From the UKAuthors Collection
Working man's hands
By TheGeeza · Originally published 10 November 2003
Seasons change.
‘She just doesn’t get it, just doesn’t understand. She doesn’t listen.’
He slapped the horse’s rump, stroked it and watched how it was impossible to make a mark or change the hair’s direction. Autumn had arrived; leaves dotted the ground and floated down the stream just beyond the wooden fence. The overcast sky dulled every colour, but threatened no rain. The chill was not enough to make him fasten his green coat. He heard the gates in the distance and the sound of a car.
‘You listen. You listen to me, Sugarbelle, and we get along just fine. Why can’t she listen? Things would be great. She used to listen. It wasn’t that long ago. She listened and everything was fine. Just fine.’
He put his forehead to the side of the horse’s stomach; he inhaled the distinctive smell: so earthy, so real and so … solid. He lifted his head, took a cap from the inside of his jacket and put it on. He felt the muscles inside the beast and watched the powerful legs and the occasional stamp of hoof. The large eye glanced at him, wondering what his next move would be. The stream had picked up speed for the winter, relentless in its motion and consistent in its noise. A spider ran up the damp fence post, over the top and out of sight; a single bird called out from a tree across the water. He removed the cap, put it back inside his coat and turned to the silent visitor.
His daughter, Joanne, took a final two steps and stopped; the gap between them was neither small or large; but it was there. She offered a smile and looked at her father’s muddy boots. He followed her gaze.
‘You always liked me to have clean boots, didn’t you?’
‘You can tell a lot about someone by looking at their shoes.’
He stamped his foot, knocking a lump of mud to the floor and then trod on it. She stuffed her hands in her jean pockets.
He kept his head down, but looked up. The stud under her bottom lip always took his attention for too long. Green hair and ripped clothes only happened on his wife’s drama programmes, or to other people’s children at the very most. He looked at his hands and found her watching them too.
‘These hands have had a tough life, Joanne.’
‘I know they have, Dad.’
‘Gone through a lot, have these hands.’
She nodded.
‘I remember when I was a lad. Think I was about … fourteen. They used to say I had girl’s hands. My dad said that. He told me these hands weren’t for working.’
‘They certainly have worked, Dad.’
‘They have … they have. I look at my hands sometimes, and I’m proud. I’m proud of being a working man and my working man’s hands. At some point they changed … I can’t remember when.’
She nodded.
‘Sometimes? Sometimes I wish I still had girl’s hands. Girl’s hands like my dad said. Soft and smooth.’ He laughed. ‘If you saw my hands, you wouldn’t know whether they belonged to a girl or a boy. Now look … calloused and old. Working man’s hands.’
‘Dad … I’ve got to go. I’m going. Won’t you say goodbye?’
‘Working man’s hands.’
He was turning them over, looking at the palms and the worn knuckles, over and over.
‘Josh is here. He’s loading my bags and I’m going, Dad. I’m going with Josh.’
He looked at her battered old boots: the height of fashion. He looked at her face, pensive and stubborn; he saw himself there, past the nose stud and the heavy make-up.
‘Has your mother put the tea on?’
‘No, Dad. Mum’s crying.’
‘Is she?’
‘She wants you to come in; you’ve been out here with Sugarbelle for hours, doing nothing. She wants you to be there when I go, Dad. Will you come in?’
‘I can’t just leave Sugarbelle here, can I?’
She looked around the empty field, fenced on all sides.
‘She might get away.’
‘Don’t be silly, Dad.’
Jo walked forward, stroked the horse’s neck and tickled its nose. The horse shook its head like it always did.
‘Show me your hands, Joanne.’
She stood in front of her father and held out her hands. She turned them over. He looked at the fingers, reddened by the cold; a silver ring on each digit.
‘Will you come in with me, Dad?’
He smiled. ‘You’ve got working man’s hands too. Just like me. Just like my father.’
She looked at her hands. ‘Take my hand, Dad. Let’s go in together. See Josh before we go. I’d really like your blessing. We’d really like your blessing.’
