From the UKAuthors Collection

Crystalline

By e-griff · Originally published 16 March 2015

For the prose challenge.

Regret and guilt.

Crystalline

It is with great trepidation I pick up my pen to write down what is, for me, in the nature of a confession. As I sit here in my study in my Cambridge college on the verge of retirement, I am minded to reveal at last the truth of a matter which I have kept secret for thirty years.

The others involved in this great tragedy are gone: Alefson, a victim of alcoholism; Rembourne, who died by his own hand, and Roger Dante, killed in the Great War, a hero. How much their deaths were influenced by shame and regret I do not know, I only know that I myself have suffered for the last thirty years and only by concentrating on academia and learning did I feel I was I able to repair, to some extent, the unforgiveable thing we did. By revealing the story now, I hope people can learn from that.

None of us ever spoke a word about the matter. And this script will only be released after my death, which thankfully may come soon. I hope we can be forgiven. No harm was intended, but that matters little when the catastrophic result of our actions is considered.

*

Alefson was our leader. A great botanist, zoologist and Antarctic explorer, his passion was searching for new forms of life. His was the discovery of the unique animals living in pools under the Antarctic ice, animalcules never before known or seen. He had single-handedly raised the University of Oslo to world prominence with his work. In all respects a great man, and as I found, a great leader.

I was a postgraduate student at a Cambridge college, specialising in environmental adaptation of life forms. I had published some papers to mild acclaim, mostly from my peers, but in the world of academia, I was a nobody. Imagine my surprise then when a letter came from Alefson inviting me to accompany his expedition. He was most flattering and had apparently read my papers and as he put it ‘recognised a like-minded soul’. I was flattered indeed, and immediately penned a reply, accepting his offer eagerly. I arranged leave of absence with my college, who were more than willing when told of my invitation from Alefson. In due course, I took a Pullman north to the great city of Newcastle and thence a steamer across the North Sea to Oslo to meet the man and the rest of the expedition.

Rembourne was a peculiar fellow. Why Alefson selected him, I do not know. His speciality was biochemistry, the structure of cells. How this might be useful, I could not tell. In terms of personality he was withdrawn and uncommunicative, quite the opposite of Dante. Dante, it seemed, had little academic standing, but was strong as an ox, very quick and smart in understanding. I believe he could have done well in academic terms, but his interests lay elsewhere. He trekked, skied, swam, dived, and numbered most physical pursuits his own. I could certainly see where his usefulness lay, and I found even in the darkest times his optimism and bold spirit saw us through.

*

We were to land in Antarctica in the summer, when the shores were as free as possible from pack ice, and there was no danger of the vessel being locked in.

We travelled from Southampton on a liner of the Peninsula and Oriental Steam Navigation Company, the Himalaya. It was a fine journey, and we were travelling first class due to the patronage Alefson had attracted. ‘Make the most of this,’ Alefson exclaimed one night at dinner. ‘For the journey henceforth will be far less pleasurable.’ He was right. Sharing cabins aboard a fast packet to New Zealand held no comparison to the luxurious staterooms we had enjoyed before.

When we reached Wellington, we took rooms in a pleasant hotel, simple but amenable. Alefson introduced us to our ship, and its captain. Captain Alex was a Scotsman, terse and serious, but one who inspired confidence. His steamboat, the ‘Venturer’ looked purposeful and had armoured bows. He informed us that he had visited the ice fields many times and we should be safe in his hands. I believed him.

It took us weeks to reach Antarctica, only stopping at Cape Adair on the way. But eventually we gazed out on the snowy expanse with vast mountains rising in the distance. An unknown land, where only a few had ventured.

Antarctica was an experience. It was not at all as I expected, which was severe chill, as our weatherproof clothing served to defend our body heat for most of the time. At first, we stayed with the ship, venturing out each day to take samples deep from the ice and poring over our microscopes to detect any sign of life. Then Alefson announced we had to move further inland, close to the mountain range and camp there in order to examine a curious feature he had found on a previous expedition and not been able to investigate. We did so, with the help of some of the crew and the dogs and the sleighs that had been shipped aboard the Venturer.

With the camp set up, the crew left us, vowing to return in fourteen days. They left with us ample provisions, and more importantly, our microscopes and other equipment that had been packed carefully for the journey. Alefson was meticulous, not a thing was left to chance. He and Rembourne shared one tent, while Dante and I shared the other. I found Dante pleasant and good-humoured, one who I divined knew more about our science than he admitted. Once, I taxed him with it.

‘Why do you reject academic study? You have a sharp mind and a good understanding. You could do well.’

