From the UKAuthors Collection

Five out of Ten

By Mikeverdi · Originally published 9 May 2014

Prompted by recent events on the site and forums :)

Contemptuous conceit
dripping from half open mouths.
Brought up from bowels
filled with the bile
of self- righteous thoughts.

The comment box filled with damnation.
‘Could do butter’ ‘Three manly typos’
‘Check your smelling before posting’
‘The tell not show of it all’

If there was a god of fair play,
surly he would save me from this;
the death knell of any work.
Five out of Ten.

Never to be read, marked down…..
deemed unworthy by my betters.
Oh the shame, the humiliation.

Where did I go wrong?
Was it that bad?

What!?!... It should have been ‘snow don’t smell’

Oh, right.. I see. Err… Umm…
Bugger, better try harder then!

ps. Does twat have a capitol T?

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

stormwolf

Five out of Ten

Hi Mike ;-)

I felt the first stanza 'over-egged the custard' and had a different 'energy' to it than the rest which was amusing.

I think you could dispense with it to be honest.

(I am sure you will never get the death knell lol )

Alison

PS Enjoy your time away.xxx

Andrea

Five out of Ten

Agree with Alison re first stanza. Funny, though, tres amusing :)

Have a great holiday!

Bozzz

Five out of Ten

I have had a five here once. My problem will always be - whether perhaps the five is really the right score, or just a signal that Gaviscon is needed elsewhere. Spelling checkers are not ideal, but they can help. Mike, I am in favour of UKA being an educative group and in any such organisation encouragement is a vital element - but at same time, reasoned marking is also key. If one gives a mark - good or less than good, reasons must also be given.... David

Nomenklatura

Five out of Ten

Hi Mike,

you will note I did not contribute to the forum thread. Numbers are numbers, everything is subjective. I might, for example, give a 9 (don't think I've given more than 2 10's) to someone who has risen above their own and my expectations by a long way. A poem of the same standard by someone whose own standards have not been met by the said poem would get (say) a 7. Perhaps these respective marks should be 7 and 5. Or, indeed, they should be the same.

Maybe.

It's not science, Mike. It's writing - and creative writing at that. Spelling and punctuation are things which, unless you get them absolutely right, mean publishers and agents will turn your work down unless you are absolutely fucking Samuel Beckett brilliant. Who among us here (I almost mentioned a name there, DOWN BOY!) is that good? I'm most certainly not.

All my crit has been offered in the spirit of friendship and common endeavour, I'll refrain in future

regards

Ewan

sweetwater

Five out of Ten

I enjoyed this, can really relate to it too. I liked the first verse for the seperate train of thought that it is,it spoke of frustration and anger to me, (you were definatly upset, anyway) The other verses were tempered with humour but you were still niggled I feel. The ending was perfect, I felt you had come to terms with the whole experience. No doubt I have the whole idea completely wrong, If so I apologise. As for the rating,the more I enjoy a piece and like the way its written the higher the mark I give. Simples!

Ionicus

Five out of Ten

I think that I understand what you are getting at, Mike. It is not the marking itself that rankles but the fatuous bilge that some condescending commentators write. I tend not to be censorious with my comments but I would expect a would-be writer to pay attention to spelling and grammar which some ignore, perhaps because it may stifle their creativity.

The appreciation of a piece is subjective and a negative feedback does not necessarily mean that it has no merits.

ValDohren

Five out of Ten

Comments are always subjective, and I often wonder just how relevant they can be. I also question how qualified some of those commentors are who do make negative remarks. Commenting should always be both constructive and polite, there is absolutely no need for offensive commenting. I also feel that if one is unable to give a reasonable rating, then do not rate at all. It is insulting to give a very low rating. We all do our best here, and after all, for many of us, it is just a passtime anyway and not to be taken overly seriously. As for your work Mike, you get plenty of nibs so I wouldn't worry too much if I were you !

Val :-)

stormwolf

Five out of Ten

Sorry to revisit this poem but in all the years I have been here, I have hardly ever seen a comment left that would warrant the first verse ;-(

There have been the odd disagreements etc but if giving crit is viewed in such a negative way then some will simply stop.

Maybe I have missed something?

That is just being honest.

Skytrucker

Five out of Ten

You hit the nail on the head there Mike. Class!

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…