From the UKAuthors Collection
A History of the Mobile Phone part 10
By e-griff · Originally published 8 May 2015
This time: I become a financial whizz, a business evaluator and tell two start-ups they are dead in the water.
A History of the Mobile Phone part 10
To read Part 1 CLICK HERE
Bids for cellular and overall, mobile business, were drying up - besides which I’d done that and wanted something new. I found myself more and more in demand for business evaluation - strategy and viability. I’d learnt enough about financial modelling to be able to draw up accurate models to predict business results and confirm the accuracy of investment prospectuses. I had to state I was not financially qualified in any report for legal reasons, but frankly I often had to correct errors qualified people had made, and essentially, although some were bright high-flyers from the best business schools, they often lacked experience so didn’t spot anomalies obvious to anyone who knew the business.
I did a supplementary report for a small consultancy about Peterstar, a Petersburg telephone company. In the course of the visit I had lunch with a senior guy from the bank who had commissioned the work. A little while later I was asked to go and see Gordon Owen, then Chairman of Energis, the telco of the national grid. We got on very well personally, he was a nice chap. He offered me a job. I certainly did not wish to be MD of Peterstar as the business was tangled up with too much, shall we say, ‘local interest’, of a not too salubrious kind. So I suggested they hire me for 10 days a month (I didn’t like to work too hard) for 6 months while we got Peterstar on its feet and then we’d see. He agreed. Part way through the time, Cable and Wireless bought out his interest so I only did 3-4 months of the contract. But as a consultant, you can’t insist on contractual terms, you just have to bite the bullet and reduce the bill. It was enough to pay for the caviar, and some other projects were floating about.
Lockheed Martin Aerospace had a project to run a satellite mobile phone service over Russia. It was a clever idea. Rather than terrestrial base stations creating ‘cells’ of coverage around them, the satellite antenna was designed to project a network of cells onto the land below. Through a buddy in New York who belonged to a small consultancy, I was called in to advise as they didn’t have the firepower to handle it. I took a colleague, Peter, who had his own successful consultancy, as a subcontractor to handle the marketing forecasts. The US arm of KPMG, a global consultancy, had produced quite an optimistic business plan and we were simply asked to double check independently. They were confident they were going ahead. I began to become suspicious when, talking to some of the people on the phone, they told me they had estimated market size by looking at the population size of the Russian cities and equating them with cellular penetration in US cities of the same size. Errrr ..... a lot of Americans really had no idea about other countries and wealth (or otherwise). Anyway, after working with Peter and producing a preliminary business plan, I told the principals to look in KPMG’s model for a line that said ‘terrestrial cellular’ or somesuch (I knew the US guys had got a model from the UK arm and simply applied it, maybe without understanding). ‘I bet it says zero throughout,’ I said. ‘It’s the only thing that would account for the major difference in our results’. They came back and said, ‘You were right.’ The business was a bust. I’d been round Russia and seen the growth of terrestrial cellular everywhere. But more to the point, 70% of the population live in cities, those that don’t probably couldn’t afford a phone anyway. And Russia is mostly cold. The satellite phone was not only bigger than a conventional one, but (of course) wouldn’t work indoors. No Russian with wealth would get up and stand outside in the snow with a big lumpy phone while his pals happily conversed on small phones sitting in restaurants etc. Of course, the rich had dachas in the countryside, which could be out of coverage for terrestrial cellular but they already had radio links for telephones there. I told them that I thought the best bet would be India, which has rich middle class people scattered all over the country in their estates and a lousy telephone service. They looked depressed. ‘We’re putting a satellite up for a consortium that’s doing just that.’ Ah well, at least I stopped their project before they committed too much money to it.
The second big bust was a Dutch/US joint venture in Amsterdam. They already had offices and had hired nearly 100 people. The MD was doing a good job operationally, but I had qualms about the viability. I asked for their financial/business model. ‘Sure,’ he said, ‘I’ll mail it to you.’ He did. It wasn’t a model - there was no model, no one had shown the business to be viable. What happened (and why there was a crash in telecoms in 2000) was US analysts proclaimed ‘It’s great to invest in this sector!’ Of course it had been, for wisely invested money. But there was then a flood of people just throwing money into any project. This one had got $50m to start up, and I had figures showing the ‘burn rate’, how much was being spent. I built a model, just a simple one, using inputs supplied by their marketing and technical departments. I assumed an aggressive 50% share of the market (even though there were at least 8 serious competitors) but it didn’t fly, it lost money. Even when I doubled sales and halved engineering costs, it still didn’t. When I showed it to the MD and he said ‘I can’t show this to the Board’ I decided to get out quick, I wasn’t going to be a party to that, so I cleaned up a final report and stuck my bill in. You see, from the burn rate I knew they would run out of funds in 3 months (and the business would not have even started by then) and not even rich Americans would be daft enough to throw good money after bad. They were good payers fortunately and I got my fee. A couple of months later, I read they had gone belly-up. I found it all disgusting and irresponsible. Sure, the investors were gambling, but these folk just threw the money away (after taking generous commissions for themselves, of course - that’s the game).
‘Some’ll rob you with a six gun and some with a fountain pen.’ - Woody Guthrie.
Next time: All good things ...
To read Part 11 - Click Here
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
A History of the Mobile Phone part 10
Always interesting, life in the fact lane. I was always told 'when the figures get to you...take the noughts off' though I never handled the stuff you write of HaHa!
Mike