From the UKAuthors Collection
A Man of Letters
By sirat · Originally published 9 January 2004

A love story.
=======================================
"Would you please stop chattering, Margaret?" Anthony requested, with just the right edge to his voice to ensure immediate compliance.
"Sorry, Mr. Thomas."
"Now I think you all know that apart from Prize Day we won't be seeing each other again after this session. We have talked about revision technique and examination technique and I have discussed your course work with you both individually and as a group. If there is anything that you are still uncertain about this is the very last chance we are going to have to talk about it. So I want you to consider very carefully everything I have told you, and if there is anything, absolutely anything, that isn't completely clear to you, speak up now."
He ran his eyes along the arc of young female faces, the different coloured eye-shadows, the occasional garishly painted lips, the scattering of aggressive spiky hairstyles, Margaret's dangling blue earrings which were against the school rules, Zoe's equally illicit nose-jewel which made him want to scratch his own nose every time he looked at it. Girls poised impatiently on the threshold of womanhood. There was only one face with which he could not bring himself to make eye-contact: the least threatening face of all, at the furthest right-hand end of the arc, half hidden behind long straight cascades of shining black hair, big brown eyes slightly downcast, chin resting on her clasped hands, exercise book open and held flat on the desk between her two slender bare elbows.
A few moments passed in silence. Out of the corner of his eye he saw her put her arms down on the desk and lift her head to look at him. He shuffled uncomfortably in his chair.
"Very well then. I just want to say that there is absolutely no reason why every single one of you shouldn't pass and pass well. You have been an outstanding group and I have greatly enjoyed teaching you over the last two years. Some of you of course I've taught for much longer than that. I want to wish you the very best of luck in the exam, and in whatever comes after. University for most of you I'm certain, but remember that there are other things in life besides study, and there is no disgrace in working for a living." He hesitated. "I know you can't wait to be grown up and out there running your own lives. One word of advice. Don't rush it. Take your time. Look around you and try to learn from other people's mistakes. And don't stop reading just because you've stopped studying English Literature. Don't settle for living in a single world when you can live in a thousand."
There was no reaction. Maybe his little sermons were becoming trite.
"Very well. There are five minutes to go before the end of the period. You have a study period next. I suggest you go now and you'll be at the front of the queue in the reference library."
He wondered if any of them would say anything, if they would thank him or give him a signed card. It happened some years, in the final session. This time, it didn't. They collected their books and started to file out of the room, chattering as usual. "Oh, Ruth, could you stay behind for a moment please?" He said it as casually as he could as she rose to her feet, but Margaret seemed to sense something and hesitated at the door. "A few things about your course work," he added as Ruth made her way to his desk. He kept his gaze fixed on Margaret as he spoke, making sure that she continued out of the room and shut the door behind her.
Ruth stood in front of him and looked down uncomfortably, breathing fast, he noticed. He felt a wave of tenderness go through his body.
"It's all right, Ruth," he said gently, "I got your note and I'm very flattered. You don't need to be embarrassed about it. It's a brave and sensible thing to tell people what you feel. You haven't done anything wrong. I want you to be able to talk to me honestly like that. There is nothing for you to feel guilty or uncomfortable about."
"I love you, Mr. Thomas," she whispered without looking up.
"Oh God...!" The words slipped out before he could stop them. "Sorry, I shouldn't have said that. It's just that, well... you must know that you've put me in a very awkward position. That's the most dangerous thing that a school student could possibly say to her teacher. You know how sensitive this kind of thing is, how easy it would be for it to reach the wrong ears. I could lose my job, and my whole career, come to that. This kind of thing is dynamite. Pure dynamite. You can't help how you feel but... well, it just isn't appropriate. You know that, don't you?"
"I won't be your student any more after today. I'll just be... somebody you know..."
Margaret's head suddenly reappeared behind the glass upper panel of the door. He glared in her direction and she went away.
"Ruth, we need to talk and it can't be here. Do you have to go straight home after school today?"
"No."
"There's a cafe at the corner of Wilmer Street, where it meets the High Road..."
ooOOoo
Anthony appeared in his long dark overcoat, carrying his bulging briefcase and smiled sheepishly in Ruth's direction. "You got here before me, I see," he greeted her uncomfortably. She nodded. "Could we sit over there?" He motioned towards a secluded table with bench seating. "You haven't ordered anything yet, have you?" She shook her head and picked up her satchel. They made their way to the chosen table, her hand brushing against his as they walked, sending a shudder through his body. They sat alongside one another on the padded bench, Ruth next the wall and almost hidden by his greater bulk. A lurking waitress monitored their movements and followed them to the table. "A cappuccino for me," he said brightly, "and you have whatever you like, Ruth. My treat."
"The same..."
"Are you sure you wouldn't like one of those cream buns they have in the window as well?" he urged with a smile.
