soul are two separate entities? And does the soul come into existence at the same time as the body or is it born when the body dies?
Just idle thoughts, as usual.
I don't suppose I'll understand the answer.
Regards.
Re: Upon My Soul
IN MY OPINION:
The body is temporary the soul is eternal, now I won't say that the body is just a vessel like some others claim! Aux contraire......
Let's say that they body is the "dress" that the soul desired/wished/chose to "wear", it's alive and made according to the qualities of a soul -- something like that -- the body is really important and beautiful, the body is like a temple in which there is one priest that is a believer at the same time, face to face with God and God's truth.
But that's a matter of esoteric philosophy.
The soul pre-exists.
Silent