From the UKAuthors Collection
The Lodger
By sirat · Originally published 2 April 2004
A monologue. I wrote this at a single sitting. It was inspired by the words of the old Paul Simon song: "A Most Peculiar Man".
======================================
I met Mrs. Ellwood in the hallway this morning. She opened her door just as I was stooping down to pick up the letters from the mat. I’m sure she did it deliberately. Mrs. Ellwood is a very nosey woman.
“Oh, good morning Mr. Ludwig,” she said, all bright and cheerful, “are you feeling well this morning?”
A strange question to ask that, when you think about it. A very revealing question. Why shouldn’t I be feeling well? Did I ever say I was ill? Of course not. The reason she says: “are you feeling well?” is that she makes assumptions. They all make assumptions. Because I don’t go out at the same time they do, because they don’t see me leaving in the morning, or coming back in the evening, because I don’t have visitors, they assume that I’m ill. That there’s something wrong with me. They have no right to make assumptions like that. The way I live my life is my own business. If I want to stay in, I stay in. If I don’t want people up in my room, messing around with my things, then I don’t have them up there. My business, you see. Nothing to do with Mrs. Ellwood. Nothing to do with any of them.
I didn’t say anything to Mrs. Ellwood. Just handed her her letters. Why should I answer questions based on assumptions that she has no right to make? They were all for her except one. The one that wasn’t was for Mrs. Creighton, the landlady. It was just an invitation to apply for some sort of credit card. If I wanted to I could make assumptions about Mrs. Ellwood based on the number of letters she gets every day. I could assume that she’s a blackmailer, or an agony aunt for a women’s magazine, or a compulsive answerer of lonely heart adverts. But I don’t assume anything like that because I don’t have the right. I don’t know anything about Mrs. Ellwood’s life and she doesn’t know anything about mine. That’s the way I like it.
My room is the smallest one in the house but it has the best view. Mr. Stephen’s room has a front window as well but there’s a big conifer directly outside it so I don’t think he can see very much. I can see right down the road in one direction. Not so far the other way because of the same conifer. I suppose Mr. Stephens should ask Mrs. Creighton to have it cut down. I don’t think she would though. Her window is at the back, downstairs. It doesn’t make any difference to her. Anyhow Mr. Stephens is hardly ever in his room. He just comes back to sleep in the late evening. You can tell when he’s there because he turns on his radio. He listens to the news, mostly, and classical music. He keeps the volume low, all I can hear is a kind of faint rumbling through the wall.
I’m glad that my room is small. I don’t like big spaces. My room at Roundways was small as well, and it had a good view from the window. Better than this one. Fields, and trees, and a little stream winding through a valley. Of course the bars spoiled it a bit.
I can cook in my own room here. I have a little electric hob and a sink to do the dishes and an electric kettle and sharp knives and everything. They didn’t let me have anything like that at Roundways.
Mrs Creighton has a daughter who visits her every now and then. I think she must live quite far away because she doesn’t come very often, and when she does she always stays for a few days. Mrs. Creighton’s daughter has long straight brown hair, down to her shoulders, and she wears low-cut dresses and short skirts. She’s a lot thinner than her mother. Her neck is fine and delicate, like the spout of a fine china teapot. I could snap that neck with one hand, in the blink of an eye if I wanted to. I wouldn’t want to of course. Why would I want to do a thing like that? She wears those white trainers, like all young people seem to nowadays. They don’t go with the skirts. Somebody should tell her.
I prefer to go out late at night, when there aren’t very many people around. Spaces don’t look so big at night. The scale of the world becomes more comfortable. I leave the house very quietly. I know which steps and floorboards creak and I don’t walk on them. I open the front door very quietly. I oiled the hinges of the front door myself. I’m a very considerate person. I walk to the all-night supermarket on the dual carriageway if I need any groceries. I can get there in about half an hour, if I’m in a hurry, but I’m not usually in a hurry. I just take my time and enjoy the walk, make a little detour into the park, perhaps, or down the alleyway behind the flats on Leeson Street. It’s hard to get away from the street lights in a big city like this, but I’ve found a few places where you can. You would be surprised what goes on in a big city, in very dark places, very late at night.