"Oh... all right then." She gave him the prettiest smile she had ever given him. He felt a bead of sweat come to his forehead. The waitress nodded and withdrew.
"You're going to tell me I'm a silly kid, aren't you? That it could never work out?" Her smile faded as she waited apprehensively for his reply.
"Do you know how old I am, Ruth? I'm forty-one. You've passed your GCSE maths. How many years are there between us?"
"It doesn't make any difference. I don't care. I don't care about anything else except... being with you."
"Oh Ruth! This is so painful for both of us. Look, what you're going through is perfectly normal and healthy. Everybody has a need for love... for... intimate relationships. And it takes each of us a long time - decades, even - to find the right person. Some of us never find that person. We think we have, many times perhaps, and each time that we get it wrong it's extremely painful, not only for ourselves but for the other person as well, because it's not their fault that they're wrong for us. That's what being a young adult is all about. It's what three quarters of literature is all about. Perfectly decent and well-meaning people hurting one another because they're not right for each other. It's something you're going to go through again and again. Something everyone goes through. I can't protect you from it. All I can do is save you from this one particular mistake. Because it is a mistake. Nobody in their right mind would countenance what you're proposing. It's a total impossibility. I'm sorry but it is."
He wasn't sure if she was taking it well or not. She looked him straight in the eye and her chin began to tremble slightly. Her face was very pretty, he found himself thinking, not for the first time. Delicate, regular features. High cheek-bones, the perfect even white teeth of the fluoride generation, dark brown eyes slanted into the hint of a V, as though she might have a trace of Oriental blood in her distant ancestry. What she said next surprised him. It came as a blow beneath the belt. "Have you found the right person?"
Slightly flustered, he stumbled over the words. "I'm a married man. You know that."
"That wasn't what I asked you."
Out of the corner of his eye he saw the waitress approach with a tray. It gave him a little thinking time, an excuse to sit for a few moments in silence. His thoughts darted back to his own student days, to furtive kisses on the stairway outside somebody's room in the Halls of Residence, fumblings in the back seats of taxis and other people's cars, tearful goodbyes on the platform as the train taking him home was about to leave, promises of eternal love. The waitress delivered the coffees and the cream bun, seemed to glance disapprovingly in his direction, and left. He tasted his coffee.
"Ruth, you've been totally open and honest with me, so I'm not going to lie to you. What Marcia and I have now is no longer a marriage. Or any other kind of relationship. We live in the same house, that's all. We're polite to one another, we keep out of each other's way, avoid conflict. I can't remember the last time we had a serious conversation. We just co-exist. So, no, I haven't found the right person, and I've given up imagining that I might."
"That's very sad." Ruth took a delicate bite from her bun. "Why did you marry her? Did you love her once?"
"You know I can't believe that I'm sitting here telling you all this. I must be insane." He hesitated. "The truth is, I don't ever remember being in love with Marcia. Or asking her to marry me either. She was the daughter of my mother's best friend. When I was little my mother and her mother used to share looking after the children. They used to take it in turns for one of them to have both of us so that each of them could work a few days each week. Yes, that's something we have in common, you and I. We were both brought up by single-parent mothers. My Father left when I was five, I don't really remember him. Anyway, Marcia and I spent half our lives together when we were little and as we grew up it just became assumed, somehow, that we would marry. Our mothers were booking a church for the wedding and a hotel for the reception before it had really sunk in that we were engaged."
"Why did you go along with it if it wasn't what you wanted?"
He sighed. "That's not an easy question. My mother had a very powerful personality... and I didn't really know what I wanted back then. I'd just come out of a very unhappy love affair with somebody at the University... the first real girlfriend I'd ever had... and I needed somebody... or something. A shoulder to cry on, maybe. And Marcia was there. An easy option."
"Do you like easy options?" she asked, taking another bite of her bun.
He smiled. "I think you're laughing at me now." She shook her head to avoid talking with her mouth full. "If you're thinking that you're an easy option, you couldn't be more wrong. Can you imagine how people would react if I told them that you and I... were an item, so to speak?"
"I don't care what people think. Only what you think. Would you be ashamed of me?"
"Ashamed of you! Good God no! No man in his right mind could be ashamed of a girlfriend like you. You're beautiful, young, intelligent... and you've even got a sweet personality. You've got everything that life has to offer. The world is at your feet. Any sane man would give his right arm to have a girlfriend like you..."
"Aren't you any sane man? I don't want you to reject me, Mr. Thomas. I'll do anything to make you happy. I just want to be with you. I don't care what anybody thinks. I don't care about marriage, or sex for that matter. I just want to be yours - completely. I want to go to sleep in your arms every night and wake up in your arms every morning."
"Impossible. I shuffle about too much in my sleep."
She smiled. "I mean it, Mr. Thomas. I want to make a home for you. I want to be there for you always. I want you... to love me. Or if you can't... well, just let me love you. That will be enough."
