From the UKAuthors Collection

Shame about the roses

By shadow · Originally published 20 February 2004

Click to see more top choices

Even romance has its price

Isabelita in the flowering field
Gathering roses
Red as heart's-blood
The colour of love.

Poison mists the air
Claws at her throat.
No need to fear -
It will not harm the roses.

Morning-fresh above the clouds
They arrow across the ocean
To strike receptive hearts.
Isabelita
Keeps her eyes on the ground.

Tight-corseted in silver foil, dampened
With artificial dew, the roses wait
To declare love, or confirm it.
By night their heads are drooping
They were not grown to last.
Isabelita's head
Droops every evening
As she trudges homeward.

Isabelita coughs in the night
Crimson petals on the sheet.
They will be dead by morning.

Blood dries on the pillow.
Petals scatter on the floor.
Never meant to last.

Shame about the roses.

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

silentmemories

Re: Shame about the roses

Fantastic!

chant

Re: Shame about the roses

yup, i thought it was excellent too. the only thing i didn't like was the last line - seemed a bit of a throwaway. for my money, 'Never meant to last' would be the perfect closure for this poem.

bektron

Re: Shame about the roses

some beautiful imagery here, enjoyed it, but I -(like chant )think the last line looks a bit 'tacked on' and is not really needed.
love the line 'poison mists the air'-bek

richa

Re: Shame about the roses

This is really good. Enjoyed it tremendously.

Skeeter

Re: Shame about the roses

I'd just like to add my voice to others. Great poem, lots of good images, nicely paced. I thought when I'd read it that the last line seemed a bit redundant, then saw that chant and bektron felt the same! I think it actually detracts from the poem, because it adds something that doesn't need to be added, plus its language is more everyday than the rest, a bit hackneyed. The poem would undoubtedly be stronger without that line. Great effort.

shadow

Re: Shame about the roses

Thanks to everyone for the comments. Looks like the last line has to go! In my writing group we have a rule - if one person doesn't like something you can argue, but if two or three don't, get rid of it. Trouble is, without it the whole thing has an unfinished feel, to me anyway. Maybe rethink the last verse ...

shackleton

Re: Shame about the roses

Good poem Shadow. Smashing images. Something about roses - especially red ones. I do agree with previous comments concerning the last line though. Enjoyed it.

shadow

Re: Shame about the roses

Thanks Shacks. The trigger for this one was when my beloved bought me a bunch of red roses for Valentine's Day - and by next morning they were all dead. Got me thinking.

shackleton

Re: Shame about the roses

They go like that sometimes Shadow. I think it's when they get picked with the buds too tight and unopened. (MInd you - I'm no expert). I caught a website earlier today, which features the work of Birmingham poets. I read the poetry that you had desplayed there. Very good - I had an enjoyable time on the site. Bye now.

emmy

Re: Shame about the roses

Really enjoyed it! beautifull description of death. Death of the roses, life or in deed a relationship.

shadow

Re: Shame about the roses

Thanks Emmy. Yes, it could include the death of a relationship - I hadn't thought of that!

spacegirl

Re: Shame about the roses

Nothing left to say except I really enjoyed it especially the imagery.

shadow

Re: Shame about the roses

Thanks Spacegirl

Sabrina

Re: Shame about the roses

WAIT!!! I understood this to be a poem about Isabelita. I see the connection between her life as being worthless and the life of the roses she picks as being valuable although they were not meant to last. My understanding of the meaning in the last phrase is the sarcasm of "Shame about the roses" when in reality it is Isabelita who is dying from the conditions of the labour she has supplied to the rose growers, and the results of the pesticides used without regard for her safety.
Perhaps it is because I live in a valley where slaves are used to harvest the fields of garden produce. They do not speak English so have no knowledge of the sacks of pesticide granules they use to sit on and eat their lunches. They have no toilet facilities and must squat in the ditches. They have no washing facilities either. They work from sun up to sun down and are not paid. They are promised.
I found this poem very deep, perhaps, it escapes others, perhaps I am totoally wrong....

Michel

Re: Shame about the roses

(Personally, I loved the last line. I'm glad to hear it supported like this!)

shadow

Re: Shame about the roses

You got it - that is exactly what I had in mind! Thanks.

shadow

Re: Shame about the roses

Thanks Michel (I need all the support I can get!).

RoseRed

Re: Shame about the roses

I got the feeling, apparently wrong, that the poem was trying to make the point that the life of the roses was more important than the Isabelita's life. I thought the last line was a perfect ending to it. The final push to make the poem understood. Never mind the life of the girl, it is a shame the roses died. Personally, I would leave the line in. Great piece, by the way, Shadow.

RR

Gee

Re: Shame about the roses

Wonderful poem. Isn't it terrible that we value roses over the health of a human being?
I particularly liked this part -
"Poison mists the air
Claws at her throat.
No need to fear -
It will not harm the roses."
For me, it really summed up the feeling behind the poem.

shadow

Re: Shame about the roses

No you were right, Rose, that is the point I was trying to make. Thanks for comment :-)

shadow

Re: Shame about the roses

Thanks Gee, really glad you liked it.

Gerry

Re: Shame about the roses

Before I read the comments on this, I was thinking what a great finish.

I still think so--a brilliant line.

Gerry.

shadow

Re: Shame about the roses

Thanks Gerry. When the first comments came in I started to think I should redo the ending, bit I'll maybe leave it as it is for now

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…