From the UKAuthors Collection

The Presence of Jalendu

By e-griff · Originally published 12 January 2004

Click to see more top choices

something made me write this........

what is a man? what does his absence mean?

e-griff

The Presence of Jalendu

The early-morning rush hour crowds would swarm round him, an eddy in the human tide. I saw him as a perturbation in the smoothly-flowing streets, an obstacle to avoid.

Each day he would sit on the hard stone corner, begging. For nearly twenty years I have seen him from my shop. When I opened in the morning, he was there. When I pulled down the shutter each evening, he was there.

I knew his name was Jalendu. Someone told me. I never talked to him myself.

Sometimes I nodded and he nodded back. When it was quiet I stared across at him, watching him sitting quietly. He never came to the shop. He hardly ever moved. I don’t know when he arrived in the morning, where he went when he left, or if he left at all.

I never crossed the street.

I would ask my brother, when I had been away: How was the shop and how was Jalendu? He would tell me ‘fine and ‘still there’. And so it would be.

I wondered about Jalendu – how old he was, where he came from.

I watched as people passed him, trying to work out how much money he gathered. People did not see him. Even those who gave money – I watched the movement of the arm and hand, dropping coins into his bowl – did not look directly at him. They passed by.

I never saw anyone trip or stumble over him, even at the height of the commuter’s rush to work and the tradesmen hurrying along the street. Even in the rain, to the tangled umbrellas bobbing and swaying above the crowds, he was invisible. He would don a large hat and pull a waterproof round him.

His eyes seemed simply to gaze ahead. I rarely saw an expression on his face – just his nod.

When my son was small, I used to send him across with something for Jalendu. An apple, some fruit, nuts, a sweet thing. Daya enjoyed it. He was old enough to cross the road, and felt important. And he liked to give.

I would ask him what Jalendu said. ‘Thankyou’ Daya would grin. I would watch them. Jalendu would look across at me, and nod.

When Daya was fourteen, he told me he did not wish to give Jalendu any more ‘presents’ as he called them. He said it was wrong, his mother had told him so. I asked Amara what she had said. She told me I was foolish to give away our profits to an old beggar, and that Daya must learn to be businesslike, or we would starve in our old age. ‘That boy is our future’ she told me.

He certainly took over a lot of the hard work, and I no longer had to pay my brother or uncle if I decided to take a little time off.

As time went by, I began to take more time off. Amara complained, asking why I did not help Daya with the shop. ‘You can’t leave it all to the boy, he has a life to lead.’ she scolded. She and her friends were always busy chattering, filling the house. She said he worked so hard I should help him as much as I could until I had to retire. So I went to the shop more often during the day.

We had to visit Amara’s brother. His wife had died and we had to go away for the funeral. It was nearly the other side of the country, to the west, a long railway journey.

When I came home, I joined Daya at the shop. For half the day, all was as usual. Then I realised. Something was missing. Jalendu.

‘Where is he?’ I asked my son. He looked puzzled. I told him ‘Jalendu, the man who you used to take small gifts to.’

He told me he did not know, Jalendu had gone.

I waited for weeks, but he was gone. I asked other shopkeepers. All seemed puzzled. ‘Oh the old beggar?’ Eventually they would say ‘I don’t know, he’s gone.’

Is that all? Is that what is left? I thought.

So for the first time, I crossed the road. I pushed my way through the rush hour crowds, bustling past, elbowing my way. I found it difficult. I went to Jalendu’s corner, approached the place where he had sat for so long.

Suddenly, the pushing and shoving stopped; people flowed smoothly round me. I could stand comfortably. I could raise my arms. I could sit. So I did.

Sometimes now I cross the road to sit in Jalendu’s place. In his sanctum, I watch the crowds pass. I am peaceful and calm. People throw coins at my feet, even though I have no bowl and I am well-dressed. I leave them.

My wife is unhappy. Daya is unhappy. ‘Why do you do it, Dad?’

I have no answer.

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

bluepootle

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

This has a mystery that is heightened by the simple style. V effective first and last lines. The dialogue seems to be the remembrance of the narrator rather than real time, and that works very well in a piece that ultimately encourages reflection in the reader.

Good images. This seems like more of an integration for you - description, pace, voice, intent, all working together well in less than 1000 words. Me likey lots.