Against his better judgement he put his right arm around her shoulder and drew her towards him. He kissed her gently on the forehead before she could get to his lips.
"Ruth, that's the most beautiful thing anybody has ever said to me. I want to thank you for that, no matter what else happens." He looked down at her eager, serious young face and slender perfect body and felt a shudder of sheer animal attraction pass down his spine. The angels must envy me at this moment, he thought, as she nestled her head into his shoulder. "Ruth, I don't know what made me do that," he heard himself almost plead. "This is wrong. Very, very wrong. I can't believe that I've let myself get into this position. You realize that if somebody sees me now and recognizes me I'm not a teacher any more. I won't have a career, or a marriage..."
"You'll have me, Mr. Thomas."
"That's another thing. Could you please, for God's sake, stop calling me Mr. Thomas?"
"What should I call you?"
"Anthony."
"Not Tony?"
"If you like. Nobody calls me Tony but you can if you want to." He paused, felt her relax into his embrace, saw her raise her hand to touch his cheek. He sensed his control slipping away, something stronger than common sense nudging his reason to one side. "You're very lovely," he whispered, almost directly into her ear, "and more tempting than you can possibly know, but this isn't real, Ruth. I know perfectly well what's going on even if you don't. What you see in me has nothing to do with lovers... and boyfriends. What you see in me has to do with parents and children. With the father, the kind loving father that you never had..."
"I had him for a little while. Maybe you're right. What difference does it make? I don't care why I feel this way, just that I do. Why does it matter so much what people think?"
"It's not just people and what they'll think. This thing is doomed, Ruth. It wouldn't last - couldn't last. You would discover all my faults and weaknesses and... how I'm just not the person you think I am. You might even end up hating me..."
"No, that much I can promise you. I'm never going to hate you."
"But Ruth, you don't know..."
She silenced him with a fleeting, butterfly kiss on the lips. He stiffened with the thought that someone might have seen. "I wish you wouldn't be so scared," she entreated, "we're not doing any harm, are we? We're not hurting anybody."
"Well, no, but that isn't how the world would see it. There are certain expectations of a teacher... rules, both written and unwritten..."
"Here's what I think of your rules." She held him tighter and planted a kiss firmly on his lips. "Maybe you're right that it won't last. Nothing lasts for ever. People don't last for ever. What if we just get a year, or even a month, of the most perfect happiness that two people can ever have? Isn't that something worth going for?"
"You're incredibly persuasive. In fact you're just incredible. I had you down as such a shy, retiring little thing. I could have imagined this of Zoe, or Margaret, but you..."
She smiled. "I don't think you're their type. I am shy. I almost died when I told you I loved you today. Writing the note wasn't so bad, but saying it right out was the most difficult thing I've ever done in my life."
"And yet... you managed to do it..."
"I might never have seen you again. I had to say something or my last chance was gone. This doesn't have to be a fantasy, Tony. We can do it. In a few months I'll be eighteen, my mother can't do anything to stop me then. We can go away together, somewhere far away. Somewhere like Africa or China or South America. You can be a teacher... you can teach English as a Foreign Language. We can live by the seaside in a little wooden house and swim every day, and write poetry. We can have animals in the garden, like monkeys and parrots, and catch fish for dinner. There's nothing we can't do if we want to. You know William Blake a lot better than I do. What did he say about the "mind-forged manacles"?
He almost laughed at her enthusiasm. "What about your place in University?"
"Lots of people take a gap year."
He shook his head in disbelief at his own naivety. "And what would we do between now and when you're eighteen?"
"We could meet up secretly. I could be your mistress."
The word "mistress" brought him crashing back to reality. "Ruth, sweetheart, if we tried to do something like this they would crucify us. I don't know exactly how, but believe me it would happen. People don't get away with the kind of thing you're proposing. Trust me, I've lived in the world long enough to know."
"What was it you said to us today, Tony? Don't settle for living in a single world when you can live in a thousand. You've taught English Literature for loads of years. You know that there is more than one possibility, that people have choices. Make a new choice, Tony. Please. Take a chance on another kind of life."
"My God, I didn't think anybody was listening to that. You're cleverer than me as well as everything else. I can't even win this argument! You're the most amazing person I've ever met..."
"And you're the most amazing person I've ever met, so we're even. Do you want to know when I fell in love with you? The exact moment?"
"Go on."
"When you told us about William Blake. You almost cried when you read some of those poems. Did you realize?"
"Well, no, I didn't think it was so obvious. I love Blake's work though. I did a dissertation on his early poetry when I was a student..."
"They're all about rules, and how they make people miserable. Didn't you notice that?" She looked him straight in the eye as she quoted:
I went to the Garden of Love,
And saw what I never had seen:
A Chapel was built in the midst,
Where I used to play on the green.
