From the UKAuthors Collection
In an attempt
By Supratik · Originally published 3 October 2014
"Let's start at the very beginning, a very nice place to start!"
Alice and John
Yes papa!
Eating sugar?
No papa!
Have these apples
Yes papa!
Love you children
Ha! ha! ha!
[I wonder on the need to teach children lie [being smart] to their parents!]
Humpty dumpty sat on a chair,
Humpty dumpty sang with love and care.
All the king's forces all the king's men,
Learned to sing with him over and again!!
[Children laugh at the fall of Humpty dumpty and also at the fact that he couldn't be put together again…why!]
Jack and Jill went up the hill
To fetch a pail of water,
Jack came down when he was done
And Jill came dancing after.
With them they bring a bird that sings,
It fell off from a tree,
They cared for it to cure its wings,
Until it flew, was free.
[Is it fair to expect children not to laugh at other's miseries if they are taught to enjoy Jack's breaking his crown, and Jill's tumbling after!].
While I respect the popularity of these rhymes, I have questions on their relevance in times where there is no dearth of torture. Children are disproportionately exposed to a lot of violence and chicaneries. I feel it is necessary to re-tell these otherwise beautiful nursery rhymes in a constructive way. This is just a modest step.