From the UKAuthors Collection

The ice bucket challenge: moralist society or mere a stunt à la mode?

By Ajitabh · Originally published 22 September 2014

People spending most of their time on such sites are accused of being socially insensitive. It’s observed that they hardly show their empathy towards any common social cause. So, this campaign proposes them an opportunity of showing themselves as a wannabe ‘activist’.

Crowd has a need and desire to be governed. And, the governor of such disorganized human entity is mostly a miniscule number of highly placed individuals with required information and resources. Governing them allow the governor to serve his interest which is, in all form, retaining his power over a larger chunk of people. The tool that a governor uses to serve his interest is principally a message packed communication which is largely deceptive in nature. The content of information is drafted keeping in mind the need of the governor as to what message he wants his governed entities to accept or reject. The method through what the message dissemination is performed is called ‘campaign’. In todays’ interconnected globalized society, social media (Face-book, Twitter) presents itself as the sole theatre for running the show of such campaigns. You all know the authors of such campaigns; they’re indeed governments, big corporates houses, international interest groups and sometimes certain rogue elements as well.

A new campaign ‘Ice Bucket challenge’ is in vogue since August 2014. The objective behind this campaign is to raise awareness for the amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) disease and subsequently to raise funds for its research. one can imagine the frenzy of this campaign by a simple fact that by 21st of August, around 2.5 million videos got registered on different social media sites showing people taking their ultimate challenge of pouring ice water on their head. At the same time, donation keeps on flooding in an unprecedented way in the history of philanthropic world. Probably it’s the first blitz style of campaign propagated through social media for a philanthropic cause which brought more than 100 million dollars to ‘the ALS association’, a US based charity for their research purpose.

This campaign offers you two sets of options: either you take the challenge of dumping a bucket full of ice-cubes on your head or you donate a certain amount for the ALS cause; or you can go for another option where one can take the challenge of taking ice bath and also donating some amount for the cause. Once you finish your challenge, then you can nominate any of your friends to do the same.
Indeed, it’s an American campaign otherwise one wonders if in India pouring some ice cubes on your head can be called a ‘challenge’. The cause behind the campaign is just. But how much does that disease (ALS) affect Indian population? If not much, then why are the Indians serving the cause so passionately? If the social media savvy Indians have become so ethically conscious, then why do not they take up a challenge that the country has been grappling with, e.g. reducing poverty, educating poor children etc. than serving the cause of that world where people have enough resources to fight any adversity or disease? Is it not that the English speaking, social media serving Indians are merely aping the way the western world sees any issue?

A maddening campaign: made in America

In a country like US where all necessary resources are available for research; we hardly hear of any sensitive health research projects being shut down due to budget constraint. A nation which produces maximum number of research papers through public and private funded organisations in various fields does need any such fund raising campaign to irrigate their research work. In such an affluent society, running such charity campaign for themselves appears to be pretentious. They should rather have a campaign on Ebola disease in Africa or for any other war ravaged land where innocent citizens die out of hunger.

The US mindset has a habit of internationalizing its every cause; this is what they seem to be doing through this campaign. They think that what affects them should and would impact the whole world equally. Therefore, the global society ought to fight the American war of any kind be it economic, security or even any physical or mental disease. Though ethically any national society has the right to promote the cause that it believes in to the other parts of the world; now, it depends on ‘other’ parts of the world as to how they perceive and analyze the importance of a campaign which does not directly hit their life.

A campaign driven solely by sites like Facebook leaves less room for such rational analysis of any subject; because, these sites for good or bad reason have diluted the significance of political and geographical boundaries amongst people sitting in different corners of the planet. Secondly, the United States exerts such an inexplicable influence of soft power on the large part of the world that any idea with tangible or intangible value coming from that country receives largely natural acceptance without any serious public scrutiny. Thus, sites like Facebook acts like an amusement park in offering a virtual public space to private individuals so that they can see, enjoy, and if the desire exists then belong to a larger imaginary community of American way of living. Hence, participating in their campaign gives a contrived pleasure of belonging to an extended American world which hardly exists in reality.

A new avatar of social media: philanthropic ‘activism’!

People spending most of their time on such sites are accused of being socially insensitive. It’s observed that they hardly show their empathy towards any common social cause. So, this campaign proposes them an opportunity of showing themselves as a wannabe ‘activist’. Posting their picture and video of their ice bucket act on any social media especially on Facebook makes them feel that they’re becoming a mini-celebrity activist for a greater human cause.

As the world has become increasingly individualistic by approach towards life, the modern man sees himself at the centre of all human operations unlike earlier era when society used to be at centre. So, the cooperation that used to exist as anchoring force between social individuals got replaced by competition; which asks every man to compete with other man to proof oneself as a winner. In todays’ time only winner is worshiped; dedication has no price in modern pricey world. Society has turned man into a creature that seeks a little attention from the outside world. Social media provides that effective platform where people are invited to develop and consolidate the desire of seeking attention as per the trend of the modern world.

This campaign gives an easy opportunity to live the moment of self-promotion under the manufactured cover of a social cause. What else one can ask for: on objective side it’s a pleasure of being part of the world wide spectacle and on the subjective side it’s a self-portrayal as a conscious global citizen who cares for the vulnerable. In both ways, a perfect tool for self-image management! In all this melodrama, hardly anybody cares for the wastage of water that’s being committed in the form of ice stunt.

The ALS Ice Bucket Challenge is an American flu that’s flowing through sites like Facebook informing us that the character of charity campaign in today’s internet driven world has changed. It involves fun, and provides people opportunity to live their dream of being mini-celebrity. Nobody knows what stops our armed chair fellow social media amateurs to kick a campaign of this nature and magnitude for an India centric cause. At present, they do not have to strive much to find such cause. Devastating flood of Jammu and Kashmir is very much in front of us which has taken the lives of hundreds of innocents where the federal state government has little monetary resources to help those dying poor little things.

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

Bonnie

The ice bucket challenge: moralist society or mere a stunt à la mode?

I would have to agree with all your points. There is something very indulgent about joining a current craze and putting the video on Facebook. Also, a lot of those who joined in didn't donate money. But many did; the Motor Neurone Disease Association (ALS)(in UK) has raised over £3 million through this. Maybe we should just be glad that funds are being raised for such a horrific condition, and ignore the somewhat self promoting methods. I did do the Challenge, as my daughter nominated me, and some money did go in. But I take your point about the wastage of water. We did it on the lawn, so that at least the grass would benefit.

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…