‘Look at me,’ he said, flexing his muscular arms and pushing out his torso. ‘How could this body sit gloomily in a study with no sun or air, no place to stride, to run? It would be a living death for me.’

This being said with a great grin, no criticism of his choice was appropriate. I never asked again, but bore in mind that here was a thinker, not just a muscleman to help and protect us. Perhaps Alefson’s choices were wiser than I first imagined.

*

The feature that Alefson had found was a curious outcropping which could not be explained by formation of ice and snow. He explained that there must be rock projecting upwards, close to the surface, the tip of a rocky ridge. ‘It is here we might find original traces of life. I consulted a geologist friend and found that this type of rock is likely to contain many fissures and cavities. The temperature lower down, if still cold, will be well above freezing, which means liquid water and possibly life could exist here.’ While we were close enough to explore the ice-free mountain range, a previous expedition had found it barren, scoured by winds and too dry for life, Alefson explained. These buried rocks could be different.

There is no doubt we were excited. We sat in Alefson’s tent until the early hours, our conversation buzzing with conjecture, until he announced it was time to sleep as the next day we would need all our energies.

*

Indeed we did. Excavating snow and ice to reach the rock was taxing. Dante did most of the hard work, but it is fair to say that we all pitched in to lend a hand. ‘One more day,’ Alefson announced. ‘The rock is very close to the surface here, and I’ve tested it with the probe. By the end of tomorrow it should be uncovered.’

And it was. At the sight of the crystalline grey sedimentary rock we whooped with joy. But it took another few days to fully clear an area large enough for us to descend onto its surface. We could have done with more Dantes, I thought.

*

Our exploration of the rock now went on apace. By the third day, we had found fissures filled with water at quite a depth. We repaired to our tents and scrutinised each sample as Dante brought them up, dropping a weighted container on a long cord into each one. So far, we had found nothing.

Dante had been uncovering more of the rock, revealing curious formations and folds, and some large voids. One in particular attracted his interest and he began clearing snow and ice from it. After several hours, we heard a cry. ‘Come here, come and see what lies here.’ There was a tone of urgency in his voice which had us hurrying. We reached the excavation, and stopped in amazement. Dante had uncovered what appeared to be the mouth of a cave.

Alefson was excited. He urged Dante on, heedless of the effort needed. Dante responded, but even he, the epitome of manly fitness, had to take a rest. Thus it was I who finally uncovered the secret. I was examining what we now recognised as a cave, gazing at the wall of snow deeper in the cavity, and idly pushed at it, not expecting anything but resistance. To my surprise, a great chunk of snow fell back into a void behind, revealing a dark, snow-free, passage with a breath of curious warm dampness.

*

The opening led to a warren of caves, large and small, with passages between high enough to walk through, although headroom was sometimes limited. The passages had obviously been carved by running water at some stage in its distant history, as the sides and floor were relatively smooth, with only outcroppings of small, harder stones like pebbles interrupting the grey rock. ‘I wish we had a geologist with us,’ Alefson said, and surprisingly, Dante spoke up. ‘I know a little,’ he said, and went on to account for the formation of the network of caves and the rock, which had once been a sea-bed. The man was full of surprises, and as I had divined earlier, had more to him than physical prowess.

Given the history and formation of the area, we were confident of finding water, pools. This would be at lower levels, and by the light of our torches, we each took one of the several downward paths, marking our passage on the rock wall with chalk so we could find our way back. Rembourne had said he would rather not search the caves on account of his claustrophobia, so the three of us continued while he returned to camp.

The network of caves was a maze, it seemed to go on forever. Each time we broke off to return to the camp and rest, it took more and more time, and also more time to return the next day to the point where we had broken off. There were difficulties, some of the passages were a tight squeeze, and woe betide anyone with Rembourne’s problem attempting exploration of this phenomenon.

We were about to give up hope as we entered our eighth day. I was halfway down to the point where I had reached the day before when, faintly, I heard a distant shout, what sounded like a triumphal yell, and obviously Dante’s from its tone. I scrambled back along the passages, heedless of bumps and bruises on the outcroppings to the point where Dante’s allotted route had diverged from ours. Alefson was there before me. ‘Come on,’ he said. ‘He has found something.’

After about half an hour’s stumbling progress, shouting hoarsely, we heard Dante’s voice, not far away. ‘Just here, just here.’ And round the next bend an incredible sight met our eyes.

The caves opened up into a vast vault, the ceiling high above. And wonder of wonders, below was an enormous lake!

*

We rushed forward and reached the edge of the lake. The still, dark, waters glinted in the torchlight, not a ripple to be seen.