Michel

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

Thoughtful and fast. The story and the style work together well, and the characters and setting come to life. This is a sensible review, with my views clearly expressed, but I have to say I am still worried about Jalendu. I supposed he ... do you think he might have retired to his sister's house?... and that he might have had a home after all, but he liked to sit on that corner in peace ... like the writer?...
(although (I thought) the writer was clearly trying to live for Jalendu, fill his empty place to find peace of mind over those years of seeing Jalendu neglected, as much as sit there to escape his own life)
Very interesting, Mr E(e)

KDR

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

I'll just echo what bluepootle says. This is absorbing, gentle, yet thought-provoking stuff.
Don't know if it's 'late' enough for Voices 2, but it certainly should appear in some future anthology. An example of story-telling at it's best.

Anshu

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

Though I am fairly new to this site this is the first comment I am posting. This is a perfect short story written with a very vivid description. The emotions of the characters are beautifully presented especially the shop owner’s. Jalendu had almost become a part of his life though they hardly knew each other and at the end his searching eyes which I could visualize in the story meant that Jalendu had a lot of importance in the shop owner’s life which was carefully carved in this piece.

It is a memorable piece.

Thanks

Anshu.

flash

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

Yes that an unusual tale, nicely presented.

Not sure i like the choice of 'smoothly,' in the following line, i just wonder if there is a better alternative, perhaps even rewording that whole segment might be worth a thought

"Suddenly, the pushing and shoving stopped; people passed me smoothly, flowing past. I could stand comfortably. I could raise my arms. I could sit. So I did."

Interesting tale, nice work.

Alan

e-griff

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

ow abaht 'effortlessly' ?

idmonster

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

I agree with the other comments I've read - the style suits the story, which was thought provoking and well written. :-)

e-griff

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

Please let me say a big 'thankyou' to everyone so far. This was a new departure for me, based on comments from a few weeks ago, pointing me in a direction that people said was better for me, suited my writing. Well, p'raps they are right! I had this idea in my head - the 'absence of a person' leaving its mark on everyone. I wrote it yesterday. I have made about 6 editorial changes, the only big one being that the (now) first para was originally written third. I genuinely tell people to sit on work polish it, etc, but this was as it flowed - broke all my rules.... :-)

No doubt it can be improved, but as I wrote it I said 'this is coming out 'right first time' '. Less than an hour's work. Blimey! but to be honest, my genius subconcious (thankyou mate!) probably had worked it all out without me knowing. The resonances and connections also come out without conscious plotting on my part (the dumb. conscious me).

I was getting a bit down about writing, bit infected last week as well, so this has brightened things up for me!

So thanks to all you guys who had a go at me after the one about the meet, and the Barrow one. Cheers!

Michel

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

effortlessly's no good. Never say anything negative, haha. But it introduces effort, the opposite of the image you want, then tries to cancel it with 'less' and tacks on 'ly'.
owbowt 'people flowed smoothly round me' (rather than 'by me', which implies a distance, whereas with 'round me' they curve round him comfortably, fitting him or cacooning him in a shell-like curve, a natural semi-circle space (I think) )

e-griff

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

excellent advice, Michel, I like your serious side!

whatja think Flash?

ritawrites

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

lovely story – what made you write it (since you mentioned that it got me curious) – you know, I have a bunch of cats – it began with one she had babies, then other cats came in too – some I picked off the streets, some, just because I always leave something out in the garden for a passing hungry cat, grain and pieces of roti and bread for the birds (though the have to be careful, because of the cats) – but my cats don’t always stay around at home – they wander about – and come home when hungry or just to sleep – but all of them show up once a day at least – the main feeding time – for the past week my Rachhso did not show up – and all the week she lingered at the back of my mind – I worried like I worry about my kid – she turned up today – hurt – I think she was hit by a vehicle – shivering – and crying – (the cry of an injured animal is so distinct) – anyway, I fed her and she’s curled up now – in pain but quiet – tomorrow it’s a visit to the vet – dunno why I told you this – your story seemed to bring it on –

e-griff

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

rita, you are a fluffy kitten, (but I won't tell anybody).
thankyou for telling me, hope it works out.
Our cat, Ryder, is now 15. We 'gave' her to a neighbour when we started spending time in France. (She lived with him half the time anyway - he made a place in his shed for her and groomed her regularly. He makes movies about Railways, and he always inserts a shot of Ryder (black cat in grass, twitches ears as steam train passes)) about 5 years ago, she was hit by a car, broken leg. We had a choice. it cost £500 to fix her, plus a lot of nursing. I paid, I nursed her (he was at work) He insisted on paying, so we split it. Five years later,she is beautifully silky black, brushed every day, and he talks about her all the time. Couldn't have a better home. Mind you, my daughter brought another cat home, which now lives here (in UK) . On her way back from Portugal this year, she dumped two cats with us (which the neighbours drop in on while we are in UK) life is SO complicated..........

ritawrites

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

Sleepless tonight -- just can't get to sleep -- Racchso is watching me -- she's on a chair by my side -- I've put and old blanket and shaped it like a basket so that the hurt leg doesn't hurt -- she keeps dropping off and waking up and watching me -- she's got yellow eyes -- the other cats are all curious -- they keep coming up to her and sniffing her -- i think they realise she's hurt -- nice cat story of yours -- :)

dancing-queen

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

Griffy, I've only just come across this one of yours - and I loved it! This new style of yours is coming along in leaps and bounds, isn't it? So very different from the other pieces I read on here a few months ago.

