From the UKAuthors Collection
Craftsman
By e-griff · Originally published 31 October 2003

I rewrote a story by Bluepootle (see my journal). This is it - much of her remains in this story.
Oh and she rewrote one of mine, Memoriam (should be close by)
Craftsman
by bluepootle and e-griff
Gaynor glanced covertly at Gary as they drove along. The young man with the spiky hair spoke in an animated tone.
‘It’s all about integrity, Gaynor.’ She nodded. ‘You see,’ he explained, ‘we mustn’t patronise our clients, that’s the worst thing we could do. They are human beings, our equals, Gaynor. No way do we look down on them or cheat them of the respect they deserve. You have to put yourself in their place and ask what you would think if some do-gooding prat waltzed in, jollied you up, then buggered off with no real commitment. You do you see what I mean, don’t you Gaynor?’
‘That’s absolutely how I feel. We have to be honest.’
‘Honesty.’ Gary paused portentously. ‘Yes.’ His head dipped. ‘Yes, I think you have summed it up nicely, Gaynor. I think you and I are going to get on well …’ His eyes met hers. ‘… very well.’
As Gary turned his attention back to the road, Gaynor Wilson blushed. Gary was one of her mentors on the course, and she’d felt really pleased when he suggested she accompany him. This was what she believed in. She wanted to help old people.
*
They made their way through the corridors of the care home to the big common room. People sat around in chairs or lay back in day beds. Some moved about with walking frames or sticks.
‘Hi everybody! It’s me again,’ Gary called. Gaynor saw faces light up and beckoning hands wave. As Gary spoke to each client, she saw trust, pleasure. He gave his attention expertly. Gaynor had thought Gary was good and here was proof.
‘Why don’t you try talking to someone yourself?’ he said quietly to her as he moved between the delighted clients. ‘Here.’ He drew a plastic bag from his briefcase. ‘This is clay – old Edward over there likes to mould it. Take it over and he’ll tell you his life story.’ Gary grinned.
‘Okay.’ It seemed a good start – listen to Edward and help him make a little model or something. Gaynor took the bag and drew out the ball of clay as she walked over to the man sitting at a table.
‘I’ve brought your clay.’
‘About time.’
Gaynor pulled out a chair opposite, sat and placed the clay on the table.
‘You’re new,’ Edward said suspiciously. She looked closely at him. The old man was bald, wisps of white hair clung to his ears. His dressing-gown was of a brown material that looked scratchy and the collar of his blue pyjamas poked out asymmetrically around the folds of his yellowing neck. His glasses were huge with lenses as thick as double glazing.
‘I’m training with Gary, Edward, I’m here to learn,’ Gaynor said carefully.
‘You don’t have to speak slowly, I’m not thick. Where’s my clay?’
‘In front of you.’
Edward tapped the table and then plunged his hands into the clay, breaking off four pieces and rolling them efficiently into sausages. ‘You come here to learn? You think I’m going to tell you the secret of life? What’s your name?’
‘Gaynor.’
‘You Gary’s girlfriend?’ the old man leered.
‘No.’
‘Soon will be, I reckon,’ he said knowingly.
‘He’s a good man.’
The old man’s face lit up. ‘He sure as hell is. Don’t know where I’d be without him.’
‘Why?’
‘My sculpture.’ Edward had lined up the four sausages and had started work on making a ball, pressing indents irregularly into its surface. ‘It was his idea.’ Gaynor glanced over at the main group. Gary had organised them into a circle and was telling them to imagine they were in a beautiful garden; that they were able to run and jump and sing amongst the flowers.
‘Right. Where did I put the legs?’ Edward patted one hand over the table until he found the cylinders, and started arranging them, peering closely. ‘I wasted my whole life, then while I’m waiting for this operation, Gary puts some clay in front of me and my whole life changes. It turns out I’m good at it – a craftsman. You know …’ He smiled. ‘… these sculptures go to a charity shop on the High Street and they bring in a good whack.’ He ran his thick fingers gently over the clay. After some time spent in silent concentration he said, ‘There. What do you think?’
Gaynor looked at the small clay horse. ‘It’s lovely,’ she gasped. ‘Really lovely – you have real talent.’