‘We need more light,’ Alefson said. ‘We will bring the lamp tomorrow.’ We had brought a large oil lamp which had been little use so far. Now it would come into its own.

Although we were reluctant to leave, we made our way back to the surface and the camp and, while we ate, briefed Rembourne on our find.

‘Tomorrow you must take many samples at different depths,’ he told us. ‘I only wish I could accompany you, but I know I should only be a hindrance with my handicap. I’m sorry.’

We assured him that we understood, and went to our beds thinking only of the next day.

*

‘There is life here,’ Alefson cried, hunched over his microscope. He was observing the samples we had collected from the surface and near surface of the lake. We had known it as soon as we were able to view the cloudy water in bright light. It contained a myriad of hitherto unknown animalcules. Alefson was in his element, completely engrossed in the new finds. We decided that the next day we would drop sample bottles to lower levels. We had tried to measure the depth of the lake, but found we did not have a line long enough to reach the bottom - it must have been over a hundred feet deep.

To our joy, the samples from lower down showed signs of life visible to the naked eye. No microscope was needed, except for fine observation of the various tiny animals that swam in the soupy water. We spent happy hours examining and cataloguing the creatures and preserving them to take back with us, on microscope slides, or with the larger ones, in small jars of formalin.

We determined to try to obtain samples from the very depths, where even larger creatures might lurk. To do so, we searched for every line, cord and rope in the camp, and assembled a great length, far greater than anything we had used that far. The next day we plunged a large sample jar into the lake, and after many fruitless tries, eventually found what appeared to be an embryonic fish in our trap. It was at least an inch long, with clearly defined features. The next day brought more, some several inches long, and in addition some kind of transparent crustacean. It was hard work hauling the line up, and each time we did not know what would appear. So many times there was nothing, but when we did find something, we were elated.

It was on the next day that it happened. Something I shall always remember and treasure ... and regret bitterly. I’d confided in Alefson that I had had some strange changes of mood as we had dropped the sample jar in our latest hunt. For no reason at all, I suddenly became curious. Of course, naturally I was curious about what we were finding and might find, but this was far and away much greater, overwhelming. I’d shaken it off, but it had resonated with me until we left the cave, when I immediately found myself returning to normal. I felt I should warn Alefson in case I was suffering delusions that might jeopardise the expedition. To my surprise, he looked thoughtful. ‘I felt the same. The exact same feeling as you describe.’ I was both shocked and amazed, and Alefson confessed he was too. ‘There must be a cause for this, some gas or emanation from the rocks or the water affecting our senses.’ Dante, when quizzed, admitted no such feelings. It was a mystery.

As we plunged our sample jars yet again into the lake, we became aware of a glow, far beneath. A feeling of discomfort passed through me, then curiosity again, then great excitement. I glanced at Alefson. ‘Yes, I feel it too,’ he said, divining my unspoken question.

The glow grew steadily stronger, and after a time, we realised something was rising from the depths, something glowing ... and vast. The feeling of excitement, and welcome, grew to the exclusion of all other emotions.

‘It’s a creature,’ Dante cried. ‘Some kind of creature.’

We could make out a shining bulk, slowly growing closer. The details were indistinct, but it was spherical. At first its surface seemed rough, but as the creature rose, it resolved itself into distinct glowing branches surrounding an inner sphere.

‘It’s like a damned great snowflake,’ Dante gasped, forgetting for a moment his manners.

And it was. As it broke the surface, we perceived a complicated branched structure, transparent and glowing, which could have been pseudopods. At their centre was a mass, its features indistinct because of the flickering light radiating from its surface . Our feeling of curiosity and welcome strengthened so much I could almost hear the words which would have been used to ask the question. I later discovered Alefson had felt it too.

I tried to answer by speaking. ‘We are natives of this world, called humans. We are scientists seeking new forms of life. Who are you?’ Dante looked bemused.

A mental image formed that was incomprehensible to me.

Here was a new life form, clearly intelligent, a truly beautiful sight. God knows how it had developed and for how long it had inhabited this underground pool.

I found a way of communicating with the creature. It reacted to my spoken words, perhaps projected by my thoughts, and I received its thoughts in my mind. It was very basic, and we could indulge in no complex discussion. And there were many thought-images I could not grasp, especially when it referred to itself. But despite these limitations, I divined a personality, and respect for the creature grew as we communicated. I would go so far as to say I believe we developed some kind of friendship, fully based on goodwill and trust.

*

‘We must learn more of this creature’s structure,’ Rembourne said, leaning forward. ‘What kind of life is it? What cells is it based on? How does it function?’

