From the UKAuthors Collection

My Responses to Some Site Member’s Comments

By e-griff · Originally published 14 November 2003

<IMG src="http://www.ukauthors.com/images/articles/star.jpg" Many of us get comments. Not all of us respond as fully and as publicly as this. A lesson to us all!

e-griff

I have been frequenting this site for some time now. In looking back at the acclaim I have received from the majority of you, the intelligent and perceptive ones, I guess (you know who you are! :-) ), I decided to pay my respects to certain individuals out there who have helped me on my highly successful journey. It is probably tempting to lesser souls who stand near the “pinnacle of their craft” (Wembley Minorities Newsletter, 1994) to look down on those masses from which they have risen and to forget the help they have been given. Let me say to you all, here and now that I do not forget that a fine, pure, soaring talent such as mine is supported and held aloft thanks to the stagnant dross it leaves behind. So it is to you I owe all, I will never forget you, nor am I intending to leave this site where it has given me so much pleasure to uplift, educate and entertain you in a manner you can rarely have experienced in your hum-drum lives.

OK, special mentions now:-

Thanks to Ewan Thomas (Dicky), for his masterly 300-word observations on my four line poem, ‘mouse’. Having spotted onomatopoeia in the third line, and a demi-alliteration in the fourth, Ewan went on to dissect every last syllable of the poem. In the metre, he found a second level quasi-ambivalent resonance that I had completely missed! Such is the measure of the man, he deftly twisted this fault into a virtue with a masterly suggestion to change ‘my’ to ‘our’ in the third line, which transformed the wavering toroidalistic mensuality of the central section into a proto-ballad of the finest provenance. His suggestions on rhyme were apposite, cutting straight to the heart of my theme; indeed, changing ‘home’ to ‘house’ lifted the whole work to a higher plane indeed. And as for rhythm, his easy familiarity with the loping, lilting style he has made his own has not made him blind to other, more simple schemas such as those employed by more experienced poets such as myself. Ewan’s suggestions, in the opinion of many, have turned my simple exposition into a jewel, a shining homage to the muse herself. I am happy to allow this belief to remain for the time being.

His master stroke (it is said) was the suggestion of the complete removal of the fourth line. This deliberate unbalancing of the whole construct conjured up a Dali-esque vision of a three-legged, rectangular table standing steady despite the laws of gravity. The reader, sure in his assessment of this immaculately balanced poem, is brought to the brink of the abyss, where he stops, surprised, amazed, and gazes into the nothingness as realisation gradually dawns: – humbly, I present my poem, ‘Mouse’ :-

Mouse.

A mouse,
Is
In our house.
(no line here by intention)

(and Ewan, I haven’t forgotten the material help you gave me last year, I promise. I hope this helps.)

Concerning prose, I was both amused and delighted to receive comments from Mary Parry (Emiline). Mary is an ‘elderly lady’, she tells me, but that does not stop her from being young at heart. Her suggestion for an additional section in my children’s story, ‘Little Jane and the Ducks’ brought a whole new meaning to the word ‘realism’. Though many parents protested about the sado-masochistic nun, the multiple sex scenes, the horrific detailed description of the disembowelling of the horse, the kitten in the microwave, the man with the enormous boots who squashes the children’s feet when they answer back, nevertheless these additions did make my work valid. It may have been refused by every publisher and banned from this site, but thanks to Mary, I know my work is now honest. Thanks, Mary! (and I’m incorporating your suggestions for my rewrite of ‘Little Women’. That scene where the Doctor is shooting up in the corner, while Beth’s quintuplets drop one by one from her in a wet, bloody, squishy, squalling heap on the grimy wooden floor, is really inspired. But I left out the jackal – I don’t think they have them in North America, and I do want to retain the integrity of the original!)

I was proud to receive the unstinting praise heaped upon my unworthy works by a young member of our site, Jamie Dark (Zigsmund). His pean of praise to my poetry was humbling. I am indeed unworthy to be blessed with the talent I have, but it being the case, I shall bear my mantle with responsibility and pride. Jamie’s words ring in my ears as I write this now. For one of his age, his insight, his wisdom, his fine, keen judgement and unrelenting observation of my works, in which he gives no quarter but spares no praise, are both flattering and heartening. His discernment, literary skills and immaculate accuracy are astonishing for one of his age. How good to know that the future lies in sure hands such as his. (ps. Jamie, poetical has a ‘c’ (for ‘cat’) not a ‘k’ (for ‘king’) in it).