‘This is what keeps me alive,’ Edward confided. Gaynor could hear the reluctant pleasure in his voice. ‘To know that people are looking at my work and admiring it makes me feel I’m doing something useful, helping others – that I’m not just some blind old git in a home.’ There was bitterness in his tone.
‘Gary says they take pride of place in the window, with my name on a card.’ Edward looked up at her, his filmy eyes magnified in the spectacles. He smiled. ‘My name – “Edward Johns, Sculptor” – imagine that. I’ll never see it, but …’
Gaynor was moved. Integrity. Respect. Honesty. How right Gary was. Look at the effect on Edward! She felt proud to have joined the profession. She gripped the old man’s hand.
Gary came over to them, grinning. ‘That’s brilliant, Ed-ward. Another horse for the shop, yeah? Marvellous.’
Edward inclined his head. ‘Been telling Gaynor here all about it.’
‘That’s great. Shall I take it for you?’ Gary picked up the sculpture with exaggerated care. ‘Come on, Gaynor, lots to do. Oh, pick up that bag, eh. Don’t want to leave things lying around.’
‘Bye, all,’ he called loudly, ‘see you next time!’ Everyone in the room waved and smiled. Edward smiled too, his lips pressed tight.
Gaynor followed Gary, who stopped just outside the door. She was about to tell him how proud she felt, how excited by the visit, when he brought his palms together and squashed the sculpture with rhythmic pressure, kneading it back into a ball. He grinned his grin. ‘Put this back in the bag eh, Gaynor?’
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Re: Craftsman
I suppose the horse had a finger print left on it, Eh!
Re: Craftsman
First off, i don't understand the point of the previous commenter.
I would have liked to have seen Bluepootle's version.
If i compare this with 'Minna' another of your piece's, i would say i found this more enjoyable to read, to me it has a more fluid style to it, it could be the topic, length and so on, but i think on first impression this been a useful exercise for you.
If you'd wrote this under a pseudonym, i would have been suprised to have found it was you who wrote it, but knowing it was you i was looking for style comparisons with your other pieces that i've read, it's hard to articulate exactly but there a few style traits that you've brought over from your other work i think.
The story itself is very good,the ending is very abrupt and cruel.But regarding the story I just don't like the potential comeback this conman will have to suffer if Edward does venture down to the shops, or if Edward's son turns up?Is the conman just walking a tightrope or have i missed something?
Alan
Re: Craftsman
thanks for your interest. Hmm....
you are right. (conman - although he's not really a conman) that was a late addition and indeed has the consequences you drew, which were not intended in my original, I shall modify it.
If pootle wants to show you the original, fine...ask her nicely.........:-) or if she's very brave, she can post it on the crit forum.......
I hope it included my style:-) it was meant to be a modification of it, not a copy of blue's.
the ending is abrupt, I agree. I don't know what more needs to be said.?
Re: Craftsman
thanks for your interest. Hmm....
you are right. (conman - although he's not really a conman) that was a late addition and indeed has the consequences you drew, which were not intended in my original, I shall modify it.
If pootle wants to show you the original, fine...ask her nicely.........:-) or if she's very brave, she can post it on the crit forum.......
I hope it included my style:-) it was meant to be a modification of it, not a copy of blue's.
the ending is abrupt, I agree. I don't know what more needs to be said.?
comparing to Minna, yes. the structure (snape ending) is more like Boy in the Bus.... but the story is different.
Re: Craftsman
Hi
I'm going to post the original on the crit forum purely so that people can compare & contrast. So nobody tell me it sucks, please, because I already know that!
Re: Craftsman
Oh, what! – I was outraged, couldn't believe the ending. What a b******. Well told. Couple of minor criticisms:
Three references to 'do you see' in the first paragraph.
Unnecessary capitalization in a couple of places—
1) "You Gary's girlfriend?" The old man leered.
2) "Soon will be, I reckon," He said knowingly.
I'm going to wait for a while before I read Bluepootle's version, so that I can take it on its own merits without any mental input from your adaptation. A damned good story. :^)
Re: Craftsman
hmm, you may be right. I'll have to sort out the 'inside the quotes" "outside the quotes" punctuation. - but unlike you and I, most people don't notice (no, no excuse, I'll get it RIGHT!!!!!)
:-)
Re: Craftsman
Enjoyed that. A brief bit of nastiness, well told.