‘That is hard to tell. We can’t snip a piece off a living creature to test it.’ Alefson shook his head.

‘But we can investigate without harming it, and I have the very equipment to do that.’

I am sure we were all surprised. Rembourne pulled out the two large boxes he had insisted on bringing and placed them between us. Flinging open the lids, he revealed apparatus unknown to any of us. One box, the smaller, had a panel bearing electrical switches and a knob with a dial marked with various numbers. Beside that was a meter, with a large pointer and a dial marked one to ten. In the other box were various pieces of equipment, electrical wires and plugs, a horn-shaped instrument, and a black perforated box mounted on springs in a frame. Supplemented by two light tripods, this puzzling collection of technical devices were like nothing I had ever seen.

Rembourne seemed excited. ‘I wish to God I could get down there with you. But you will have to operate this equipment on my behalf. Don’t worry, it is relatively simple, and any of you can master it in no time.’He reached into the box, pointing to the horn. ‘This is a loudspeaker, it projects sound waves.’ Moving to the black box in a frame, he said, ‘And this is a microphone, which collects the reflected sound and measures its strength.’

Of course, we were all familiar with the telephone, and understood the purpose of the devices. ‘But what about the box with the dial?’ Alefson asked.

‘Ah, that is the key to my investigations. It is an electrical device, with its own accumulator, that generates frequencies which feed into the loudspeaker at high volume. And the meter measures the responses.’

‘But what can that tell us?’ I was truly puzzled.

‘The pitch of the sound waves is higher than the human ear can hear. It is in a range tuned to absorption by living cells. By making a series of readings across the range of tones, I can deduce some idea of the substance of this creature, and how its cells may be constructed.’ He grinned, an unusual expression for Rembourne. ‘I knew this equipment would be useful.’

*

Thus the next day, having been briefed on the detailed operation of the equipment and the methodology we must employ in making the readings, we set off, Dante carrying the heavy generator box, and Alefson and I carrying the other between us.

Once again, the creature rose to meet us, and a welcoming feeling of goodwill filled my head. I spoke words of greeting in return. We set up the equipment. The creature was curious, slightly cautious I felt. I said it should not worry, our tests would not harm it, explaining its function, and its thoughts became relaxed.

We turned on the generator and lined up the equipment on the tripods as Rembourne had instructed. The horn was pointed at the heart of the glowing mass, as was the microphone. At first, Dante set the generator tones with little incident, while I recorded the measurements of the reflected sound at each point. I was pleased to see a pattern in the levels, which rose and fell across the different tones. Surely Rembourne would have something to work with here? But as the tones climbed higher, according to the dial markings, I began to sense a feeling of discomfort. There was nothing particular I could identify from the creature, but a vague feeling of something changing, not being normal. I instructed Dante to carry out the final readings quickly, as if the creature was being distressed by the sound, it was better over soon.

Oh how I rue that decision. How I regret not taking the creature’s discomfort seriously. But it had no suspicions either. It trusted us. Never was a trust so badly misplaced.

As Dante set one particular tone, something happened. My head filled with an overwhelming scream of pain. I saw Alefson fall to the ground clutching his head, and Dante look on with confusion.

As I watched, the glowing fronds developed thousands of tiny cracks and pieces tumbled off into the water. I cried out, ‘Turn off the accursed machine, Dante’ and he did so. But it was too late. As we watched in horror, the glowing core at the heart of the giant creature began to dim. In my head one faint thought flickered - a mixture of terror, pain and questioning. Then all light left it and it disintegrated, sinking into the depths, and the presence was gone. Gone forever.

After a while, in utmost sorrow, we pitched the damned machine into the lake, and stumbled back to the surface and the camp.

We hardly spoke, except to tell Rembourne what had happened. ‘God!’ he said. ‘It must have been entirely crystalline, and by chance the equipment hit on the very frequency to resonate the crystal structure to destruction. Why did I not consider that?’

Rembourne seemed more affected than the rest of us. That night he developed a fever, and began continually blaming himself, crying out, ‘Why didn’t I ...?’

It was two days before the crew returned to accompany us back to the ship. We spent our time carrying all our samples down to the cave and throwing them in the lake. No trace of our discoveries would ever be found.

‘The snows will cover the cave entrance next season,’ Alefson said. It is unlikely anyone else will find the cave or its contents.’ How difficult for a scientist to hide discoveries. From that day on, Alefson was a different man. The spark had gone out of him, he was no longer our leader. Even Dante was quiet, his usual good humour flown.

Before the crew arrived, we made a solemn vow to say nothing of the sorry matter, the tragedy, the betrayal. And we all kept to that vow.

