From the UKAuthors Collection

Croick

By Elfstone · Originally published 30 April 2004

In some ways this is still relevant - unfortunately this sort of thing is stilll happening all over the world.

Croick

It was the worst time of the year too;
In the summer we might have borne it better,
But they chose to wait till
Winter had a good grip
And the Factor and his men a better one.

The burning it was that finished us
With the bairns screaming and
The cailleachs wailing like banshees.
The thatch went up like a torch and nothing to stop it.
The memory scorches me:
Standing in the snow clutching the youngest
While our glen went up in smoke
And the anger burned in us.

The factor and his cronies
- heartless to the last man of them -
Showed no mercy.
If there’s Justice beyond,
They’ll roast in a fire of their own making.

We took what we could from
The ruins of our lives
- precious little we’d had and
Even less left in the ashes.
In our sore need we turned to the kirk.
Sad and weary was the walk to Croick
And what welcome did we find there?
- a locked door and a stern face,
And the anger burned in us.

We huddled against a snell wind
In the lee of the kirk.
The men put up a shelter of sorts
And we made do
As people must who have nothing.
The dying was of grief as much as cold
And every day a grinding struggle.
And the anger burned in us.

Of the journey here I will say nothing;
Necessity drives a long, hard road.
We made a life of sorts in this strange land,
But still my thoughts turn east
To an empty glen and
An English Duke who sits in splendour
With the stink of burning thatch on his silk clothes.

And the anger burns in me yet.

© Elfstone 16/4/04

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

ruadh

Re: Croick

Liked this Elfstone....some things never change unfortunately

ailsa

razorcuts

Re: Croick

sorry elf but this anglo hatred went out with nelson's eye and to hear it still being regurgatated makes me recoil. it happened, let it drop. it's this sort of voice that incites old hatred's. what is this meant to achieve. it's been done......to death. if the English do something that affects you and yours today, then get back to me but until then, it's history for godsake.

as for the poetry, it's quite good, if you can ignore the anti englishness which is the obvious essence.

well done

Elfstone

Re: Croick

Good heavens razorcuts, my poem has obviously touched a nerve!! Let me try to work my way through your points.

The easiest to reply to is “What is it meant to achieve” - well on another site we were ‘Challenged” to write a poem about a historical event from the perspective of someone actually there at the time. This was the result. Why did I choose this particular event ? - because it happened just up the road from here in the area around the Kirk at Croick; because it was a series of events which made a very profound impression on this part of the country; because the effects of the Clearances are still with us in subtle ways (the Highlands have never recovered - and probably will never recover - from the depopulation); because it is “in the family” ( my great-grand parents were part of a whole island community which was “cleared”). All of these factors informed the poem in some way.

Yes it is history, of course - that was the Challenge. Are you suggesting that poems should not be written about history or historical events? - surely not. We should not dwell on history in a mawkish way - I loathe the kailyard sentimentalism which sometimes colours Scotland’s view of itself - but I will defend a country’s right to discuss and analyse its own past. Indeed in Scotland’s case I will defend its right just to know its own history and for the most part we don’t. I studied History in Secondary school up to Higher level and I was taught not one page, nor date, nor event of Scottish history. We studied the Unification of Italy and the Industrial Revolution in the Midlands and the Franco-Prussion war, and heaven knows what else, but not once was my own country’s history mentioned. (Why that was the case is another discussion. ) What I know now I learned from family - particularly my father who was an History graduate and my own reading or watching of documentaries. If you deny a country knowledge of its past you deny it a real sense of its identity. Just as each of us is in a sense the sum of our life experiences, so a country is in some sense the sum of its collective experiences.

There is no anti-Englishness in this poem. As I hinted in the introduction this is a poem about man’s inhumanity to man. Substitute Rwandan, or Bosnian or Serbian or Israeli or Sunni or Shia, or any number of other nationalities/religions; substitute the word “foreign” for the word English and the poem would be as relevant. The woman I ‘became’ in this poem could just as well be standing in a shattered town in Croatia or in the West Bank. The poem was never intended to incite hatred, but to inspire pity for the oppressed, who ever they may be and where ever they are. The 'essence' of this poem, as you put it, is pity.