And the gates of this chapel were shut,
And Thou shalt not writ over the door,
So I turn'd to the Garden of Love
That so many sweet flowers bore.
She stopped and he finished the quote for her automatically, like a man in a trance:
And I saw it was filled with graves,
And tomb-stones where flowers should be:
And Priests in black gowns, were walking their rounds
And binding with briars, my joys and desires.
"It was my favourite poem," he finished hoarsely, "always my absolute favourite. How did you know?"
"Because it was the one that made you cry. The one that hit home for you. That told you things you couldn't bear to hear."
As he sat, silenced and motionless, she finished her bun and drank down the last of her coffee.
"I've told you everything that I came here to tell you," she finished quietly and with total self-assurance, "it's for you to decide what to do next. I'm going to be in the churchyard of St. Leonard's early on Sunday morning. My father is buried there. It's my Garden of Love, you see. If you want me, I'll be there for you. I'll wait until the people start arriving for the service."
He nodded and stood up automatically to let her leave. She kissed him once more fleetingly on the lips as she passed him by, and was gone. He sat down again, his face drained of colour, and stared into his coffee cup.
ooOOoo
The first misty light of morning over the churchyard of St. Leonard's revealed Ruth's slim form seated on a low stone border that circled a grave that was a mass of red and white roses. Anthony in his long dark overcoat walked up silently behind her and sat by her side. She did not look around.
"You're here before me again," he said quietly, "and I thought I had got up so early."
"I've been here all night," she replied, equally quietly.
“Your father’s grave?”
She nodded.
There was a pause but neither looked at the other. "I'm frightened, Tony," she whispered. He put his arm gently around her waist.
"You think you're frightened. How do you think I feel?" She looked at him at last and he saw the agony of anticipation in her eyes. He gently wiped a tear from her cheek. "I've got a new quotation for you:
Children of the future Age,
Reading this indignant page;
Know that in a former time
Love! sweet Love! was thought a crime.
They turned and held one another awkwardly but for the first time free of all inhibition. "Now I've got to find a crash course in Teaching English as a Foreign Language," he whispered as her body stopped trembling and she relaxed totally into his embrace.
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Re: A Man of Letters
maybe i'm jumping to the wrong conclusions here, but I remember when I posted 'The Way She Walks', you commented that you thought the subject of teacher / student relationships was worthy of serious treatment, which is what you seem to have now done.
I liked this, it was a sensitive piece, dealing with love rather than lust and handling a difficult subject with enough tenderness to engender sympathy with the characters. I guess the fact that the 'momentum' comes from the student and the fact that she is of legal age, makes the whole thing a bit easier to swallow than if he had been chasing her and she was a bit younger, but I think the way it was written helped in that too. There were one or two very resonant lines. I particularly liked, "That's what being a young adult is all about. It's what three quarters of literature is all about. Perfectly decent and well-meaning people hurting one another because they're not right for each other."
I think this is probably my favourite piece of yours that I've read. Thanks for a good read.
k
Re: A Man of Letters
Many thanks Kenouchi. That one of yours was probably exactly what started me thinking about this one - it's been incubating for a long time. Your comments are greatly appreciated.
Re: A Man of Letters
Beautifully written. And the story told just right.
It makes one ache for feeling, for those heady first moments of a relationship, for the possibility of second chances, and for the possibility of connections, and explorations, and sensuality, all inextricably mixed as one. Very fine. Swep
Re: A Man of Letters
Thanks very much Swep. Greatly appreciated.
Re: A Man of Letters
Can only echo Kenochi's comments. Extremely well written throughout with complimentary & well thought out dialogue.
Re: A Man of Letters
Glad you liked it Redsetter. Comments much appreciated.
Re: A Man of Letters
This is very sensitively treated and I think it almost comes off. But not entirely, for me at least. I think what it needs is more build-up to their meeting.
I say this because, if the first he knew of her feelings was the note, I think we need to understand more of his reasons for taking the risk of seeing her alone. His course of action, to protect himself, should have been to inform his head teacher or head of department.
But clearly he's tempted. We learn why in the para that begins: Ruth, you've been totally open and honest with me, so I'm not going to lie to you. What Marcia and I have now is no longer a marriage.
So here we know that he's vulnerable. But I think this happens too quickly and he makes the admission too soon. This is a tedious way of saying that I feel more is needed at the start of the story to let us into his state of mind. I would also like to see him struggling with his conscience about temptation etc. But it's just a personal reaction.
Also the topic interests me because a writer I know has twice dealt with the topic of female teacher having an affair with one of her pupils and I found the chemistry intriguing.
Re: A Man of Letters
This was ok and a solid if predictable tale, but i don't think you bring anything new to the subject.
I thought the teacher was a tad old fashioned for a forty one year old but i guess they exist...not usually your English Lit teacher though.
