From the UKAuthors Collection

Please Advise

By sirat · Originally published 22 June 2015

My response to my own challenge in the Prose Challenge forum, a story inspired by Mary Gauthier's song 'Falling Out Of Love'. My interpretation of the brief has been simple and literal.

This is the first time I’ve tried to keep a diary or a journal, or whatever this is. I don’t know how you’re supposed to do it. Marian said I should write it as if I’m the only one who’ll ever read it. But then why would I want to write to myself? I suppose it does make a kind of sense, because we don’t remain the same people. As the years go by we turn into different ones, don’t we? The me at seventeen wouldn’t be remotely like the me at twenty-five or the me now at thirty-nine. If we met we wouldn’t get on. But it’s not true anyway. Marian is going to read this and use it to make judgements about me. Interpret it all with whatever kind of skills counsellors are supposed to have. I don’t think I’m going to be able to forget that.

Writing in itself is nothing new. It’s what I do. One of the things I do. Presenting myself to other people, trying to control how they see me and how they react to me, that’s the other thing I do. That’s what acting is. Pretending to be somebody that you aren’t, and doing it convincingly. Pretty profound statement, eh? I’m somebody who makes a living, a modest and intermittent one it has to be said, by pretending to be other people. But I’m not going to get very far doing that here, am I? That’s hardly the point of this exercise. Here I have to be me, and I’m not sure how to go about that. It’s a pretty scary idea.

Okay, here goes. Mask off. Just me from now on.

I imagine, that is I presume, that most people come to a counsellor because of some great big agonising life crisis. Mental hell, I can’t go on, I want to top myself, all that kind of thing. Well that isn’t me at all, I can play that part and people tell me I’m good at it, but it couldn’t be less like I really am. When I’m honest with myself, like I’m trying to be here, most things in life leave me cold. My dominant mood, when I analyse it, is indifference. I like a decent meal, I suppose I quite like what I do (at least if the reviews are okay), I get a bit of pleasure out of sex, there’s quite a lot of music that I like – but it’s all pretty low key. I jog along now. Life isn’t bad and it isn’t good. I don’t think I’ve always been like this. In fact I’m certain that I haven’t. But I don’t know when it started.

I’m ashamed to come to you as I am, without any mental hell, no dramatic crisis, and tell you that I need help. I keep thinking of all the people on this earth with real problems, starving, dying, getting tortured in prison, sold into prostitution, driven out of their homes because they’re the wrong religion, limbs blown off by land mines, genitals mutilated because they’re female – all the people who are really suffering – and here’s me, white Anglo Saxon male with a place to live and a good education and a source of income and good enough health, both mental and physical – pretending that I’ve got problems. It’s a joke really, isn’t it? And one that’s not in very good taste.

So what is it that I actually want? That’s quite a hard one.

Maybe what I want is a cure for life. The things that happen as we get older. The passions that dry up, the things that used to be new and exciting and aren’t any more. All the stuff that used to matter and just seems trivial now. But I know what you’re thinking. I’m hiding behind generalisations. Avoiding the issue. All right, let’s get personal and specific.

A couple of weeks ago, as you already know, my long-term partner (sometimes I even call her my wife) said it was about time we started thinking about having a family if we're ever going to.

I can’t say it was a total surprise because we’d talked about it years ago, when were first together, and said that it was something we would like to do some time. But I never expected ‘some time’ to arrive, and now I think it has. For Julie anyway. I’m perfectly aware that the option doesn’t go on forever if you’re a woman and that she’s completely right, ‘some time’ has arrived.

I didn’t know what I felt about it until she actually said the words. I didn’t have any answer prepared, and that was probably the worst possible way that I could have reacted. Just silence. It must have been pretty horrible for Julie because what it really meant was, I’m not sure whether I want to go with you to that particular place. I’m not sure whether I love you that much, the way I’m supposed to. I’m not sure how much my life is really tied in with yours. It was a dreadful moment for both of us I think.

It forced me to face up to the person I really am. And what I really feel about Julie and about life. And when I do that, what do I see? A kind of greyness. I’m living day to day according to routines. I don’t think it would look that way to an outsider because my life contains quite a lot of variety but it’s what I’m doing. Even if I’m away touring, which doesn’t happen so often now because so much theatre is London-based, I’m living by habits. What time I get up in the morning, what brand of shower-gel I use, what I have for my breakfast, what I say when I phone Julie, how I relate to her when she’s there, how I avoid doing or saying things that irritate her, the whole role that I play – it’s completely constant. A part I’ve played for years, over-learned, over-rehearsed, as automatic as locking the door when I leave the house.