There was only one word in it that jarred for me - the word 'Dad' at the end. It seemed to be out of character. They are obviously not an English family and the way you've structured the dialogue lends to this fact. So IMO the word 'father' or perhaps another word that would be used in this culture would fit better. Don't ask me what other words, though, as I've no idea and I'm not entirely sure what nationality they are (Indian? guessing now - and it's not entirely necessary to know) :)

Good work! DQ

e-griff

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

well, it was deliberately not set anywhere particular, although the names are 'Indian', I really don't know enough to make a stab at any detail, although there probably is a resonance throughout of what I have read and seen. If anyone can tell me a better word, I'd be grateful. I had a feeling 'Dad' was better than 'father', but beyond that.............

by the way the name 'Jalendu' means 'reflection of the moon in the water' !

shadow

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

Haven't really got anything to add to all the other comments - just wanted to say I liked this a lot.

e-griff

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

thankyou - appreciate it. It's a little landmark for me. :-)

gouri

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

The story goes well with the title.The last line wraps up the feeling of the narrator.

Gouri.

flash

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

It read beautifully until that point for me Griff, i thought i'd raise it just to see i had a point. I think Michel has given good advice and an alternative. But there is nothing wrong if you wish to stand by your original text, it's only me(really) so far that thinks there might be a better phrasing for that little portion of the story.

I'm sure you'll make a sound decision.

Alan

e-griff

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

honoured, gouri!

e-griff

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

weel, you gotta listen to the audience, haven't you? - unless I go for an 'I write for myself' strop!

e-griff

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

OK, dunnit, thanks both.........

e-griff

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

Thanks, as you know, I tried hard with this

PaulS

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

Hi Griff.
Really enjoyed this piece! Well done.
I am reminded of an old chap who used to stand in the same spot, outside Marks and Spencers for many years collecting for a charity. Once, out of wanting to keep warm or some such reason, he began to sing. From then on he became a bit of a celebrity and a landmark. He raised about a quarter of a million pounds and now resides in a retirement home. The local newspaper likes to show how he is doing from time to time.

e-griff

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

Thanks Paul and thanks for the 'hottie' much appreciated. Maybe Jalendu wasn't so fortunate...

Heirloom

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

Very good. Sticks in your mind for a while afterward - quite an achievement, I'd say, considering it's less than 1000words. I thought the ending was particularly good, which, of course, is an absolute must in something this long. Yeah, you really pulled this one off.
Well done, griff.

e-griff

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

thankyou, I appreciate it..

Archer

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

ha ha! i opened this up thinking it was going to be a sci fi piece about a desert monster. didn't get what i was expecting, but thought it exceptionally well written. of professional standard, i think.

e-griff

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

wow! praise indeed. thankyou.. :-)

CrimsonFeeling

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

This story is amazingly illogical, and reflects the oddness of human nature in a great way. My problem, when writing, is that if I dare venture beyond the realms of logic and into the way people truly feel about even the smallest things (AKA reality), I find it hard to make it even slightly believable. I like this story, I picked up a few good tips from it.

e-griff

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

well, you and me both. it was new for me, so we start equal. thanks for commenting..

sirat

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

Congratulations on the Anthology nomination Griff. This is a very memorable and atmospheric story, and in my opinion the second best thing of yours that I have read. My personal favourite is still Minna. I think "whimsical" is the word I would use to describe this one: it resonates in the unconscious even though I can't quite say why. There's a layer of imagery or meaning that slips through your fingers when you try to grasp it.
Well done!

e-griff

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

Thanks David, appreciate your remarks. :-)

woodbine

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

Hi Griff,

I think this the best story of yours I have seen. Am 'off' at present so shoudn't comment only having read it once but this struck me: in your preamble, maybe you are nudging readers the wrong way by directing all atention to Jalendu when the change, the arc of the story is not his but the narrator's change of attitude towards him. As he is aware of this when telling the story perhaps your second sentance should begin, "I saw him as" rather than "He was" , or your opening about Jalendu, the obstacle is inconsistent with your ending.

e-griff

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

Hmm, very thought-provoking. I shall ponder, but initially I think different people have read different things into it. Your way is not how I wrote it (well, I don't know how my subconscious wrote it) Your suggestion would not necessarily disturb the story for others who read it differently, so it's probably worth doing for those of the 'Woody mind-set' who may read it.