Clearly my poem has touched a (political?) raw nerve in you and I accept that you are entitled to interpret it as you wish, even if your view is radically different from my own in writing it. You say little about it as a piece of poetry other than that it is “quite good” and I honestly don’t know what to make of the “well done” at the end. Given the rest of what you have written I’m not sure if you are being sarcastic - one of the disadvantages of not having body language and tone of voice to guide us here.

Elfstone

Re: Croick

Many thanks for reading this and for your comments Ailsa. Elfstone.

Zydha

Re: Croick

I have read this before, Elfstone, and the power of your words in this poetic documentation, has left me in awe once again.

That was quite a challenge we had, and we all interpreted a time or event which meant something to ourselves. If you remenber...I went on to write of Dr Martin Luther King, But, this shows your passionate feelings for the history of your surroundings so well, another excellent piece of work, Zydha x

Bradene

Re: Croick

Hi Elf I will say again what I said before after reading this piece. I am ashamed that I had never heard of the event and I am greatful to you for writing this so that I can find out more about it. It was I who set the challenge, strangely I who am English wrote very sympathetically about Mary Queen of Scotland, one of my favourite characters in history. I thought your answer to razorcuts was a very fair and balanced one and you are right in implying that history still has relevence today, I agree whole heartedly. As to your poem, as usual it is flawless. love Val xx

dargo77

Re: Croick

Elfstone, I like this because reminders of the past help us to control the future. There can be no doubt that the Scottish nation suffered greatly at the hands of invaders. I enjoyed your account of this period of history. Well written and informative.
A Hot Story for me.
Dargo

razorcuts

Re: Croick

well elf, i didnt know that what you had written was set as a challenge. mind you it still does'nt hide the theme from me. just as you're proud to be a scots-person, i'm proud to be an englishman and i defend my right to argue against this hollywood style anti english. it grates, i'm sorry but thats what it does to me. my hackles raise. it seems that everyone else can stand up for themselves except us english, its frowned upon and unless you were english in this day and age you would'nt understand. you may point a racist finger at me and i would vehemently point one straight back at you.

as for populace decimation, have you not read of the wars this little country has been involved in. its surprising we have forefathers to descend from! i live now in an area where the civil war tore the english people apart, should i side with a section that fought against brother and father? no, it happened and as i stated we have to stop apologising and get on with it. sadly, scots, irish and the like despise the english for crushing them when, if they could have, they would have done exactly the same, have you not been told of the atrocities that the english inflicted? they were savage times, savagery that we would not recognise today.

i'm sorry but i've re-read your poem and it just does'nt indicate any other race except the english, maybe if you could find a line or two to differentiate or expand, go for it. i know your introduction hinted at a panoramic scenario but it then went along the old footpath.

it is not a political pov i have, i'm an english person who is willing to voice the words we are ashamed to voice, tho its nothing that we should be ashamed of.

i'm not being sarcastic, it was well written, i think.

its just the content i disagree with.

razorcuts

Re: Croick

' to which the engish were inflicted' apol for typo.

e-griff

Re: Croick

I didn't read this as Scottish, English at all. What it was about was one person's seeking power over others and inflicting cruelty upon them - and how racial, national hatreds are built. As elfstone says (I think) this is happening the world over - from Afghan warlords to South American plantation owners, to the ten-year old bully in the back streets of Bolton to the gangster with his 'territory' and the boss who bullies their staff..... The priest who 'will be obeyed' The teacher's subtle mental cruelty, the social security clarks small ways of demeaning their 'clients', the nurses treating old people...... humanity...

Elfstone

Re: Croick

Zyha thank you for this. I remember your work on MLK and thinking both 'brave' and 'appropriate'! I always value your critique of my work and I'm grateful for this. Elf.

Elfstone

Re: Croick

Val there is absolutely no need to be ashamed - it was a long time ago and nothing to do with anyone now living. Indeed it was just one small event in a huge number of small events which made up the Clearances, probably only known to locals and students of Scottish History. And yes I do believe it has relevance, sadly, in many parts of the world today. Many thanks for reading again and for your comments. Elf.

Elfstone

Re: Croick

Dargo very many thanks - a hot story?!!!?!!! I'm most honoured (and very chuffed).