Mrs. Creighton asked me if I was happy here a few mornings ago. I told her I was very happy. She seemed almost... disappointed. Maybe she doesn’t like my being here. Maybe she would like me to leave. But that doesn’t make any sense. My rent is paid monthly without fail by the Social Services. I don’t smoke or drink or make noise or have strangers in my room or make a mess or cause anybody a problem. She should be pleased to have a lodger like me. Isn’t it funny how people don’t know when they’re well off? She’ll never have another lodger as good as me. You’d think she would be grateful. You’d think she would appreciate how considerate I am.
There are other places that I go to as well as the supermarket of course. There’s an apartment in one of the blocks on the William Randall Estate. There’s someone I visit there. The lift always smells of urine. But that’s private, you don’t need to know about that.
I go down to the towpath as well sometimes and walk along by the side of the canal. It’s very peaceful down there, just one or two houseboats tied up, and now and then an old homeless man sleeping under one of the bridges. When I first used to go there you would see a few younger people as well. There was drug-dealing going on there. That and worse. I like to think I’ve been instrumental in some small way in cleaning it up. People don’t go there very often now. Not late at night. Not after that unfortunate business with the Australian girl student. You probably read about it in the local paper. Young girls shouldn’t go out late at night like that. It isn’t safe.
There’s only one place that I ever go in the daytime. Apart from the library, of course. I usually drop in at the library while I'm out. It isn’t open at night, like the supermarket or the apartment on the William Randall Estate. If I didn’t go to them they would come to me, and I don’t want them to do that. I don’t want the people in this house getting to know about my business. Or people coming up to this room, messing around with my things. They ask me how I am and I tell them I’m very well and they give me my medication for the next fortnight and I take it home. That’s all there is to it. And for that they get paid quite a lot of money. They get to sleep at night as well. Not like the nurses at Roundways who had to pull back the blind on my door and look in every half hour. They have it easy down at the clinic.
I suppose you’re wondering what it is I do in here all day long. I know Mrs. Ellwood wonders. She thinks about me a lot. A couple of times she has knocked on my door and tried to see into my room. She makes up excuses, like there’s a package for me, or she needs to borrow something. That’s why I like to get to the mail before she does in the morning, so that she doesn’t have an excuse. In fact she doesn’t seem to try it any more. I think I’ve got through to her.
No, it’s very simple really. I like to sit quietly and think. People don’t do that often enough you know. I read a lot too. I’ve always liked reading. And I have my albums and my collections that I like to keep up to date. I buy the papers when I go to the supermarket for my groceries, if there’s anything in them that I want for my albums. I cut things out and I paste things in. It doesn’t make any noise or keep anybody awake. It’s a very considerate hobby. I cut out pictures and articles that interest me, and little mementos. Things like a student identity card and a couple of Australian dollars. I’m quite a sentimental person I suppose, where that sort of thing is concerned. I didn’t really want anything but the girl insisted. As a sort of souvenir, and a mark of gratitude for tackling the man with the knife.
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Re: The Lodger
I like the final 'about face' with this; the writing leads us to one conclusion and then challenges us for making it on very little evidence. Great control.
Re: The Lodger
Thanks Aliya, your comments are greatly appreciated. Mr. Ludwig did warn you about making assumptions, didn't he?
Re: The Lodger
Yup, that ending is definitely more interesting! G
Re: The Lodger
An intriguing story. I was fooled right to the very end. He was right, it's not good to make assumptions or to poke your nose into other people's affairs. I think this is the first piece of yours I've read so far, I shall be looking out for more of your work I thoroughly enjoyed reading this.
Re: The Lodger
Thanks Shangri-la. I'll look up some of your stuff too. And thanks Griff. Griff saw this one in a slightly earlier version and made some helpful suggestions.
Re: The Lodger
I liked this a lot. Its the kind of thing I like. Good to see a fellow Paul Simon fan too.
Mimi x
Re: The Lodger
Loved this - the gradual build up and then the jolt at the end. And 'Most Peculiar man' is one of my favourites.