For some reason the actions and dialogue sound unreal in the cafe, i was irked by the teacher buying the student a bun, it seemed to me that this would be his response for a younger student not someone who is nearly a woman, this didn't sound realistic, the fact she accepts and finishes it off i suppose could be viewed as us being showed that she is not quite yet a woman and still a child in some respects.
I didn't think the cafe would be the right place for such intimacy, again i found that hard to believe that he in particular would be unable to resist her advances.
So it doesn't quite work for me but i'll probably be in the minority.
Alan
Re: A Man of Letters
Thanks, Bee and Flash. Firstly, re making it longer at the beginning, earlier versions were indeed a lot longer and I had scenes between Anthony and his wife, but I didn't feel that they were necessary to telling the story, and even with the home scenes removed it came to almost 4,000 words, so I thought it was as long as I dared without turning it into a novella. Flash, I won't write a long essay about the characters in the story but if you analyse them and their respective histories a bit I think (hope) you might see something of where their motives spring from. As regards drawing the action out and putting in more detail, again I think it would become too long for the material. Re conscience, I don't think Anthony sees himself as breaking any moral laws. At heart he is on Blake's side but the "Priests in black gowns" exercise a lot of influence in his life and he doesn't find it easy to court their disapproval.
Re: A Man of Letters
this is a very good story – I loved the way he kept treating her like she was younger than she was – which would be the way of assuaging his guilt feelings – and yet being attracted to her sensually, yet tenderly. I liked the way she behaved like an 18 year old – self assured, yet vulnerable. The only problem I have with it is that I think it would not happen in real life. The teacher would not give in – however attracted, however lonely. The last scene would happen, and they would be tender towards each other, perhaps they would even dream of a future together, but they would have parted. I love the gentle treatment you gave the story.
Re: A Man of Letters
I enjoyed this piece a lot. I liked the constant undercurrents that I felt throughout. I was waiting for some sort of a disaster to occur (and i'm glad it did not). However, I agree with Bee, more build-up to their meeting would have had a greater impact. I liked the way you've developed Tony's character.
Re: A Man of Letters
Many thanks for your comments, Rita. I am interested in your feeling that Anthony would not have given in to his desires at the end. Obviously I disagree, and when I try to put myself in his position I can see something immensely tempting on the one hand and merely "respectability" and the continuation of dull routine on the other. The only thing that would stop me from taking the step would be cowardice, and Anthony is indeed apprehensive, but like Ruth he manages to do it rather than let his only chance slip by.
Richa, many thanks for your comments also. As I said, earlier drafts were longer and had a slower build-up. What I have done in this version, rightly or wrongly, is set up Anthony's choice fairly briefly and then allow him an unspecified number of days in which to come to his decision. Since several people have made the same point I am beginning to wonder if the subject would have leant itself to longer treatment, but in common with most short story writers I have an ingrained aversion to making anything longer than it needs to be. Many thanks once again for the feedback..
Re: A Man of Letters
Not sure about this one, Sirat.
The first line put me off - "Anthony requested, with just the right edge to his voice to ensure immediate compliance". "Immediate compliance" made me think of a robot or a nazi. I think the beginnings are so important as they set expectation.
Jumping to the end, I thought "as her body stopped trembling and she relaxed totally into his embrace" was too cheesy and cliched.
I loved the school friend peering at them and the whispered "I love you". That invoked really good imagery.
I thought the speeches to his class were unnecessary. I think you could have described that simply in a couple of sentences?
I agree with Flash that the cafe seemed an odd destination. I would have thought under a damp tree might have given a better atmosphere, perhaps with the odd rain drop on her face or something?
I think some of the speech could be codensed right down. eg. the "Mr Thomas - Tony" bit. Being so awkward, he could have just said his name and she could have quietly played with it, as she came to know him more. What I'm trying to say is they seemed a little chatty - in a cafe - for such an awkward pair in such a situation?
It all seemed a little unlikely - a 41 year old dropping everything for an 17 year old without appearing to have contemplated her much at all? Or perhaps, in the romance genre, that is the objective! I would have liked to have seen him thinking about her before. In the last class of her schooling, would he have just ignored her note - unless he lusted after her anyway? Would that lusting have diluted any sympathy for him - a teacher lusting after a student?
Sorry to sound negative - just letting you know what I think! I wouldn't mind betting the longer version gives a better basis for his character. (but more unlikely to be read by the masses here because of wordcount)
Steve.
Re: A Man of Letters
Thanks for that detailed feedback Steve. I think I would have to rewrite it lots of different ways to please everybody, but I am impressed by the way it has involved people and got them thinking about the two central characters and their situation. All your points are noted and helpful to me in learning this craft. Cheers.
Re: A Man of Letters
My feeling is that it works as it is; it has its own 'reasoning' which makes the cafe and the dialogue and the awkward speech work, all of a piece. I thought that that speech and the lack of response and his thoughts about that told a lot about his character and his deep and unconfronted disappointment with his life.
