From the UKAuthors Collection
Disbeliever.
By sweetwater · Originally published 2 February 2015
Was in two minds whether to post this or not, but for me it's theraputic, and a revelation. I am NOT saying I think I am being lied to when told a poem is good, I am saying I have come to realise my problem is in my own head and by writing this poem it's in black & white, so I can't argue. :-)
They say I am a poet,
their words I don't believe.
They say my work is very good,
I think their tongues deceive.
Every plaudit kindly given
leaves me riven, with distrust.
Poets held in high regard
by them my work discussed,
they tell me truly, I can write;
Yet how do I allow my mind
to trust that they are right?
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Disbeliever.
OMG ;-)
First the crit on the poem then the content.
The rhyme and rhythm was going along nicely then the last two lines were out of sync, the last line particularly.
You need to work on that a bit. just because you are making a point does not IMHO mean it’s good to lose focus.
I see what you are saying and can tell by some lines and the 'about' section you are trying to say the problem is with yourself i.e. a lack of self confidence or self worth but this line galls a wee bit..
'I think their tongues deceive. '
Deceive in its true form speaks of some sort of underhand workings...or are you the one who you feel is deceived?
This really opens a can of worms, same as my comments on rating in the forum. Too much praise loosely given can in fact give someone an idea their work is better than it is...and also against what do we rate? The others here or the poetry produced everywhere or the old established poets?
Also, it brought up some hard questions about who has the right or the knowledge to actually say whether a poem is any good? I think it was left that poetry is very subjective and therefore its 'horses for courses' but there are some basic glaring mistakes that many make especially in rhyming poetry and that is to mangle a poem or repeat words on order to make a poem rhyme when it is at the expense of the meaning or the rhythm etc..
Nobody can give anybody else self esteem. Some have an abundance of it, too much maybe...some woefully lacking.
I am speaking for myself here..
i think its wise to go from a position of being open to well meaning feedback rather than fight your corner as some do...then to always strive to get better and accept we all post inferior work sometimes but if the impetus is to improve the way is always uphill with passion ;-)
I hope you understood what I am trying to put over. It affects all of us.
Poets are very sensitive souls in general but those who progress as far as I have seen since coming here, are those who are willing to be open to the feedback from others who all had to start somewhere.
Some are born naturally gifted and most of us have to learn with the skills we have and the desire to speak through words.
It is not easy to lay ourselves bare to the world and his wife but like in everything else it's a case oh 'who dares wins'
hope that helps :-)
Alison x
Disbeliever.
Errr... this is well written, well rhymed etc.. but total bollox. I would take this out into your garden and set fire to it, sacrifice it to what ever gods you believe in, and NEVER let me read it again. HaHa!
Mike
Disbeliever.
Essentially a nice little rhyme expressing your point. I think all creative people feel this way, so you are not alone. The consolation is it's spurring you on to improve, and that's good.
I didn't like the awkwardness of 'by them my work discussed' just to fit the rhyme. I'm sure you can improve on that. And the last three lines don't fit the rhythm/rhyme. You need to insert a line before they tell me truly .... also the next to last line reads a bit awkwardly I would say.
There, have I depressed you? I hope not. I assume this is a bit of fun, not a serious poem you have honed. :-)
Disbeliever.
Dear Sue, in effect you are asking "What is truth"? and how can you tell. Of course there are no absolute answers, but to allow that to affect the mind is, in my mind, a non-scientific approach. Because there are no absolutes, man has to learn to live with likelihoods. and in this case it reduces to like and dislike. If the likes outnumber the dislikes - rejoice for that is the nearest to truth you can get. I am a 'like' and think you are a natural. My love too...David
Disbeliever.
Hi Sue,
I agree with Mike to a certain extent, but I would not go as far as burning it.In fact, if I ever had any doubts I would re-read it and the comments others have made, and gain belief from those comments.We all have ,moments of doubt like it. Best wishes, Peter xxx
Disbeliever.
Don't know why you posted this Sue - I am sure most of us lack confidence in our efforts sometimes, I know I do. I have considered leaving this site a number of times in view of not feeling good enough, but then someone comes along and gives me a great comment and it puts me back on track rather than leading me to feel deceived. Yes indeed, throw it in the bin.
Val xx