From the UKAuthors Collection
Deja Vu?
By Elfstone · Originally published 22 September 2014
I have written nothing for quite some time, but recent events have had a profound effect ...
[IMG]http://i28.photobucket.com/albums/c233/Rhovannion/Raasay%20Sept%2014/DSC00294_zps28978c05.jpg[/IMG]
Deja Vu?
‘Stands Scotland where she did?’
Glamaig certainly still stands aloof,
but now half-hidden in haze,
as though regret shivers
even the bones of the earth.
How many years of misrule
have trudged sullenly by
while that mountain stood
in shimmering indifference
to our stupidity?
The surrounding, defining sea
is unnaturally calm -
perhaps stunned by disbelief
into silence,
its swells and rollers gone
in deference to our gullibility?
The ‘YES’ sign sits forlorn
on Eilean nan Ghobhar,
stinging us with its rebuke.
It will weather as quickly
as the promises will be forgotten
and soon look just as shabby.
The soft, quiet air hangs down
over an unhappy Sabbath
like the quietude of resignation.
Where are the storms of outrage?
the lashing of angry breakers
against insulted rock?
Where is the howling wind of indignation
at the bitter memory of a land
that all too meekly grumbled
at lies, Poll Tax and stolen resources
and learnt nothing - nothing! -
while MacRae’s ghost haunts us yet,
reeking of unanswered questions?
‘Stands Scotland where she did?’
who knows - who cares?
After all the hopes and dreams,
all the years of wishing and waiting
come tears of futlilty and
the anguish of deja vu.
@ Elfstone 21/9/14
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Where are the storms?
Sharp pointed passion whirls through your piece. All are
guilty on both sides - it is capitalism versus the care divide that is worsening by the year. Will God save mankind? Not on his showing to date. perhaps even he is leaving it too little and too late? This is a fine work. Bravo....David
Where are the storms?
Your poem is indeed full of passion, Elf. As a foreigner looking at your political scene I was quite sympathetic to the Scottish quest but whenever I tried to express an opinion on those lines I was shouted down by my unionists English friends. You have put your point of view very forcefully and it seems to me that the only consolation is that no bloody revolution took place. We'll have to wait and see if the status quo remains or if changes will happen.
Luigi x
P.S. I see that you managed to post the photo.
Where are the storms?
I only looked with a casual interest at the events, down here in the west country Scotland seems so far away. I do however try to understand, after all Scotland is only asking for what was taken from them by force; like half of the world at one time or another. I wonder now if the 'yes' vote will rest in peace or will we see the flags flying again in ten years? I will not be here to see it but I wish you well.
Mike
ps I thought you said it with great feeling, I loved it.
Where are the storms?
Beautifully and forcefully expressed as one who loves Scotland and feels things in the bones, as I do also.
There has been genuine grieving in many quarters, dignified and stoic....as the ancestors were.
The land itself speaks to us and gives comfort in a way that those who do not know this visceral connection can never understand.
Allow me to take into favs and nominate it an' a' 😉
Alison x
Where are the storms?
I don't agree with your political views. But I fully recognise your passion and respect it - a natural reaction it is clear. To concentrate on writing: - what I would say about this poem (without passing judgement) is there is too much message and not enough art. In my opinion, you have the talent to write something far more powerful and convincing when you recover from what is obcviously a great disappointment for you. I look forward to that. :-) very best, JohnG
Deja Vu?
A beautifully-written poem full of wistfulness and disappointment. But don't get downhearted. Scotland's day will come. Pretty soon, I think.
Do you speak Gaelic? Or Scots?