As I said in my reply to razorcuts viewing history in a sentimental - or indeed in a bitter - way is unhealthy, but ignoring it is just as bad and suppressing it, as has happened in various countries over the years, is downright sinister. We need to remind ourselves of the human capacity for doing awful things, in the hope that we can prevent them being done in future. Mind you given all that is going on in the world at the moment that seems to be a vain hope. Elfstone.

Elfstone

Re: Croick

You are right of course e-griff. This incident is a microcosm for the brutallity that is visited upon poor and dispossessed peoples all over the world. I wish there was an easy answer to the problem; I wish that people could treat others with kindness and respect, but I have no idea how we are ever going to bring that about.

Many thanks for reading and taking the time to comment. Elfstone.

zenbuddhist

Re: Croick

of course the clearances shaped the social landscape of the highlands..they devastated population levels to the extent that it was impossible to recover from.....this poem [though what its doing in the prose most read is a mystery] to me depicts a realistic setting for what it must have been like for these people...one point on all the scottish/ english furore there were many scottish lairds who were even more ruthless in the clearing of the lands to make room for the cheviot black faced sheep.....the greed for money knows no national boundary!

Michel

Re: Croick

Very evocative, IMO. Flows beautifully.

All round the world, relevant. Agree with
the point about *not* studying history or
seeing it from a nationalistic perspective.
Not faulting pre-sets of people; faulting those
who oppress anywhere.

Elfstone

Re: Croick

Thanks Michel - very grateful for your comments. Glad you approve! Elfstone.

Elfstone

Re: Croick

Many thanks for taking the time to comment Zen. You are right about greed being a huge motivating factor in abuse and suppression of Peoples all over the world.

I didn't realise this was in the Prose section until you mentioned it - very strange!!! Elfstone.

Gee

Re: Croick

A very powerful piece of writing. I liked the repetition of this phrase - And the anger burned in us. I felt the slight change at the end made it more personal.
I feel that anyone reading this would want to know more about the event that led to this poem. I know I do.
Isn't it a shame that people don't seem to learn from the mistakes of the past though?
Brilliantly written.

Elfstone

Re: Croick

Gee, I am very grateful for you comments and you're right, we don't seem to be very good at learning from past mistakes.
Many thanks for reading and taking the time to comment. Elfstone.

riggy

Re: Croick

Oh Elfstone, this had me in tears, you took me back there so easily. That doesn't happen often. Thank you so much.
meg

Elfstone

Re: Croick

Riggy, many thanks for your comment. It's a while since this one was posted, so it was a pleasant surprise to see a fresh comment. Strangely enough I cycled up to Croick with a pal on Wednesday. I hadn't been there in a long while. It is beautiful but sad too. I know that my poem indulges in poetic licence, amalgamating bits of family history and imagination with the actual facts of Glencalvie, but still these people must have suffered terribly. Elfstone.

Elfstone

Croick

Shywolf, you are very kind in your comments and many thanks for that generous rating!

I thought you might get something out of reading this and the comments that were made about it when I first posted it. Oppression has been with us in many forms for a long time, but sadly it seems we are no more enlightened now than they were then.

Elfstone.

weefatbob

Croick

A wonderful poem which I have just used with several school groups during an outdoor education programme. They walked over the hills to Strathcarron and camped out near the manse. Each group was then taken to the church at Croick and the story of the Clearances related to them. I finished by reading this poem. Rarely nowadays as a teacher do I get a silent audience but this had them totally transfixed. A very moving experience for them and me. Thank you.

e-griff

Croick

the thing is, the clearances were part of a general agricultural revolution which had swept europe and england before it reached scotland. It was based on economic necessity, not ANY anti-scottish or dominant behaviour, which is why Scottish Lairds joined in. It modernised agriculture at the time, and so had beneficial effects for everyone, as well as unfortunate ones for those directly affected. (just as the coalminers in our century).

Presented as it has been here, it is clearly fuel for those scots who love to feel oppressed and hard done by which probably accounts for some of the original reactions. I can see why an english person might feel slightly upset by it.

Most history is shaped by ecomnomic necessity, not human emotions. :-) Good pome, though. G

e-griff

Croick

it's suddenly occurred to me to ask what exactly a teacher is teaching chiildren about this, and what effect it has on their opinions. Perpetuating long-gone resentments? Of course, I dunno, but interesting to know.

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…