I have to mention the frequent comments from one ‘Bloodblister’ (he does not give his real name). Often obscure and abstruse, some would say ‘rambling’ he has certainly made it his business to aid me in my humble forays into literature. While I greatly appreciate all sincere comments, I did find it hard to understand your dry wit, Bloodblister, and your ‘unusual’ sense of humour, if I can so phrase it. I am sure all the failings are mine. Although an acclaimed and practised poet, a veteran of prose writing in all its styles and idioms at the highest level, inevitably none of us can be completely perfect, so my guess is your comments caught me on my ‘blind side’. May I say, though, that I do return your own sentiments many fold, and wish you much luck in your writing career, as I feel you will have need of it.

Now, on the lighter side, a small note for ‘Peony’, Samantha Doggett, who recently sent me a PM. Samantha says her admiration for me ‘knows no bounds’ and further goes on to suggest we could meet, ‘in the flesh’ as she so succinctly puts it. She tells me ‘the meeting of our souls in discussing your work leads me to believe that a more corporeal meeting might enable us to mingle our spirits more effectively, to our mutual benefit and satisfaction.’ She adds, ‘any time, any place!’ and asks for a recent photo and a certificate from a clinic. What she has in mind, I cannot tell. Reluctantly, Samantha, I must disappoint. One such as myself is sought by many. I promise to continue to give you of myself freely on the forums, more than many women could hope for in a lifetime, I dare opine!

Next, I would like to mention Carlotta Prinz (Stuffy). Carlotta complains that my poem ‘Esquimau’ borders on the obscene. With the best will in the world, Carlotta, I simply can’t work out how you can reach this conclusion. I make it very clear in the poem that there is a ‘great length’ lying between them as they gaze at each other. It might not be surprising that the heat of my feeling has spilled onto the page, but that would be entirely natural, certainly not ‘obscene’ as you suggest.

As to your other suggestion about the donkey in my Nativity Story, the honest answer is it had never occurred to me, and I do not think it anatomically possible. However, in order to calm any wrong feelings it may have engendered in you, I am sending a small donation to your order.

Two small mentions:-

Pedant - I think your individual notes and five pages of comments on the effects of the three small punctuation errors in my otherwise perfect 10,000 word story is admirable. – ‘long may your pen leak’ as we say in Scotland!

Wirral - I admire your tenacity. Not since Paxman met Howard has one question been asked so often and so persistently. I hope I have convinced you of the validity of the word ‘and’ in the context of the chips and the fish? Sadly, even if not, I am afraid, like Michael Howard, I must move on…

Enormous thanks to Jerome Hanks (Tosser) who completely re-wrote my story ‘Unchanged’. What a surprise, Jerome! And, I suppose, an honour. I admired your courage in changing the hero to the villain, and making his sister the perpetrator of the plot against the Pope (now, amusingly, the Galactic President, I see). I do see that the Vatican and Rome could well be a metaphor for an interstellar ship, as you so imaginatively (and insistently) suggest. I particularly liked the transformation of two of the key characters, ‘David’, the boy soldier, and ‘Secundus’ , the priest, into two space-budgerigars named ‘Fruity’ and ‘Humps’. You certainly have drawn a ‘freshness’ from the characters in your version Jerome. A very good effort, and, as you say, an ‘omage to my original. However, I must insist you use your own name and remove any mention of me. It would be entirely unfair for one of my stature to trespass on your ‘magnum opus’. You deserve one hundred per cent of the response this one gets, my boy! (Oh, and I do like your new screen name!)

Rosemary Jinks, (Rosemary Jinks) has been a continuing supporter of my work on this site, with well-considered, kindly phrased remarks which nevertheless bite to the very heart of any perceived problem (of which Rosemary identifies many, bless her). This is especially useful for an author, even one as experienced as myself, as no-one else ever spots those little things that are Rosemary’s own personal forte.

I would like to suggest, Rosemary, that from now on, you could leave the ship of my talent to sail on with its groaning cargo of your ‘bons mots’ many of which I have still to appreciate fully, let alone implement. It seems hardly fair that the weight of your piercing intellect and finely-honed critiquing skills should be for the benefit of myself alone. I must learn to stand on my own two feet, Rosemary, without your support, or I may fall from the lofty height I have now attained, through laziness. Bestow your gifts on others, my dear, I am sure they are waiting in anticipation – don’t disappoint them, please!