Gee

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

I thought this started perfectly. I could clearly imagine this man sitting amongst a throng of people, just somehow removed from them.
I felt you echoed this with the gradual detachment of the narator from his family.
Beautifully written.

Gillian

e-griff

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

Thank you so much - your comments are most appreciated.

e-griff

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

Forgot to say thankyou. Thankyou!

TheGeeza

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

I thought ... ahhh ... at "And so it would be." - a little bit ... ahhh. Stands out.

Other than that, fab and thought-provoking ... the growing boy. Great stuff. Even the title is good.

Well done.

Michel

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

I agree with these comments by Bee, and do much prefer the non-committal 'He was' to 'I saw him as', which introduces the narrator and clouds our vision (so to speak). I would also call it a more 'subtle' lead-in, whereas 'I saw him as' gives the reader an early judgement, hinting that that judgement is set up to be changed, and that that change is the focus of this story.
(Just an opinion, of course! but anyway ... sending it off because I think it's important)
I like Dad, too, by the way! - I think it suits.
Michel

e-griff

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

OK. I'll think it out again.

e-griff

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

Hmmm

Michel

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

Forgot to mention... I hate to say this but I do think you need 'For nearly twenty years I had seen him from my shop' since the rest is in past tense. (Instead of 'have'). It's just grammatical ...
The less you preempt the story, indicate what's coming (what happened to change the situation or in what way it changed) - the better, of course, BUT, since you use past tense and it is suspenseful -making the reader immediately curious as to why, after twenty years, and what, and how come? - then you can't really say 'have seen' which means that you still see him now, at the same time as past tense, which means that you don't.
Hope this makes sense!
(How I like to say that!
especially when it's Tense
and I've got my little brickbat -
but it's funny how it hones in
on my own shocked head
when the notion crashlands
'cause it's literally dead)

(Michel what do you think you're doing?
Darning booties? Get off the - kick!
Bang Wallop! There! I kicked him off
for you! - Michel's brother Mickey!)

e-griff

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

I'm not so sure it's as clear cut as that. and although I have not conciously tried to mimic the accents of India in any way, as I don't know enough to do that credibly, I think that at the back of my mind the phrase does have a resonance of 'Indian english' from the narrator. G

Michel

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

Yes, of course! Well - if you can have 'have seen' so much the better! and I agree entirely that it fits in with the - not accents, exactly, but vernacular - of local speech. Or seems to, just as you explain. Agreed and more!
(I did much MUCH MUCH prefer the 'have seen' - and even had that in my comment, because it was such a big point, but deleted it as confusing - so now that I understand exactly what you were doing - and I can certainly see that it fits; you do 'indeed' get away with it! - that's great! I certainly think that 'HAVE SEEN' IS FAR AND AWAY BETTER FOR THE *STORY*. Not just changing my story to fit yours - I did cross my heart wish to keep 'have seen' where it is...it makes the story all the more - underlyingly - suspenseful and mysterious! By the way (better not delete this), I like this story very much, that's why I keep rereading it, so intrigued - and I like it all of a piece, just as it is. It covers every point; clear in appearance, subtle in meaning, and perfectly faceted; not a comma more, not a word less, to not-quote Jeffrey Archer.)
Yours in need of more resonance,
Michel
Or as the 'The Diamond of Kali' put it: ...The three Thugs ceased their attack, knelt and struck the ground thrice with their forehead. Then, after many respectful salaams, they departed."

gunnerM

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

Only just found this one!
There's no way I can critique this and after all everyone else has said all I can add is...

Excellent.

An intersting point is that the story itself is less than 1000 words, yet the comments and thoughts it has provoked must at least equal that word count.
Let's see some more of this new side of your writing!

e-griff

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

thankyou! it took hours of investigation and asking other people how they wrote and edited their stories (some of it 'ad nauseam' :-) ) but coming out the other end of my obsessive learning process, I simply sat down and wrote this. It had been in my mind for a few weeks, and as I wrote more layers slipped into it. I don't know if I can do it again, maybe its a one-off. we shall see.

Omma_Velada

Re: The Presence of Jalendu

Thanks for pointing me in the direction of this story e-griff, I really enjoyed it.

I have just finished reading 'Unless' by Carol Shields (about a middle-class girl who takes to sitting on a street corner), which had echoes of the issues raised here.

Saying that, I did not see your ending coming, but found it very credible after the build-up (different ideas to wife, distant to son, job undervalued).

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…