From the UKAuthors Collection
Writing different stories
By Supratik · Originally published 4 July 2016
...
Wind…
The nearby pool shivers,
The tree flutters,
The meadow shimmers;
Each, writing a different story
With its waters, leaves and blades
An essay is written on the time-stage
The draft escapes the eyes
Stays in the pool, with the tree, upon the meadow
Breaths of life live in the pages
Moving moments of experience
On that stage of time
Writing different stories.
Version proposed by Nic (ifyouplease)
Draft
The nearby pool shivers,
The tree flutters,
The meadow shimmers;
Each telling a different story
With waters, leaves and blades.
An essay written on the time-stage
The draft escapes the eyes
Stays in the pool, with the tree, upon the meadow
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Writing a different story
Absolutely beautiful Supratik.
Yes, all nature is alive and speaks. They tell a story. Sometimes just among themselves and sometimes to those of us with ears to hear.
It's one of the reasons I like working with crystals.
They are record keepers that have many tales to tell and many are millions of years old. They have seen so many earth changes. The Native Americans call stones the stone people. They understand that the wind has a voice as you do too.
One of your best works in my opinion.
Alison x
The title was perfect too btw.
Writing a different story
This is excellent, Supratik. A very clever poem.
You are comparing wind to an essay, which is particularly intriguing in the line: "The draft escapes the eyes".
At first I thought you had just spelt the word wrong, meaning a draught of wind, but when I read it again, I saw it could just as easily be the draft of an essay. If this is deliberate, then it is an incredibly clever pun.
In case you didn't know, draught and draft are pronounced the same but draught means a gust of wind, whereas a draft is an early copy of a piece of writing. That's British English. In American English, both meanings are spelt the same way, as "draft". The Americans like to simplify things!
I should say that "an essay writes" doesn't work, unless you say "an essay writes itself". Alternatively, you could say "an essay is written" (the passive).
Also, regarding the last line (and the title). If I understand the meaning correctly, then the grammar again doesn't work. You mean more than one story, right? Then it should be plural, "writing different stories".
All the best and very well done.
Archie.
Writing different stories
I agree, one of your best. My only criticism is the use of the word 'The' quite so much in the beginning.
Mike
Writing different stories
The thing is, my friend, an essay can never write anything. To suggest that it can, sounds very strange. An essay is an object which is written by the subject, the essay-writer. "An essay is written on the time-stage" sounds absolutely fine to me.
If you wanted to be slightly more inventive with language, you could say "an essay writes itself on the time-stage". This would be the only situation where an essay could possibly (figuratively) write anything. For example, if you are writing an essay on a theme that already really interests you and that you know a lot about, you might say "the essay is writing itself"...
Writing different stories
i don't know about the second stanza, i don't think you need it. saw it all without it.
it is a very good poem
yeah, i think you could definitely cut the second stanza omit the word wind and use it as a title instead
Wind's draft
The nearby pool shivers,
The tree flutters,
The meadow shimmers;
Each telling a different story
With waters, leaves and blades.
An essay written on the time-stage
The draft escapes the eyes
Stays in the pool, with the tree, upon the meadow
Writing different stories
Yes, Supratik, a poem giving full consummate joy in its beautiful simplicity, and turned into perfection by Archie, and IYP's uncanny ability to improve work further. How we need too these more spiritual and lyrical gems away from more conventionally expressed work. Feels refreshing, lovely read!
Trevor
Writing different stories
sure you can send your poem, thanks for receiving the comment in such a gentlemanly and mature way.
Writing different stories
Or maybe just call it "Draft"...
Writing different stories
Hi again Supratik,
I think the amendments suggested by Nic to be incredible!
If it gets amended I would like to nominate it but no pressure! lol
Alison x
Writing different stories
I loved this, but then I would, you have written about the nature I call my friend, and how she will share her secrets with us if we care to listen. Beautiful write. Sue x