From the UKAuthors Collection
Unborn smile
By shadow · Originally published 1 March 2004
Even the womb is not totally private.
Entombed
Enwombed
In darkness, lapped
By warm amniotic seas
You blink and stretch
And smile
Your Mona Lisa smile.
Unconscious reflex, or
Some strange and unimaginable dream?
This is the last safe place, yet even here
Sound waves vibrate your private sanctuary
Even here
No hiding from the intrusive camera.
Your secret smile now in the public gaze
With no permission asked.
But one thing still you keep
Held close, inviolate -
The meaning of that smile.
Which none can know, nor will you ever tell.
Smile while you can, the hungry world awaits.
You'll soon learn how to cry.
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Re: Unborn smile
I like this poem very much. (you need a full stop at last word of poem)
Dargo
Re: Unborn smile
Thanks Dargo - full stop replaced (I'm sure it started out with one, must have dropped off in transit).
Re: Unborn smile
I like this poem...Erma
Re: Unborn smile
yes, this is another good one. i don't like your ending again though! i want you to strike these lines out:
"Which none can know, nor will you ever tell.
Smile while you can, the hungry world awaits.
You'll soon learn how to cry."
and end the poem with this line:
"The meaning of that smile."
or actually, i want you to do more than that. i want you to rework the poem, making it a little more oblique, so that you slip the 'meaning' idea past my guard in the last line, rather than signposting that it's coming. :-)
Re: Unborn smile
But that sounds like work! I don't do work. (Snivels briefly) Oh all right. But not now, I'll need to put it away for a bit to mature and grow all whiskery.
Re: Unborn smile
Thanks Erma
Re: Unborn smile
What's that about whiskey?
I'm not a poet so I can't enter the debate, except to say that I thought it was very moving.
The prospect of the real world waiting to pounce however, seems very sad, when on the other side of that thin wall lives optimism and hope.
Michael
Re: Unborn smile
Thanks Michael. Whisky? Where? Oh I see - no, I was thinking of leaving it alone till it turns into one of those strange things like you find in the back of the fridge.
Re: Unborn smile
Don't loose the lines : the hungry world awaits. You'll soon learn how to cry.
As a mother I find these lines very fitting. No wonder babies cry. They've been forced out of a warm quiet bed into a noisy world.
Good poem.
Re: Unborn smile
Thanks Claire. Don't worry, I won't do anything precip - precipitititous.
Re: Unborn smile
Enjoyed this poem! It is sad how nearly every secret of having a child is being exposed. What with the new scans that can see the babys face in scary tiny detail, there is nearly nothing left. Though I must admit my little chap was sexless until he was born, he had his legs truely well crossed at every scan and I had a few.
Another interesting point you made was what are they smiling about? Recent studies showed that unborn babies dream in side the womb but what do they dream about?
Look forward to reading others pieces of your work.
Emmy.
Re: Unborn smile
Thanks Emmy. It was a photo in the paper that prompted this - got me thinking, is there no place safe from the cameras?
Re: Unborn smile
i wouldnt remove the last 2 lines either, in my opinion.. there is so much truth to that... it's all part of being human and i think by removing that the poem loses its meaning..
other than that.. i love the word play at the beginning of the poem..
you've captured that sense of "sanctuary" that you mention so well.. beautiful poem
Re: Unborn smile
me again! (sorry)
"i think by removing that the poem loses its meaning"
not sure how the poem loses its meaning. i would say shadow's got three ideas in play here.
1) the baby in the womb's privacy may now be invaded.
but
2) the privacy of the baby in the womb's smile may only be invaded at a superficial level - it may be seen, but its meaning may not be understood.
i like the way that shadow plays with these two concepts - she introduces early on the 'Mona Lisa smile', and i did not know why it was a Mona Lisa smile. that was what i wanted to know and, very properly, i had to wait till the end of the poem to find out. only it wasn't the end of the poem because shadow then tacks on
3) the world is a bad place and though the baby may smile in the womb it will cry once it's in the world. though readers may get some satisfaction from hearing this, it is, imv, a commonplace, and thus merely serves to weaken the poem.
in retrospect, i would like it if shadow drops the word 'intrusive' - cameras are by their nature intrusive, so the adjective seems superfluous, and alters the last line to 'what that smile means', such that the reader has to wait till the very last word of the poem for the meaning of the poem to be discovered.
so i would like the poem to read ...