*

Now, over forty years later, with all of them gone and myself about to quit this life, it is proper to leave a testimony for others to read; to tell of the beauty we destroyed and the wonderful chance that was lost to communicate with another form of intelligence. What other man has suffered so much from guilt that he can never speak about? Until now, in this letter attached to my will, to be read when it will not matter any more and I can be at rest.

But most of all, in memory of a friend whose name I never knew.

.

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

bluepootle

Crystalline

I really like the formal tone here, the solemnity, and the reveal of the creature isn't a let-down in the face of such an elegant build-up. It's a fascinating construction, and I also like the fact that nothing is (for me) overexplained. You also never tell us why the narrator might die soon, and I think that works. It highlights how much of this experience remains unknown. Very strong, with the form and meaning coming together so well.

Some tiny things:

I found it jarring that you translated, in a way, the 'language' of the creature into phrases ('Who are you?' etc) I felt less might be more here, by simply suggesting that communication was taking place on a deep level rather than through conscious projection of thoughts. But that might just be me.

You've got a lot of 'deep' and 'depths' all clubbed together at one point. It drew attention to itself.

PS. Animalcules is a brilliant word. I'd never come across it before and was about to flag it as some sort of typo, but then I looked it up. I love it.

TheBigBadG

Crystalline

Yup, good stuff here. That enthusiasm you were feeling appears to be the satisfaction of getting a good one. Love it when that happens. The formality and academic tone, as Blue said, is neat here, offsetting the guilt and shame. I like the sense of isolation and strangeness during the whole sequence in and around the cave as well.

The structure is probably my favourite thing though, the way it resonates (sorry, couldn't resist) with his jealously of Dante's physicality and his regret at the results of his academic endeavour. The fact he ends up hiding in some college (I'd suggest Clare if you want to name it - tucked away, reclusive, would make a nice hiding place because only Catabrians really know about it) having travelled literally to the ends of the Earth. Fruitful setup, nicely done.

Couple of particular suggestions:

* There were maybe one or two repetitions I'd merge. The double mention of claustrophobia for instance.

* Exclamation marks - Ok, personal thing of mine, but I hate them more with every passing year. I think your words are good enough without the !

Also, one morsel for thought on a more macro-cosmic scale. I do think the introduction is a bit unbalanced at the moment largely because it's written as a letter/document. The epistolary framing is a good idea, and suits the tone very well, but maybe put something more at the end? The classic gothic - Dracula, Frankenstein etc - structure frames both ends with letters (or letters within letters), for instance. I wonder if you could move bits of the intro to the end so it gets into the story more quickly, and close with a sign-off reflection on his bleak state of mind despite living in a beautiful place, perhaps?

Anyway, good stuff like I say.

Rab

Crystalline

An excellent take on the prompt (I kept waiting for a glass model to turn up!), and I like the slightly archaic, formal tone. The unwitting destruction of the crystal creature is a good metaphor for our need to know and own everything, too.

OldPeculier

Crystalline

Very good stuff. I liked the formal language, especially with the hint of boyish enthusiasm about the trip and your traveling companions.

I think there was a little too much given away in the first section. You talk about the beauty that has been destroyed which sort of gives the game away for the rest of the story. That line might be better at the end maybe.

Either way, I think its a very readable tale and a good interpretation of the prompt.

TheBigBadG

Crystalline

You're right, you did only use one and I may have simply demonstrated my own irrational distastes. But irrational or no, they're mine! *ahem* I just find there's something unsubtle about them, brash even. 'Wonder of wonders' was ample emphasis for me.

pommer

Crystalline

What a fantastic story of a journey of exploration into the unknown.I really enjoyed reading it and I could feel the atmosphere throughout.I loved the description of the participants and the various stages of the journey especially the discovery of the lake and finally the being that appeared to be residing there, and the attempt of communicating.I also felt the sense of loss of a friend and the regret. A wonderful story well told.I also appreciated the use of formal language. Congratulations. Peter.

Mikeverdi

Crystalline

Sorry to be late. As I read this excellent story I was reminded of books I've read by Rider Haggart, Conan Doyle etc.. similar in writing style. I love the way you adopted the style and made it yours. I was a little thrown by the language transfer,the words seemed a little out of kilter; but I guess how else could it communicate. John I really liked this story, one of your best for me.

Mike

ps and well worth the Nib.

Mike

sweetwater

Crystalline

I really enjoyed reading this, I found the more old fashioned storytelling drew me in, and it was very easy to get totally caught up in the unfolding tale. The ending was almost heartbreaking, man always manages to destroy whatever he touches. Sue x

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…