Re: The Lodger
Very good...the characterisation was pretty much spot-on, the pacing good. I did sort of see through the 'twist', but the last couple of lines were still very effective.
Overall, a really enjoyable story. Thanks for the read!
Re: The Lodger
this is great, so many little hooks to be swallowed all the way through and then the line is reeled back in at the close and the reader along with it.
a fine read
bek :-)
Re: The Lodger
I'm sure I've read this before. Is it on your homepage?
Any way, it is a great read.
Re: The Lodger
Superted, Shadow, KDR and Bek: Many thanks for taking the time to comment. I'm very pleased that you liked this story. I've been at work and your comments were all here when I got back, which was great.
Re: The Lodger
No, Claire, it isn't on my home page or anywhere else but here. I suppose I have written similar things before though. Anyway, glad you enjopyed it. Thanks for the copmment.
Re: The Lodger
sirat...I really liked this one. There is an art to the short story, after all, but I must say that I felt this particular piece could have been drawn into something a trifle longer (and I would love to read it, if you ever do!). Having said that, I do feel it worked just as well, as is; a brillient end twist, which I did not anticipate and a firm grasp of the narrator's world view which came across very believably. A most enjoyable read!...Adele :-)
Re: The Lodger
Thanks very much Adele. Glad you liked it. I have an inborn aversion to making stories longer than they need to be. In fact I agonised about removing some of the stuff about Mr. Stephens because it isn't absolutely vital to the story. I can't imagine myself ever setting out to make something longer. But that's just me I suppose.
Re: The Lodger
Sirat, I'm speechless. You are a very interesting writer, I knew that. This story is so good. You write very carefully, you respect your readers and yourself as a writer, you want to give them the best possible writing, best regarding its construction and its flow, your style is polished, refined. You must love writing. Now I have printed Bottom Feeders and I will read more of your stories.
Silent.
Re: The Lodger
Very kind of you to say that Silent. Yes, wherever else I may fail it's certainly true that I try hard. "Bottom Feeders"? Gosh, that's an oldie. I'll be fascinated to hear what you have to say about it.
Re: The Lodger
An interesting story, liked the ending. Cleverly written about assumptions, enjoyed the read.
Gouri.
Re: The Lodger
Thanks for commenting Gouri. Glad you enjoyed it.
Re: The Lodger
This is really good. Firstly, it works well as a monologue. Secondly, it leads the reader to believe a certain thing till the end. And then you realise that you've mis-read all the clues sprinkled in the story. And it's not because you are dumb. Thirdly, one gets a clear picture of the protagonist's character. Enjoyed the read.
Re: The Lodger
Thanks very much for that detailed comment. I'm particularly pleased that you didn't think I played the reader for a dummy. I was really trying to let the reader catch a glimpse of their own prejudices, however "reasonable" they might be. I am also delighted that you thought the other aspects of the story worked. Greatly appreciated.
David.
Re: The Lodger
A peach....this is my kind of story dave....really enjoyed it....the fact that you wrote it in one sitting makes the ten rating even more appropriate.....cheers Z
Re: The Lodger
Hi sirat
I really enjoyed this. I like what I read to flow before me like an un-creased sheet. a lot of stories often have a little too many bumps and distractions along the way. This was a really well ironed sheet. Made me think of butterflies by Ian mcEwan.
sounds a bit poncey that doesn't it?
Re: The Lodger
Nothing poncey at all Ronnie, you can compare me to Ian McEwan all you want. Many thanks for the kind comments.
Re: The Lodger
Delighted that you liked it Zen. I often write a complete first draft at a sitting, but I will have been thinking about it much longer. What I can't seem to do is start writing without knowing where it's going in advance. When I try this I produce rubbish. Works for some people apparently but not for me.
Thanks again.
David.
Re: My Kind of Story - The Lodger
Beautifully written. Loved it.
As Zen said - 'my kind of story.'
Re: My Kind of Story - The Lodger
Many thanks Michel.
Re: The Lodger
Very good Sirat. That ending was perfect - in fact I had to read it a couple of times to check that you weren't doing a double-double take. Had me enthralled. A most peculiar man - a most peculiar life (I'm talking about the whole lot of us now). Enjoyed your story.
