From the UKAuthors Collection
Old Harry (now removed for editing - comments remain)
By e-griff · Originally published 5 December 2014
For the prose challenge. Prompt: a Tom Waits song.
I've removed this as it didn't come up to scratch (see comments) will rewrite and maybe re-present.
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Old Harry
It's quite a quiet, self-reflective piece, and I like the way you ended it, although I wonder if you could make it even more subtle, and reflect on the setting as he walks home instead of spelling out how he feels. You know, a bit of mirroring through the description or something.
Howie is a great character.
I'm not sure all the dialogue works. At times it feels quite formal and very sober, with phrases such as 'incessant demands', but writing this voice well is a real challenge, I think - I wouldn't like to take it on. Still, I think it works as a story and, weirdly, it did make me feel a bit Christmassy.
Old Harry
I like this one a lot. It genuinely gives me pause for thought. Why do I write stories?
Why do people write in general, or write songs and sing them? Why am I nagging Lily Brooke and Rick Hayter to do something about their respective careers when they're perfectly happy doing what they're doing now?
As Aliya says it could probably be polished up a bit technically, but reading it I forgot about the technicalities and just started listening to what old Howie had to say, and I think that's a pretty high accolade for a short story.
Old Harry
It is a good story but Aliya has it right, the dialogue is out of kilter with the voice. You are writing about an American drunk singer, but when he talks...it's as English as me :) He would never use as many words. Its a great story and you should go back and prune it. I still like it, but good... could be great; and you're better than this.
Mike
Old Harry
I agree with the comments above. I liked the story, thought it was a good take on the prompt, but I couldn't really hear a Tom Waits type character saying these middle paragraphs in that way; perhaps there was too much of a difference between the shambling drunk who sits at the table slumped over his glass.