To me, it came across strongly that he had thought about the girl - about girls in general (most of whom he seemed to think of, vaguely and dispassionately, as plebian creatures of a plebian world) - but especially this one. He was powerfully impressed and attracted by her.
The cafe, the fact that he chose to go there because he thought - in his inexperience - that it was a place people should meet, in public, to talk sensibly, and the bun, the waitress and the fancy coffee ordering, and the absurd 'order anything you like!' were excellent. The embarrassing kisses and arm-straddling in the cafe were well done, too.
It seemed to me that he was lost the moment she approached him. Everything he had suppressed rose up at each step to overwhelm him.
Cliches can be found here, but they abound in this kind of situation, anyway - people tallk and think in them.
I didn't think the style of writing was a strong point of this story, but I thought it all of a piece and very successful.
Glad this was nominated .... (before I even read it! Shock! Awe! Quite right, too! This will surely be a VERY (TOPNOTCH!) POPULAR STORY in the Anthology.
Firmly fixed at the outset in the familiar 'established' world of school, it soon leads us out of the frame, conveying a great deal - without telling - about life and hope and desperation; it is atmospheric, unpredictable and suspenseful. And the reader is cleverly drawn in; embarrassed by, worried about, forced to care about the characters.
Re: A Man of Letters
What can I say? Yours is the review I will be printing out and framing. You have understood the absolute soul of what I was trying to do. Thank you.
Re: A Man of Letters
The story moved at a very slow pace in the beginning. For me, it gathered momentum when she says:
"And you're the most amazing person I've ever met, so we're even. Do you want to know when I fell in love with you? The exact moment?"
And then when William Blake comes into picture:
"When you told us about William Blake. You almost cried when you read some of those poems. Did you realize?"
The quoted lines from the poem worked well giving the story a stronger shape. A beautiful ending. Well written, a good read.
Gouri.
Re: A Man of Letters
Thanks very much for the comments Gouri. Glad you liked it.
Re: A Man of Letters
Sorry, but for me this reads like an English teacher's fantasy.
How convenient that the character of Ruth is such a beauty, prettier even than the 'cool' girls. How convenient that she should fall in love with him because he's moved by William Blake (so literary!) and she has no father. "I want to make a home for you. I want to be there for you always. I want you... to love me. Or if you can't... well, just let me love you. That will be enough." Surely only in an old man's fantasy could a contemporary almost-18-year-old utter such lines sincerely?
How convenent that Anthony's marriage was a sham even from it's conception, not even a relationship. And how convenient that Anthony's realistic concerns about the viability of their relationship should all melt away into a sickly sweet happy ending.
Maybe a more interesting story would be: what happens next?
PS
Loved Laura H's amusing and cynical take on a similar setup in 'The Dilating Pupil'.
Re: A Man of Letters
Well. Pgarner, it looks like i can't please all of the people all of the time. Thanks for taking the trouble to comment.
Re: A Man of Letters
Crucially, it's a story, so about specific characters seen in a certain way, the author's way. These characters may not be typical or even 'likely'; they may talk cornball, fail to touch all the bases, be off with the fairies; they may be secretly obsessed, or shape their lives to a dream or a book of fantastic romance where people are more than just people. But this in itself is typical 'of the human condition'.
You will find the most unlikely 'leading women' in the books of Graham Greene; they seem only to exist as foils for the struggle of the inner man, IMO; but that inner man romanticises and childifies those half-baked women so that to him, that is how it is. Looking at this story - to him, our teacher, that is how it is. As for the young woman? Crucially, we don't know her past, what might have led her to dote on her teacher and - almost - cherish him, as if she understands his dream, and shares it; wants to take on that role, fulfill it. Perhaps she wants to belong in that haven of security? - belong forever to school? - to the warm, clean, yearning, trusted figure of authority - whom she sees as a boy, a younger brother, perhaps, because they are so alike? Or perhaps she has to grasp hold of that book world of beauty that exists nowhere but in that classroom? Who knows her motive? Perhaps she wants to become the teacher herself, in some way? Teachers do run off with their students, though, sometimes. I mean, it does happen. I am just saying, unlikely it may be; impossible, not at all. If you look at the film 'Wonder Boys' you will see a beautiful and clever student of around the same age attempt to seduce her teacher; the language she uses is different, but we might find (if they were not both fictional, unfortunately) some of her motives - wanting to be absorbed in and by the teacher - the same.
I like the Dilating Pupil by Laura Hird very much, I think it's outstanding - lurid, brilliant and fresh - but it is a different story, one that tells us of man unredeemed, might be one way of putting it. The convincingness of her story, however, doesn't mean there is no room for other characters in other stories to act out their own fantasies in their own reality.