There are dark moments for every author. That sarcastic, biting comment which seems ill-considered and malicious, that uncaring ‘bovver boot’ stamping on the garden of your heart. All these must be borne for the sake of art, I assure you, so next time I make a small comment, Dennis , can you please refrain from the twenty-seven e-mails and fifty PM’s, questioning my sanity, the legitimacy of my birth, and asking for my address with promises of ‘visits’ and ‘parcels you won’t like’? Thankyou. Admittedly, I may have been a little harsh in places, but surely you are man enough to take it? (Unless what they told me is true, of course :-) ).

Finally, and with great pleasure, I have to address Maggie without whom this site would be a dark, desolate place. Maggie, how can I express my admiration for your flawless reading of my psychology? As you preside over the site, doling out your ‘Mega-Maggie’ awards each day to selected pieces, you know very well that such baubles are not for the likes of me. ‘Let the hoi-polloi have the baubles!’ I hear you say. ‘Hereward Taft needs none such, as he rises and soars like an eagle in the literary firmament.’

I am sure you are right, Maggie, but a thought strikes me. Most of the people here are lost, seeking guidance in their quest to become halfway-decent writers. Would it not be far more appropriate to award my pieces regularly? (as I am sure you have restrained yourself from doing each day). This would surely put other people’s work in context, guiding them to a higher level of attainment. Why not encourage the poor, lost souls in this way, by showing I am just ‘one of them’ (although you and I, dear Maggie know the truth, I don’t want to discourage them). Give their miserable little lives some hope. Who knows, it’s not impossible that one or two might one day succeed in the arduous climb to reach the foothills of the mountain that is my talent. I am here to give, Maggie! Just a thought…………..

Hereward Taft (Humblewriter)

Disclaimer: All names and characters used in this piece are fictional. Wouldn't dare do otherwise, folks! :-)

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

JeffDray

Re: My Responses to Some Site Member’s Comments

Stunningly perceptive and can I say how much I enjoyed your use or irony and allegory. Now if you could just insert a few apostrophes it would be perfect.

shadow

Re: My Responses to Some Site Member’s Comments

It is most gratifying to know that our comments hve not been without effect. (Incidentally, I counted at least six exclamation marks which were quite unnecessary. Try to control yourself, do!)

TheGeeza

Re: My Responses to Some Site Member’s Comments

I read the first couple of sentences and thought you'd flipped your lid!
Thought it was really funny and well observed ...
Nice one, Griff.

bluepootle

Re: My Responses to Some Site Member’s Comments

Can we read your version of 'Little Women'? (I think 'Little Jane and the Ducks' may be a step too far, though, even for me.)

britgrrl

Re: My Responses to Some Site Member’s Comments

To put an end to the dastardly conjectures that now abound as a result of this article, I herewith post comment to this...er...writer's work, and totally deny being the latter mentioned 'Maggie'. So stop sending the accusing e-mails and pms you lot!

Aside: how did you know my middle name, anyway?
paranoidgrrlofbrit

Salty and very amusing write e-griff.

ritawrites

Re: My Responses to Some Site Member’s Comments

Hey – how ‘bout a roll in the sack? (As you can see, I was particularly uplifted, educated and entertained by “the meeting of our souls in discussing your work leads me to believe that a more corporeal meeting might enable us to mingle our spirits more effectively, to our mutual benefit and satisfaction” bit. And think it’s a very good idea. How about a ménage a trois? :)

e-griff

Re: My Responses to Some Site Member’s Comments

Yeah! *but I'm an old bloke, married nearly 30 years* Harumphs! *but I could give it a go.*

er, ..... where is it?

Hmmm --- the tele.........

gacampbell

Re: My Responses to Some Site Member’s Comments

That's a nice gesture, Griff. My only comment on this piece would be that I wouldn't use the word 'abstruse' as it's quite difficult to understand. Just kidding - I liked it.

e-griff

Re: My Responses to Some Site Member’s Comments

Have to admit that I have been a few of these in my time!

What about you, dear readers?................

chant

Re: My Responses to Some Site Member’s Comments

very witty and entertaining. nice one, griff. ;-)

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…