She stepped forward, he stepped back; he was against the horse. The horse watched them from the corner of its eye.
‘Dad.’ She stepped forward again and made a grab for his hands. He twisted and moved away. She stood where he had; he looked at the twinkling lights of the farm house, fighting against the descending gloom. ‘Dad? Dad, I’m going to miss you.’
She stood, working her top teeth against the stud, rubbing her forefingers against her thumbs, down by her side.
He heard her turn and listened to each step across the ground to the gate; he heard the gate click and close. A while later, the sound of a car starting broke the silence. He heard the driver move the car across the gravel stones, the sound of the front gates opening and closing behind it. The car moved off into the dark night. The light at the front of the house went out and plunged him into near darkness. The horse shuddered and moved. He took it by the reins and led it towards the gate in silence.
He slipped the bolt across the stable door.
‘There, Sugarbelle. You’ll be nice and safe in there, my little lady. I’ll see you in the morning.’

Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Re: Working man's hands
Wow. Really powerful.
I loved the intial descriptions of the season; that put me in a very real place when I read it. And I liked the fact that you didn't give us the stereotype of the father/daughter relationship - instead she was reaching out to him, and the parallel with the horse was brilliant.
I would say I felt the dialogue was a little overblown for me in places. The 'take my hand' and 'be there when I go' just seemed a little too heightened for me, others may not mind.
Re: Working man's hands
Thanks, BP. Glad you liked it.
'Take my hand': perhaps a tadge too much. I'll think on that one.
Steve.
Re: Working man's hands
looks like a try at yet another style for you - and a successful try as well, IMO very smooth! :-)
Re: Working man's hands
Thanks, Griff.
Re: Working man's hands
A good solid formula tale, i enjoyed reading it and thought the dialogue was good. I was expecting more spite from the stubborn proud father in the last line, i thought that lacked a little punch.
Alan
Re: Working man's hands
Thanks, Alan. Comments always appreciated.
I think he was more unable to deal with the situation, rather than consumed with spite. I alluded to that by his inability to look away from the stud below her mouth.
Again, thanks for feedback!
Steve.
Re: Working man's hands
Like the detail. The small things - describing how autumn washes the vividity out of the previously colourful world, the spider scuttling up the fence-post - always seem to count, even in short fiction, and you seem to have a good eye for these things. It makes the whole thing come alive, and isn't that meant to be the point? (Or one of them.)
In pieces like this (as in life), the characters are really supposed to say something without saying it, and if I have one criticism of this piece, the dialogue is it: Neither character is clear in what they're saying-without-saying. It's hard to read between the lines and see the thing clearly. At least, it was for me. All I got was a snatch of what they REALLY wanted and were trying to say.
Again, though, that one quibble apart, the piece was good. The setting worked, the characters were engaging.
Something of a departure from the norm, perhaps, but quite enjoyable, nevertheless. :-)
Re: Working man's hands
Thanks, KDR - glad you liked it.
Re: Working man's hands
Hi Geeza - I liked this one a lot! Like others have said, a different style for you - but one that you've pulled off well.
This story had me thinking of one of mine - Colour Blind - as that dealt with a difficult father/daughter relationship (and a stubborn father at that) - but written from a stage before this (i.e. before the daughter leaves home). I'm glad you didn't make the same mistake as me and have the father giving in at the end, though.
I think the ending works fine as you have it - although I was thinking that the father obviously loved his daughter and didn't want her to go and that perhaps there would have been a show of emotion once she'd left e.g. blinking away a tear, or something similar. That would confirm to us that he wasn't cold-hearted as well as stubborn. Men do cry, after all (although not often publicly). Just a thought.
DQ :)
Re: Working man's hands
Hey, DQ. Glad you liked it.
I think as the seasons changed, so did his daughter - he couldn't understand her any longer.
To be honest, I think if I'd had him do something like shed a tear, it could've been a bit cheesy / predictable. Walking the horse through the dark covered him in enough gloom (as did the overcast skies). Men do get upset - we are humans - but many keep it well inside.