In the famous 'Lady With a Pet Dog' the language of the telling, and the culture of the times is of course different but the attitudes are as cool and shallow as in Laura Hird's story; and then step by step - fantasy, obsession, dreams, hopes - begin to move in and take over. In this story, too, the woman is not so much the focus; it is more about the hitting of the heart and soul of the man. I think that's legitimate. A story need not attempt to convey, ambiguous and unsatisfactory as that may be, any more than what happened to this one -or these few - people at a particular time. No history is required, no exploration of motive. We may as readers, reject the characters as of no interest to us, having no bearing on our lives and behaving like nobody we know or can imagine or would want to imagine - we may find the story pointless; but no matter how atypical or risably unsophisticated the characters and story may seem on the surface, if that story reaches readers, it has said something true, something that speaks to the heart of the 'human condition'.
(sorry this is garbled - but it's too long to edit now! I was just trying to speak up for variety in story telling)
Best wishes
Michel
Re: A Man of Letters
Many thanks for that very thoughtful defence of the story, Michael. But I think pgarner has a perfect right to see it as shallow and fantastical if he wants to. That was how Anthony himself viewed the whole thing until about half way through the meeting in the cafe: as totally absurd and impossible. Then it began to touch his own deeply repressed yearning for the dream, beautiful fairytale and his reason (what Blake called "Urizen") wasn't strong enough to hold him back. He knew perfectly well what he was getting himself into, that it wouldn't last and that it would probably end badly, but he also knew that it was probably the last time something as magical as this was going to come anywhere near his grasp. And frankly, I don't think Ruth had too many illusions either. Remember the talk of the gap year? I didn't really want to get drawn into an "author intent" type of discussion, but could I just point out that nobody seems to have picked up on the circumstances of their meeting in the churchyard. Rita had spent all night sitting beside her father's grave. Her relationship with her mother was so slight she never even mentioned it. I don't think you have to look all that far for reasons why she might have had a crush on a kindly, rather fatherly teacher, and why she might want to play the "child" role a bit in his presence. I saw them as answering needs in one another which I tried to show, and as entering into something which they both knew and accepted was not going to last for ever. I may be deluding myself wildly but I honestly don't think that either of the two central characters in this story are bland stereotypes or cardboard cut-outs.
Re: A Man of Letters
No, I should have made it clearer that I was saying this story had set these characters 'up' so that their behaviour was consistent and convincing, but that there could be many reasons behind their actions, all coming together. The list I gave of Ruth's possible 'motives' amounted to a wish for 'family', to belong, to be secure - and the obvious role of Anthony as father-figure; but I didn't want to say it was 'just that' and try to analyse this particular story in detail; what exactly is intended. I wanted to say that we are free to judge and assess characters and we bring ourselves into it, while reading. (I agree about the churchyard! that says so much - and it is apparent that Ruth is willing, even anxious, and certainly feels free to leave her mother and any other family she has, behind - to enter into the 'dream' life with the man she knows little of, but has constructed so vividly). I certainly agree very strongly that neither of the two central characters are steretypes. That was my point, not at all well made, but my point.
I thought you established the way they were thinking very cleverly, including showing Ruth's involvement with her father - and her feeling of freedom to make her own decisions about where she went and what she did, even now - and the way Anthony kept insisting it was all a wild dream but giving into it - as he had to do.
I was saying more that this may not be a story, in itself, that appeals to your critic Garner, and that is why he rejects it as shallow and fantastical; but that is what it is about. Giving in to the fantastical, going all the way - as the main character in Lady With a Pet Dog did even as he saw his place in society, his whole life, disintegrate; he didn't and couldn't care. Something like that.
I agree about not getting into an author intent discussion, and do want to say that all the points you make are clear, including Ruth's talk of 'a gap year' at the same time as declaring undying devotion. That was 'telling', funny and convincing - and *not spelled out for the reader*. This is what I meant about not having motives explored and explained - I meant, not in so many words for the reader; I meant that they should be woven into the fabric of the story, as it unfolds, as they are in this one; with, however, room for speculation and interpretation. Anthony's assessment of his marriage, for example, might not be 'fair' in that it might be like many others - but it is clear that he is, personally, deeply dissatisfied with his life - willing to throw it all behind for however long and plunge in - the future of no real consequence in the terms in which he usually viewed it, and knew was the sane way to view it, the 'established' way of the established adult. Sorry, I'm not putting this well!
I just mean that I feel I agree with you about this story, but that I thought pgarner's dismissal of it as a simple fantasy of the author was, to my mind, not something you should take seriously as an assessment of the work. And I was arguing for a more open mind in reading - so it was a more general defence of the story and of fiction, than it was of this story. It seems to me that we could dismiss an awful lot of fiction if we decide the people in it are naive and/or deluded so not worth bothering with. If we think the tone is not overtly cynical enough. Out the window goes almost everyone.