Entombed
Enwombed
In darkness, lapped
By warm amniotic seas
You blink and stretch
And smile
Your Mona Lisa smile.
Unconscious reflex, or
Some strange and unimaginable dream?
This is the last safe place, yet even here
Sound waves vibrate your private sanctuary
Even here
No hiding from the camera.
Your secret smile now in the public gaze
With no permission asked.
But one thing still you keep
Held close, inviolate -
What that smile means.
Re: Unborn smile
Hi Shadow, enjoyed the read and the on-going discussion makes me venture a little more than a compliment.
To a good extent, I am able to relate to Chant's point of view bcoz I feel from the beginning of this poem ~ you picturise a secure, safe place -- the womb. To me the existence of the baby as a whole is the womb, and outside world doesn't even have the presence of a secret waiting to be discovered. From the darkness of that world, there is the first mystery -- a smile that can be compared to the earthly mysterious one of Mona Lisa. So for me the next important factor is the secrecy , supremacy of this smile. I feel the poet's need to compare a smile to Mona Lisa of great importance. When you refer to the "intrusive camera" -- more emphasis is given on the existing smile --- than on a future discovery of a "cry".
I am really an old-fashioned person who gives a lot of importance to the role of the title of the poem.... as it is an "unborn" smile --- the reader in me was interested in that part of the world --- feelings, expressions, existence that are still unborn.
As much the last lines have its own philosophical beauty ~ the poem suffer from an overuse of images. The poet has a good idea in those last two lines --- but may be for another poem where the importance solely shoulders on this concept.
Thanks ~ it is been a long time I have poured my thoughts on a poem to my heart's content. ~Mary
Re: Unborn smile
Thanks Marym - I'm a bit overwhelmed - never thought of myself as a proper official paid-up poet -scares me a bit when people take the stuff seriously...
Re: Unborn smile
Thanks Chant and Faerie. I do see what chant means about the last two lines - introducing another idea - I have this compulsion to tie the end up with a nice bow. I'm very grateful to everyone who thought it was worth so much trouble :-)
Re: Unborn smile
yes, i think Mary's put that very well indeed. and shadow - this poem's definitely worth the effort! :-)
Re: Unborn smile
Even though I feel the last lines are not necessary in THIS poem ~ I wouldn't ask you to loose any of these ideas. It is like loosing one's own baby!
Keep writing more~ Regards, Mary
Re: Unborn smile
Nicely done, and very true. Good writing...
Gerry.
Re: Unborn smile
Nicely done, and very true. Good writing...
Gerry.
Re: Unborn smile
Nicely done, and very true. Good writing...
Gerry.
Re: Unborn smile
Thanks Gerry x 3 :-)
Re: Unborn smile
Sorry --I had hiccups lol.
Re: Unborn smile
Don't change a single bit of this, it was beautiful and held great meaning for me, I adored being pregnant with my Son and I could almost swear that I could hear him gurgling happily when I was lay resting in bed.
Anyway.. if you do change stuff in this stunning poem not only will it become maybe a little bit contrived, but it will indeed transform into that hairy thing you find stuck at the back of the fridge... lodged in the water draining bit in-between a hair, a rather brown piece of lettuce, a small chunk of hard cheese and a mushed up dairylea cheese triangle... nuff said!!! Who's got whisky???
Re: Unborn smile
Hey - are we sharing the same fridge? Thanks Shinobi.
Re: Unborn smile
No problem :)x Don't think you'd like sharing my fridge, not only does it have a different time zone but I think things have a habit of moving around by themselves in there. Plus I couldn't tell you where the hair came from ~ ik!!! Unless it's yours? ~ grin
Re: Unborn smile
shadow, i like this one. i tend to agree with chant. i mean, you have this hermetically sealed universe and then the intrusion of the camera but still, we are inside the womb. the line: 'Which none can know, nor will you ever tell' is rather unnecessary. and then the final two lines are, like you say yourself, a bit of a bow. it may represent a truth but the mystery of the smile is far more interesting. best wishes, anthony.
Re: Unborn smile
Hi Anthony, thanks for the comment. I'd almost forgotten this one! I'd better dig it out and revise it a bit, seems a shame to waste all that good advice.
Cheers!
Moya