From your comments, I'm hoping I portrayed the scene to give him sympathy and an inner warmth. To confirm it further may perhaps have been too much "tell".
Read my comments on your Colour Blind story and it ties up with what you say above too!
Thanks for your feedback, as always!
Steve.
Re: Working man's hands
I agree with DQ.
I did love the story & the displaced affection towards the horse. But I did feelt hat maybe he should've showed his emotion after she'd gone & maybe told the horse!!
She seemed to be the only one he really talked to.
Re: Working man's hands
Thanks, SG. Glad you liked it.
To coin a phrase: I refer you to the comment given previously (to DQ).
Thanks for your feedback!
Steve.
Re: Working man's hands
But that requires work!!!!!
You should just repeat it for emphasis :-)
Re: Working man's hands
By gum ... lazy. Okay:
If I had him shedding a tear (or talking to the horse), it could be a little cheesy with too much "telling". With him walking back with the horse in the dark ... the dull day (etc. etc.) - and with DQ's suggestion that he didn't appear cold-hearted (as was my intention) - I was hoping that was job done. I didn't need to tell or show that any more.
I hope you could feel his emotions without me having to tell you he was crying - or without him telling you anything through the horse.
Too easy just to have him say what you thought he might be thinking!
Steve.
Re: Working man's hands
Not a particularly constructive comment; only to say that I enjoyed the story. You've put a great deal into a short of only a 1000 words, or so.
Re: Working man's hands
Thanks, idmonster. Glad you liked it.
Re: Working man's hands
I don't often get much time to read the stories here, I'm usually picking over the poetry - but just wanted you to know that I read and enjoyed this one! John.
Re: Working man's hands
Thanks, John!
Steve.
Re: Working man's hands
I certainly think you should make the father cry – after all men a human too – and humans have emotion which they display especially when they are put in situations where the emotions are called into play. Your comment on some of your previous commentators that it would “tell” – sounds too much like following the herd mentality of creative writing gurus who preach that theory. I think, if you are a writer, then you should follow the demands of the story you are writing. If the story demands that a person cry – then the person should be shown crying, instead of following some formula that a writer ought to adhere to just because so-called gurus say so. Originality is the main criteria one must adhere to if one wants to be a writer --
Re: Working man's hands
Thanks for your advice, but don't worry, it wasn't a formula I was following; he didn't cry as I didn't see him cry.
Re: Working man's hands
Moving and perfect. I know you don't intend to, but don't make the father cry: my imagination muscle needed the work-out. Nice to read a piece which engaged mind and heart.
Re: Working man's hands
No - don't worry - I think his being upset is clear enough, without telling.
Thanks for your comment, LezH - glad u liked ...
Re: Working man's hands
A subtle, well written story. I thought the end may have lacked a little something, and some of the dialogue (particularly the father's) was a tad overdone, though one could argue that the father was miles away, in a dream-like trance, so maybe it's just me. Good scene-setting and descriptions.
regards
Steven
Re: Working man's hands
I've had another look at the end & some of the comments posted about this piece.
I think by referring to darkness and silence you are reflecting the loss but you're lacking a direct attachment to the father. You're saying, "look at this man, how he's plunged into gloom". What you're NOT saying is "look at this man, plunged into gloom, this is how he feels about it." We're left in the dark ourselves. Some have suggested having him shed some tears - I'm not sure I agree with that, but I would say it would have a stronger ending if he did something or gave some indication of how he feels. As it stands he seems to be in denial about her leaving - perhaps that's exactly what you were trying to convey. It seems a lot of readers here would like a more decisive resolution.
Good stuff, as usual.
Steven
PS Congrats on the 3rd place!
Re: Working man's hands
Thanks for you feedback, Steven ... only just noticed your comments (as don't seem to get notification email at the mo).
I left the direct text about his feelings out deliberately - I had in my mind the scene - and what I thought he might feel - but I wanted to keep it very short and for the reader to make up their own mind. Some of the settings were put there to hint at what I thought the man was going through. I hope those hints pushed the reader the way I wanted them to go.
Thanks again.
Steve.