Didn't like:
"Gary paused portentously"
and
"he said knowingly"
Re: Craftsman
see what you mean..... blimey! that's what I would jump on in someone else's story! crtiquer crit thyself! proves something, eh?
will change instanta!
Re: Craftsman
I cringe when I look at some of my old stuff sometimes. But there's a kind of weaning period for your own work during which time it can do no wrong. When it enters adulthood and detaches itself from your short-term memory, all is revealed!
Re: Craftsman
Caramba! *what?*
I'm happy for people to comment. when they're right, I'm grateful. if I think they're wrong, I'm not offended. wish some touchy souls on this site could be the same (not in any other way, I am not a good model!) *angst reveals itself*
Re: Craftsman
exactly!
Re: Craftsman
I'm new to the site, so please excuse any unintended rudeness... oh dear, not a good way to start - sounds like I'm about to launch into a tirade.
Which I'm not.
I compared your version with Blue Pootle's. I could see what you meant about two stories in one - you've separated out the disenchanted youth storyline to focus on Gary the 'conman'. Would you always recommend separating two storylines in a short story? I thought it really worked in this story.
Also, was there a reason why you introduced ambiguity into whether or not George could produce fine sculptures? In Blue Pootle's version, it was clear he could not, which made Gary's lying even more apparent.
Re: Craftsman
blue was having trouble with the story, trying to tie the two parts together, which I as a reader could not. I was giving crits, trying to help and not being too clear, it seemed, so I just sat down and wrote this to demonstrate..... as far as she says I correctly interpreted her intentions, and a lot of the description is hers, untouched. Perhaps I am less subtle than she - I put in the opening conversation to lay the ground for his hypocrisy. The suggestion to make the sculpture 'good' I had made after the first reading of hers. I think that Gary heedlessly crushing a good piece of work shows him as far more cynical and unheeding than if he crushed a poor one (which he might be excused for as 'trying to be kind' ) I also made the ending sharp, the last words doing the telling, the shock (like my story 'Boy in the Bus Station - same technique).
In this case, splitting the themes out was right, in my opinion, for a fairly short story it was confused. But it's not a 'rule' (what is?) .
In truth I think she was a little put out, but she is game, and I invited her to pick one of mine. The one she chose 'memoriam' had the problem, not of two separate themes, but two intertwined themes (treating memories and the church) the 'church ' part had people confused. She rewrote the story and improved it a lot by cutting out the church part.
Later, i found I had edited it and not reposted (months before) so that version is now also on site as well - it is very similar to hers. She makes a better job of description, perhaps 'showing' more than I do. I tend to be direct, more 'telling' - perhaps its my scientific training.
Hope this is what you asked (?) and thanks for the thoughtful comments, and for reading. welcome!
Re: Craftsman
Not put out at all; I view this version of the story as a cross between an extremely good edit and some sharp writing to make the point.
It is different from mine in focus, certainly, and the overall goal wasn't to say 'all adults are hypocrits' but to suggest the the main character has to make a decision about what kind of adult he wants to be. I think my version fails to do that, and this version doesn't try to do that. This is about the build up to the shock conclusion - almost a different type of story, but v powerful.
So, no, I wouldn't say it always works to separate the themes in a short story, but maybe the point is that clarity always has to be present - a sense of direction and a pace that leads to a conclusion. This version has those things, where mine didn't.
Re: Craftsman
Thanks both! I'll make sure to read all the versions of memoriam when I get a chance! :-)
Re: Craftsman
Reading Chippy's comments brought back something that niggled me when i compared both versions. It's the end product that the sculptors produce in both piece's, in Bluepootle's 'George' produces an item of little worth, but your character 'Edward' produces something beautiful which Gaynor recognises, this slightly worries me because i feel some readers might find this unrealistic that a pensioner or anybody could produce something of quality from clay in a few minutes. Might be me nitpicking and i suspect you may have pondered this when coming up with this version.
There was another couple of points,but i can now see reason for them without pointing to them.I did enjoy the story and i hope it gets few more deserved reads. I have to say prefer your idea for the story, although Bluepootle's original has many good things about it too.
Alan
Re: Craftsman
thank you blue, for your kindness, and thanks flash for the comment. Perhaps we should have joint authorship? I'll do that.........
Re: Craftsman
Aaahhhh, I feel all fuzzy now. Thank you