From the UKAuthors Collection

Sweet Choice

By Elfstone · Originally published 13 June 2016

We have only the choices Fate allows us ....

Sweet Choice

This price that's paid by you who are bereaved -
This aching of tear-laden, silent grief -
Is price well paid for all that is received
In gaining soul-deep love, however brief

The sharing years may seem in count of days,
Contrasting each long hour of Sorrow's deep;
While loneliness of Death's diverging ways
Consumes all but the memories you keep.

Would you forsake companionship's delight
For fear of all that losing it will bring,
Or drain the glass of happiness despite
Knowing a mourning bell may likely ring?

All those who that sweet choice have never known
Will tell how dull the empty years have flown.

© Elfstone 16/5/16

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

Mikeverdi

Sweet Choice

Better to ha e loved and lost, than never to have loved at all

I have always believed this. The feelings of grief can tear at your heart, memories will come in time to help. The pain however will never be far away.

It's the same with pets, although not everyone will agree with this.

Great writing on an emotive subject.

Mike

sweetwater

Sweet Choice

I love the way you have captured so much emotion and heartbreak with such truly beautiful words. A stunning poem.

I know the devasting heartbreak of losing an animal, losing my beloved retriever Bracken eleven years ago runs a very close second to losing my mum whom I still haven't got over, twelve years previously, I still miss my whippet Tally, and that was even longer ago. Loving deeply whether human or animal, the pain of their loss knows no bounderies, and no end. Sue.

pdemitchell

Sweet Choice

Well thought and wrought tribute to a pal. Mitch

Ionicus

Sweet Choice

A skilfully crafted sonnet expressing grief and lost love.

Well done.

gwirionedd

Sweet Choice

An excellent and poignant sonnet, spoiled only by the archaic syntax of the penultimate line. I think you should rethink the ending. Otherwise, very nice indeed!

gwirionedd

Sweet Choice

Well, sonnets are just lines of metric verse, usually iambic pentameter, which do not necessarily lend themselves to the use of archaic language. It is simply that one is forced to rhyme at the end of the line which tempts poets into using unnatural word order and forced rhymes. I believe that a poet should resist this temptation, because it is the 21st century, and it clangs on the ear somewhat to read something written in 16th century syntax.

Poetry should replicate real, natural speech as much as possible. I mean, obviously you need to be inventive and imaginative with language, and possibly use rhyme and meter if you want, but other than that, it should sound like genuine English speech. Archaisms are false and lazy. Any guide on how to write poetry will tell you this.

I used to make the archaic syntax mistake quite often when I was younger, but now I've learned to avoid this like the plague.

gwirionedd

Sweet Choice

Yes, you do have a point regarding experimental poetry, for example. Experimental poetry doesn't necessarily replicate real speech, or need to.

But with the majority of poetry, sonnets for example, it is necessary to do so - grammatically, I mean. Poetry should adhere to the same grammatical rules that normal spoken language does. Otherwise, it sounds very odd. If we were having a conversation together in the pub, and I started putting words in the wrong order, or using the grammatical tenses wrongly, I would sound very odd to you, as though English was not my native language. Well, the same is true for poetry.

When we read Shakespeare, it doesn't strike us as odd when, for example, he places a verb at the end of a sentence. This is because we are aware that he was writing in the 16th century and this was how people actually spoke back then!

At some point in the 17th century, Early Modern English became Modern English, and people stopped putting their verbs at the ends of sentences. Modern English has a very different character to Early Modern English, largely because of grammar and word order.

16th century syntax is not appropriate for a 21st century poem. It's like a newly-built mock-Tudor house. It's not genuine, it's fake. And you run the risk of sounding like Yoda from Star Wars.

It's OK if you're writing a poem where the action is set in the 16th century. If there is some kind of artistic and historical justification for it. But otherwise, to be frank, it sounds awful. The moment I see an example of it on this website, I usually immediately stop reading, and go and read something else instead.

Just to give you a new perspective on things...

Archie

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…