Re: The Lodger
Perfect pieces cannot be commented, there is no advice to give to make anything sound or feel better, and this to me is one of those.
I didn't have a clue of what was waiting for me in the beginning, I thought he was just one of this people who just look at other's lives instead of living himself. When he starts commenting about the neck of the young woman in trainers, I nearly jump...
I wouldn't want a coma changed in this story, David. Great read indeedy.
Thank you.
Luisaxxxxxxxxxxx
(Running to listen to the song once more)
Re: The Lodger
Many thanks Shackleton and Lulu. Your kind comments much appreciated.
David.
Re: The Lodger
My most sincere thanks to whoever has nominated "The Lodger" for a future anthology. Much appreciated.
David.
Re: The Lodger
Wonderful writing. Many lessons there for those of us who are lower down on the learning curve.
I would however like to make one point, in reply to your stated 'aversion' to making a story any longer than it needs to be. That is of course a hard statement to contest - but I do (humbly) in two ways. To start with your story was so good it left me wanting more. And secondly, I feel that flesh and bones is more satisfying than just a skelitan.
My hat is off - Michael
Re: The Lodger
I really enjoyed this and it kept me guessing to the end, even after the end. I know that he's meant to be the goody but I did wonder when he mentioned the student ID card. Did the girl give him that?
Very enjoyable read and very deserving of the great read nib.
Chrissy
Re: The Lodger
Sirat,
You wrote this in one sitting? Wow!
Such a great ending, one of the best pieces I have ever read.
Regards
Chris
Re: The Lodger
I hate to be the odd one out regarding this story but although I enjoyed it I found the end very flat and dissapointing.
Re: The Lodger
Many thanks for that Kipper. I suppose I see brevity as part of the merit of both a short story and a poem. Part of the art is to say a great deal in a small space. All the words should do something, they should be there for a purpose. At least that's what I think and what I admire in other people's short stories that I read.
Re: The Lodger
Thanks for the kind comments Chrissy. Re the student ID card, I imagined her saying something like: Have this at least, it's got my picture on it. I can easily get another. And here are a couple of Australian dollars - not worth anything but just as a souvenir." Something like that. I also imagined her begging him to tell her his name so that she can give him due credit when she talks to the police and the local paper, and him refusing. That's what I had in mind anyway.
Re: The Lodger
That's okay. I often find myself in the same position regarding a story. I think it's good to pass on your feedback whether good or not. What kind of ending would you have found more satisfying?
Re: The Lodger
Well, what can I say Chrisk? That's certainly given me something to live up to. Thanks very much!
Re: The Lodger
David,
I liked this ... but
I wasn't keen on the word "assumption" and "assume" peppered all over the text at the start - I know it ties in with the twist, but I think you could have used other words to say the same thing?
The student card and dollar "gifts" - firstly, I thought they should be mentioned in the plural when he says, "things like..." (so it's not an explicit list) - secondly, I just couldn't believe a terrorised girl would think to insist on giving a gift in that way. I thought maybe he should have stole them from her (to make him even more of a perculiar man)?
It's a good piece of writing - and I sound negative - I'm not, but I'm not going to list the merits of the piece as you seem to have had enough praise for this one already!! :-)
Steve.
Re: The Lodger
Hi Steve.
Thanks for the feedback. I think I'm happy with Mr. Ludwig having something of an obsession with people making assumptions about him and even with his using the term a lot. I think it fits in with the kind of life he has had, the time he has spent in the mental hospital, his inability to communicate and feelings of being misunderstood (for example by the landlady). As for the girl wanting to give him something for saving her, that was just what I thought she would want to do. Maybe you're right and people who have been saved from some horrible situation don't react in that way at all. I have no personal experience of being in that situation (thankfully) so I don't really know how I would feel: I can only try to imagine. The story is open to the interpretation that he has stolen her things and is now lying about it, but that wasn't how I pictured the events. As for talking about the ID card in the plural, I simply don't think that would be correct grammatically, and Mr. Ludwig is a well-read and thoughtful man who doesn't make grammatical errors.
