From the UKAuthors Collection
Butch
By e-griff · Originally published 17 April 2015
A short second stab at the Prose Challenge of Monday. This one is brand new.
Butch
We were a happy family, the three of us. They treated me well, feeding me, praising me and looking after my health. It was great. The big one taught me to defend him against others who meant harm, enemies - sometimes others like him, and sometimes others like me. I would see them off quickly, they were afraid of me, and if any one of them chose to fight, I always won.
Then a strange thing happened. The gentle one disappeared, and the big one changed. He didn’t always provide food on time, and he didn’t see to my health by my exercises. He always spoke nicely but he didn’t talk to me like he had done before.
One day, the gentle one came back with a strange creature. It was a small thing wrapped in cloth. They talked to it all the time and ran around feeding it and cleaning it and going to see it if it cried out. I didn’t like it, but who was I to protest? They showed it to me, and I could see it seemed like them, though much smaller and not the same at all.
I decided to treat the thing well, and always inspected it and showed approval to them when they showed it to me. They liked that, and after all, I wanted to please them. But gradually, over a long time, I became suspicious. The gentle one seemed very tired, and fell asleep a lot, and the big one got very bad-tempered and shouted at me once or twice, which was not normal. At first the thing didn’t communicate with them properly, and only learned very slowly. Eventually, when it moved around by itself, it wasn’t normal. I decided it wasn’t truly one of their young, as I know the young can communicate immediately they are born, and move around like adults. I developed a suspicion that the thing was some kind of creature that was fooling them, sucking up their attention, especially from me, and it might be bad, an enemy.
I lived with this suspicion for some time until one day when they were both working in the garden, they told me to look after it for them and left it with me. To be fair, I had often called them when the thing seemed distressed. They were always nice to me after. The thing itself would often grab me and press itself against me making funny noises and pulling at me, which hurt slightly. I didn’t know if they were threats or praise, but I tolerated it for their sake, escaping as quickly as I could to the kitchen.
I had noticed the thing had become completely demanding and they ran around trying to please it all the time This was surely not natural. It must have them well and truly enslaved, so I decided it was indeed an enemy, a threat. And it needed to be removed. So I did it.
I thought that the enchantment on them would be lifted, that they would be grateful to me for releasing them from their suffering, but this was not to be so. They exhibited supreme distress, scooping up the thing and weeping, backing away from me. They shut the door and a while later two strangers came in dressed in strange clothes and fastened something around my mouth, and a chain around my neck. I didn’t react. I had done my job, the job the big one had taught me, and I was sure things would be back to normal again in time.
Now I’m in a car. I like cars. But I’m in a cage, chained to the side, which makes me uncomfortable. I don’t know where they are taking me, and I don’t know what will happen.
.
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Butch
It's the flipside of your earlier piece, where this time the loving dog who doesn't really understand the human situation comes to a dangerous conclusion. As such, the two stories make an interesting pair, side by side. This is more of a cautionary tale to me, short and to the point.
Butch
Weirdly I liked this better. Paragraph three needs a look.
Mike
Butch
Very unusual story. I haven't read the first one referred to but I found the build up of tension and conclusion was done very well.
Butch
Brilliant story; now I need to go and find the original one.
Butch
I was thinking of....'but much smaller but not the same at all'. Without punctuation or changing one of the but's, it just seems a little weird is all. Now it seems like I'm being pedantic :(
Mike
Butch
This is a straightforward story of good intentions and misunderstanding. I think it's clear enough that the dog was picking up a bit of ambivalence from the parents about the newcomer, I'm less clear as to whether that was because the baby did in fact have some kind of developmental problem or was just part of the usual strain of bringing up a young baby. I think that part of the story needs clarification. The dog reflects that: 'it wasn’t truly one of their young, as I know the young can communicate immediately they are born' – how would he know this about human beings? Is it dog young that he has in mind? It doesn't sound like an accurate account of human young, but you're clearly trying to tell me something when you put it in the story.
Technically the story is straightforwardly told, which I like, and the only slightly garbled sentence that I noticed was the one that began: 'I lived with this suspicion for some time but it long time later...'
The story works reasonably well. I don't think it has anything very profound in the way of content but it's generally well crafted.
Butch
I believe they did a very bad job of bringing up their dog- material for thought. I don't know whether you intended to point that out. Tragic but very well described from the dog's point of view. But sad because so much harm to dog and man come from bad training and ignorant dog owners. Makes me mad.
great piece eGriff. Well done.