From the UKAuthors Collection

Out of Place

By e-griff · Originally published 9 June 2014

For Prose Challenge

Situation given as theme. The main challenge is to avoid 'tell' .

Out of Place

The tin banged down on the counter in front of her. She looked at the shelf that the shopkeeper had taken it from.
‘Why do you charge me more than the shelf price?’
‘That’s for regulars.’
‘But I’m a regular.’
‘Club members. We run a club.’
‘So, can I join?’
‘Not here long enough.’
‘But I’ve been shopping here every week for a month.’
‘Takes a year.’

*
She left the corner shop, glancing up and down the street, then headed for home with her shopping. Only an old man and a hurrying woman were going in different directions. As she passed the old woman, the woman spat. It landed in the gutter.

*
As she was preparing the tea, the door clicked and her daughter came into the kitchen.
‘What’s wrong?’
‘Oh, some of them at school got onto me again.’
‘This has to stop. I’ll go up to that school.’
‘No, Mum, don’t, it’ll only make things worse.’

*
They were watching TV together.
Why do I have to wear these clothes, Mum, that’s the main problem, I’m different from the others and they don’t understand.’
‘Because I won’t have you in that heathen dress. You are a respectable girl.’

*
Her daughter came down the stairs.
‘Why are you spending so long collecting your books? Why do you always go upstairs first when you come home as well?’
‘What is that?’ she said, looking at the dress.
‘The girls are talking to me now, Mum. I changed it a bit at first, but one of their mums made this for me. The girls like it, they say I’m trying to fit in. They thought I was all stuck up.’
‘Take it off. Wear another, proper dress. Then give it to me and I’ll throw it away. Heathen nonsense. You should be ashamed.’

*
There was a knock at the door. A young man stood there, swaying. ‘ Go back where you came from. We don’t want your kind here.’
She shut the door in his face.

*
At the supermarket, prices were good, and she only paid the shelf price. The checkout girl even smiled at her.

*
A bearded man stood at the door.
‘Excuse me for bothering you, Madam, but may I have a word …?’

‘Excellent tea, thank you.’ The man leaned forward, fixing her with a gaze.
‘You see, you are causing trouble here.’
‘What trouble? We are respectable people, my daughter and I.’
‘I’m sure, I’m sure.’ The man held up his hand. ‘I have no doubt where you come from you are a very acceptable member of the community.’ He dipped his head slightly. ‘ But here …’ he continued, ‘… you are not fitting in. You are different, your customs are different, your dress is different. People notice that most.’
‘But … ‘
‘I know you have tried to fit in, your daughter especially gained some popularity and found friends when she dressed a little like us for a while, it showed she was willing to fit in, just a little bit. We’re not asking you to change anything except small things like that. By the way, why did she change her dress back?’
‘I would not allow it’
‘Perhaps you could reconsider. It’s such a small sacrifice for such a large result.’
‘So what do you want me to do then, dress like you, change my religion?’
‘The first, just a bit. The second, not at all. We are a very tolerant community.’
‘But if we dress like you, it’s not normal, not respectable for us.’
‘Maybe not you, but your daughter? The young are sometimes wiser than we.’
‘No, I can’t. If we are not accepted, we will leave.’
After the man had gone, she sat for a long time.

*
‘We’re leaving. I’ve put the house on the market. This was a big mistake.’
‘ But Mum, it’s great here I have friends now, and the place is much better than that flat we had.’
‘We will be with our own people. That is better for us. You will learn proper ways.’
‘Mum, I’d never do that. I have my faith, same as you. What do a few clothes matter?’
‘Hold your tongue. Go to your room. I don’t like these foreigners.’
‘But we were all born here.’
‘You heard me.’

*
Mother and daughter sat in their new flat.
‘This is better.’
‘It’s not, Mum. People here aren’t very friendly, school is horrible.’
‘But we are with our own people.’
‘I don’t care. I was becoming happy where we were. I found people were kind if I tried to fit in.’
‘No. That Vicar was wrong. It would never have worked. We will be happier with our own people.’

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

bluepootle

Out of Place

It's a very weird read. The format makes it as rigid and as uncompromising as the mother; there's absolutely no give in it. I think the mother could do with a name, particularly since you've got a daughter as well, so there's a 'she/her' confusion. Or maybe make it a son, and I think that might make the issue of dress more intriguing. Rather than wearing a dress to fit in, it could be a different article of clothing.

It's interesting. It's not what I would call a successful piece of writing because there's not really enough there to get your teeth into, but I think as an experiment it has provided something, if only to demonstrate how the form of the work can mirror and enhance the characterisation.

sirat

Out of Place

I think I liked it more than Aliya. The odd format gave it a 'foreignness' that fitted the theme. It wasn't so much the format that didn't work for me as the dialogue itself. It was all a bit stilted and too direct, the vicar in particular. I think he would have been a lot less outspoken, hinting at things, feeling his way, being polite and charming. Even the shopkeeper seemed more overtly prejudiced than I would have expected, especially to a good cash customer. Usually it's a bit more subtle. There was also very little feeling in the way the mother and daughter spoke to each other. It had the feel of a bad play-reading about it. Although the narrator wasn't in 'tell' mode, the characters seemed to be.

I think it was an interesting experiment and I liked the narrator's refusal to comment on characters' inner thoughts or facial expressions or interpret in any way. I think it kind of works in something of this length but I don't think I would want to read a whole novel in this style.

e-griff

Out of Place

You're both right.

It's an interesting lesson. I compare it with seasoning in food. You don't need too much, but having some is vital.

Her role just falls apart with no tell to glue it together.

I didn't use names as inevitably it would have given the denouement away. :-)

TheBigBadG

Out of Place

I think I'm more in line with Blue on this one, I'm afraid. For me the thing that keeps me outside the piece are the section breaks. I get why you've got them all but I suspect that with this kind of exercise, where you've got a limited toolset, the focus should be more on ensuring narration flows. As it is it felt like it would make a good script for a trailer or treatment.

That said, I do take Blue's point about form reflecting character. For me that would be the angle to pursue with this particular story, were you to pursue it. Given you don't 'fess up the specifics of which minority religion they belong to it becomes about the mother in conflict with the world - so more observations of the world around her, perhaps?

OldPeculier

Out of Place

Now, I really liked the format. It was short and sharp like machine gun fire. I think it suited the show only style.

My dislike was that it didnt seem to go anywhere. They came, they didnt fit in so they left. If the last paragraph saw the mother sitting on her own in the new flat, maybe talking to herself then I would have felt some kind of conclusion I think.

I also couldnt help but think about Royston Vasey in the first bit, but that is no bad thing.

ifyouplease

Out of Place

YES! GOOD STORY.

Skytrucker

Out of Place

I thought that it was a well constructed piece of work with a twist in the tail. I can see that, once again, I am going to be slightly at odds with the writing police. In my opinion if a story holds my interest, it is good. I get bored very easily and Mr The E-Griff has never bored me. Ever.

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…