Now there’s something not right about that, isn’t there? That’s not what being in a relationship (I can’t bear to say ‘being in love’) is supposed to be like, is it? Julie and I have sex, on average maybe about once or twice a month, and we don’t mind sharing each other’s cups or seeing each other naked, but apart from that we could be flat-mates. There’s something quite wrong about that. After all, we’re still in our thirties, not our sixties or our nineties. The relationship, whatever that phrase means, should be more important. There should be fire, passion, lust, adoration – all the things I’m so good at faking, if the reviews are honest. Do I fake them for Julie? Of course not. She’d see through me in the blink of an eye. We just get along. And we do get along, in a way that’s the hard part. If we didn’t, if we had flaming rows every day, we could just say ‘This isn’t working’, and move on while there’s still time for both of us. But we do get along.

I think I could understand it better if there was someone else I had a crush on (there’s an old-fashioned word), somebody I lusted after, but I think it’s years since I’ve lusted after anybody. That feels wrong too. Maybe there’s just something wrong with me, something organic, low libido – it’s a recognised condition, isn’t it?

Does Julie lust after people? That’s an interesting question. I’m sure she would say no if I asked her, but I don’t really know. How would I feel if I came home one night and she told me there was somebody else? How would I react? Would I just go silent again? I’m honestly not sure. The phrase that jumps into my head is: ‘It’s about time! Go for it, girl!’ Now I’m being flippant I suppose. But I do feel guilty about using-up the best years of her life (for want of a better way of putting it) without really feeling the way I’m supposed to feel, or giving anything back in return. Julie is on to a loser with me and that’s unfair.

Does Julie love me? Another interesting question, and again I think she would say yes if I asked her, but I haven't asked her. Not for years. Maybe she would hesitate too, like I did with the babies question. Who knows.

I think I’ve almost talked myself into wishing she would go. Have babies with somebody who wants babies. She could even be a single mum if she wanted to, she’s the kind of person who would excel at that, she’s so capable, so self-sufficient.

Then there’s the third person in all this to consider. The potential baby. Are we the kind of couple who ought to be in charge of an infant? I’ve no doubt we would jog along like we always do and the child would be basically all right, but I would be a pretty appalling father. Julie would be a single mum whether we were together or not. Doesn’t she see that, I wonder? What do I know, or care really, about bringing up children? It would be Julie’s project, like when she wanted to have an allotment, not mine. Now that would be just downright wrong.

It was Julie’s idea that I should come and talk to you. I think she sees your role as the person who’s going to remove all my misgivings and bring me to my senses, help me to grow up and see that the time has come to start a family. She isn’t used to not getting her own way. I suppose I’m not either. But this is something too important to be bullied into or out of. This is the rest of our lives.

I don’t want to hurt Julie in any way. I have never had a serious row with her and she has stood by me through about fifteen years of personal and professional shit. She’s my best friend and the first one I would turn to in any kind of crisis that I can imagine. She is, in absolute honesty, the nicest person I have ever known. The only little problem is, I don’t think I’m in love with her.

Please advise.

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

bluepootle

Please Advise

What an interesting look into somebody's life, and their own passivity. I think that's really difficult to do from a writing perspective because very passive characters tend to turn us off, but the diary format (which he warms to in the act of writing, which appeals) and his honesty overcomes that. Written characters are often going forth, shaping destiny, but I think the truth about all of us is probably more accurately recorded here. How many things do we actually feel in that heightened emotional state that we come across in films and books?

I also really like the ending. The lack of easy solution highlighted in two words.

The sentence: 'It was a dreadful moment for both of us I think. ' I'm not so keen on, only because I wonder if that sentiment wouldn't be better captured by describing her actions/response at that moment to bring it to life. Because its such an introspective piece just one moment of real descriptive power could be incredibly effective. But overall it's a very involving and honest piece, and I enjoyed it.

sirat

Please Advise

Many thanks to whoever nominated Please Advise for the Anthology. Much appreciated.

TheBigBadG

Please Advise

It's a valuable and honest take on the breakup conundrum, one which I appreciate more because it eschews the easier routes (in terms of storytelling) of drama and conflict. There's a lot of truth in this, about slowly winding down to a state of mutual appreciation and love with passion absent. The second half in particular works well because it presents the complexities of the situation in hand with the complexities of the character. He's heavily conflicted and in search of the truth for both their sakes, but it's a subtle distinction he's questioning.

For me it really started unfurling around the point of 'Maybe what I want is a cure for life...' In fact, I wonder if you could reduce the preamble to that a bit? Keeping the talk of the counsellors is fine with me but I felt the para starting 'I’m ashamed to come to you as I am...' didn't add so much. It's a bit 'There are children starving in Africa' which feels a bit obvious, sells the rest of it short a bit. I do like the way je's talking himself into dealing with it, so I'm not suggesting cutting the lot, but maybe some so he's still caught up in doubt but gets to the point more quickly.

Also, agreed, great last line. I can see him putting the full stop there, putting the pen down and staring at it. Clear as day.

Mikeverdi

Please Advise

I found this utterly absorbing from start to finish. I'm not to bright with all the stuff that others pick up on, I just want a believable story told in a way I can understand and relate to. This was it. You tell a story well David and thanks for posting.

Mike

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…