Whew! Hope I made some sense this time - ??? but -
best, Michel
Re: A Man of Letters
"Sorry, I'm not putting this well! "
I find myself envious of your ability to "put things". It is a privilege and a thrill to have my humble story analysed by someone of your insight. I agree entirely with your general points, particularly the one about the author not enforcing his own interpretation of a story (which, whether it is the author's or not is still only one interpretation), and that of course is why I was so reluctant to get drawn in to the interpretation game.
Re: A Man of Letters
This was a very good read all the comments others have made, covered every thing that I also wanted to say other than...thanks for a good read.
Re: A Man of Letters
I’ll be brief and just say I echo the accolades of above. I am new here and this is the first of you works I’ve read…. but won’t be the last…keep them coming, very enjoyable read!
Re: A Man of Letters
Many thanks LA. Much appreciated.
Re: A Man of Letters
Bloody marvellous. Was really gripped by this story. Just one wee thing, at the start when he's addressing the class, you could maybe shorten his dialogue ever so slightly so you get into the real meat of the story quicker. Just a thought. A great read
Re: A Man of Letters
Thanks very much Laura. As you know I have a very high regard for your views. I'll look at the opening again, but I think there is important mood-setting and characterisation going on that I wouldn't want to lose.
Re: A Man of Letters
I`ve just read this on laura`s website.....excellent stuff......but your biog was a source of fascination also....I notice it has benn rated 10 and quite rightly so....hope your wee stone is not bothering u too much....all the best Z
Re: A Man of Letters
Thanks Zenbuddhist. Laura did a great job on the presentation, with all those links to books and authors, etc. If you enjoyed the bio there's a longer version on my web site.
The stone is behaving itself quite well at the moment, thanks to the Amoxycillin that's flooding my system.
David.
Re: A Man of Letters
BRILLIANT descriptions..wonderful character development and flair which is very original..not like many..You are an original thinker and writer..
GREAT work.
Re: A Man of Letters
Careful, Penprince, you'll be giving me a big head.
Many thanks for the kind words, greatly appreciated.
Re: A Man of Letters
It has been a while since I've read some of your work, this piece seems so different to your earlier writings. I find hard to believe that you wrote it.
Your style has changed. Don't worry It could just be me.
Excellent plot though. Written well.
A lot of mixed views above. I agree with some, but it's piontless to write about them, it has all been said before. At the end of the day it's about what you feel is right with the story and stick to it.
Re: A Man of Letters
Thanks for the comments Claire. It's a very simple story, I think, very little plot. I seem to be changing in that direction, less plot, more introspection, more concentration on characters. Many thanks for your feedback.
Re: A Man of Letters
This was interesting, if a little formulaic I guess. It must be hard to write anything wholly original when so much has gone before on the same subject. Nevertheless there's a certain amount of tenderness which made me want to carry on reading.
I knew straight away how this would end - for me the teacher is a little too easily swayed. I agree with Bee that a little more foundation-laying might have been interesting. Maybe if we were privy to the teacher's thoughts we could understand his motivations more. It's clear that the student is indeed looking for a father figure - especially with the way she claims she isn't interested in sex. I was amused by the way he bought her a bun and the fact that she called him 'Mr', but I ended up thinking 'silly old fool, don't fall for her'!
Good story though, has got me thinking about how I would treat the subject, and whether there is anything new that I could bring to it.
Re: A Man of Letters
Thanks for the comments James.
Re: A Man of Letters
A great story sirat. I liked the way you made the teach try to avoid the temptation firsta nd with all the sensible reasoning but then gives in to his feelings. Great! I enjoyed reading this and again it didn't leave any unanswered questions in my minds mind, as there was no questions to think of in order for an answer. A great ending. Liked it.
Re: A Man of Letters
Thanks very much Betty. This has been the best received of my recent pieces and it's the one that will be in the second Voices anthology. It's the first "straight" love story I've ever attempted, but with my usual hint of darkness at the core. I'm delighted that you liked it.
Re: A Man of Letters
This is one of yours I missed, and I'm glad I caught up with it eventually. It's a lovely story, of unfulfilled hopes and expectations; and it's romantic. I suppose the pupil-teacher thing makes me a bit uneasy, because it would always be said 'oh he's taking advantage' etc. But hey, Chris Woodhead got away with it, they made him into a Chief Inspector!! Nice story, well written and very involving.
Re: A Man of Letters
Glad that you caught up with it eventually Skeeter. Many thanks for the kind comments. Pleased that I was able to create at a least a little unease as well as the straight romance.
A Man of Letters
The comments below this piece were as enjoyable as the piece itself.
I didn't have a problem with the teenage girl's lines. It seemed believable enough to me: when this kind of thing happens, I imagine it seems right (or meant to be) to the people involved, or else why would they go through with it?