David.
Re: The Lodger
Solid and a very sound piece, obviously technically well written regarding grammar and punctuation. But i didn't see anything that was either original,exciting or suspenseful. I thought it was one paced...some might say controlled paced, but i stick with the former.I suspected early on that we would be led to suspect the narrator of some heinous act, but i also this would be too obvious for this to be the ending. I suppose the ending where he is a hero rather than a villain is a little unusual...but i also found it a little flat, the introduction of the Austrailian student late on seemed tacked on to me. I also found the students gesture of giving memento's to her saviour a lilttle odd.
Overall a good piece but not a great piece. 7/10
Alan
Re: The Lodger
Here is a peculiar fellow,completely insitutionalized.He's phobic about anyone messing with his stuff and a not happy around bright lights.I don't imagine, in Roundways,they left him in the dark, much.Obviously violent,in nature,or they wouldn't be checking on him,every half hour.He is completely paraniod,thinking everyone wants to know his business.I'll bet he eats his meals with his arms in front of his plate,protectively.
Why would an Australian girl give him two dollars and her student I D,in gratitude, for him to paste in his souvineer album.THis man is out of touch with himself and,a cold blooded killer...len PS I thouroughly enjoyed this story
Re: The Lodger
Thanks for the feedback. I don't agree with your interpretation of his past as violent. The usual reason that patients are put on thirty-minute watch is because staff are afraid they will self-harm or attempt suicide. Of course yours was the assumption (there's that word again) I wanted people to make, and probably the one a lot of people had made about Mr. Ludwig. The second point I've already addressed.
Glad you liked the story.
David.
Re: The Lodger
Well, the business about thwe gifts I've already talked about. As to twist endings, a lot of people don't like them and often they don't really come off. If this one didn't work for you, so be it. I can but try.
Thanks for the feedback.
Regards,
David.
Re: The Lodger
I suppose it feels flat because ihave been in the same position of people making assumptions about me having spent time in pshyciatric hospitals in the past.I would like him to have been more triumphal and sticking two fingers to the world.
Re: The Lodger
I agree with you about the thinking sometimes I`ll scramble to find a piece of paper & a pen when I think of something good so`s that it doesn`t go out of my head....[this practice may go a long way in explaining the nutter references .....haha]..I`ve only written one story at one sitting and it was short......but I never know where the story is going in advance....funny or rather interesting how people are different in their approach.....cheersZ
Re: The Lodger
I enjoyed this. Not sure why, since I didn't fall fall for the assumpitions, but it is well written and kept me going to the end.
Re: The Lodger
Thanks Middle. It's good to know that it works to some extent even if you aren't taken in by the twist in the tail. Feedback much appreciated.
David.
Re: The Lodger
A really good piece, the character rings true. Enjoyed it!
Re: The Lodger
Many thanks. Glad you liked it.
David.
Re: The Lodger
Very pleased I read this. In other circumstances I could see the ending seem incongruous; not in this situation. Very well written too.
Re: The Lodger
Thanks Smirking. Glad you thought the ending worked, and of course that you enjoyed the story. Thanks for commenting.
Re: The Lodger
Excellent! Once again, a fantastic story. I like the idea and all about assumptions, whilst throughout the whole story, you leave the reader with one assumption and then finishes the story leaving the reader with a different assumption. An excellent story which I really enjoyed reading.
Re: The Lodger
Thanks very much Betty. I'm really pleased that you seem to be reading all my stories today. It feels like it's my birthday!
Re: The Lodger
Here I am catching-up on reading after an 18 month absence and I come across this gem!
This is 'my kind of story'. Brilliant!
JayCee
Re: The Lodger
Thanks very much JayCee. I hope you'll go ahead and read and comment on some more of mine. It's lovely to get more comments a long time after the event. If you click on the "Most peculiar Man" link in the introduction you can listen to Paul Simon while you surf.
The Lodger
yup, the same attitude, mine had 8 legs now and was about the size of a cookie.
good story though!
faye
The Lodger
error!!
now=though
f