From the UKAuthors Collection

Shot At Dawn - Victims Of War. Part One

By Kipper · Originally published 5 May 2014

Eighty years after the first world war, I found that I had a small part to play.

Shot At Dawn - Victims Of War. Part One

In the year 2014 we celebrate in remembrance of the start of World War One, sometimes referred to as the Great War. We celebrate to remember those who died, that we may live. We do so as a nation with sorrow and mostly with pride.

There will be many tributes and few will say that they are not justified.
But here I want to speak about part of the history of those times where, for some, pride was replaced with shame; families were shunned; not allowed to express their loss; and grief had to suffered in silence. These were the families of a small number of men who, sometimes on evidence that simply would not be tolerated today, were accused of desertion, cowardice, insubordination and other crimes. They were convicted and executed. They were however, despite their fate, victims of war.

In August 2006 it was announced by the Home Office that a posthumous pardon had been awarded to 306 men who had been executed for those 'crimes' during WW1. This was the culmination of an 80 year campaign by many people, not least a group who became known as the 'Shot at dawn' brigade (more latterly the Pardons Committee, led in its later stages by Harry Templeton). Counted amongst their numbers were some members of the house 'Lords' and the house 'Commons'. Also there were many others drawn from all quarters of society.

I was also one of them; admittedly somewhat late in the campaign. But, unlike many before me who died before the work was done, I was able to see the successful culmination of our endeavours.

Though mine was a not a major role (it involved correspondence with various bodies including No 10, and the Ministry of Defense) I am nevertheless proud of the small part I played in bringing about recognition of a grave miscarriage of justice.

While it is acknowledged that not all those who were executed as cowards were innocent of that charge, most of them were. It is also recognized that the condition known then as shell shock, was largely ignored or at best seen as a temporary problem to be 'dealt with' before sufferers were returned to the trenches; as often as not quite unfit to do so. We now know that Post Operative Stress Disorder (POSD) was more damaging and more long lasting than was understood at the time, and that most of those charged with cowardice may well have been affected by this condition rendering them totally unable to defend themselves in answer the charges made against them.

The campaign to gain some justice for these men started soon after the end of the war, when many voices were raised in disbelief when what had been happening became better known. The campaign continued for eighty years. That it took so long stands testament to the power of the establishment, the status-quo, and no doubt to attitudes held then by society at all levels following the huge losses; mostly the nations young men.

Indeed there are still some who share those views, views sincerely held I am sure, but far fewer I believe as time goes by. But the campaign finally bore fruit, and in the year 2006 the pardons were granted. It was in that year that the Government of the day finally allowed pardons for this small group of men (306 in all) to acknowledge that some miscarriages of justice had occurred. That they were indeed victims of war.

Among the many consequences of this campaign is that from the early years of the Twenty First century descendants of the families of these men were allowed to march past the Cenotaph at the Remembrance Day Service. This 'honour', prior to the successful conclusion to the campaign had been denied them. This was the first concession that any government had made over all those decades, where previously they had refused to weaken their stance. Also about this time, the names of some of these men (some as young as Seventeen) had been added to some War Memorials, exonerated at last, as victims of war.

Subsequent of those pardons, and with that miscarriage of justice having been atoned I wrote the poem 'Shot At Dawn' which I submit in celebration and grateful appreciation of all those who fell in the 1914/18 conflict. Most of them fell honorably in the trenches or on the field of battle. But a few, this small band of boys and men, became victims of war for a very different reason, but were victims nevertheless.

Now, one hundred years on from its start, as we remember and commemorate all those who did not return from the first world war, I hope that you will find a place in your heart to remember them as well.

Respectfully yours, Michael G Kimber (Kipper)

NB
In addition to those mentioned above there were a further 40 executions during the period of WW1, where pardons were not granted. These were for other crimes such as murder.

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

sweetwater

Shot At Dawn - Victims Of War. Part One

I don't usually read prose, but this caught my eye, I have never agreed with the cowerdice label. There is nothing wrong or cowardly with not wanting to kill other people. Some people can do it some can't and others won't. Running screaming through a hail of bullets to get away isn't desertion, just sheer blind terror.So glad this is now understood. My father was in the second world war, he was awarded a bravery medal for rescuing an injured man under heavy gun fire, he was also mentiond in a book by Airey Neave for it. For his war effort he was later shot through the lung, had a spine injury and spent a long time in a concentration camp, to go home to years of struggling to make ends meet. So Bravery or cowerdice, both go unrewarded in war, Medals are precious, but I bet he would have preferred his 'old' life back instead.

expat

Shot At Dawn - Victims Of War. Part One

Well done for your efforts in the campaign; I'm sure there were a lot of embarrassed shufflings in high places when these executions were initially made public. As you say, the traumas weren't accepted or even recognised in those jingoistic times.

I remember watching Paths of Glory as a youngster and even then being upset at the callousness of the court martial and the subsequent executions. Worth watching for those that haven't heard of it.

A well-written piece and I look forward to Part 2.

Steve

Mikeverdi

Shot At Dawn - Victims Of War. Part One

Thank you Michael, I too have read accounts.

Mike

Pronto

Shot At Dawn - Victims Of War. Part One

It's a fact that all men and women, no matter how brave, have limits to their courage. I think I read somewhere that the Germans only executed about five of their blokes for cowardice in WW 1. Different attitude I suppose.

I'm glad you're campaign was successful.

stormwolf

Shot At Dawn - Victims Of War. Part One

Hi Micheal,

Just popping in to say hearty congrats on your two nibs!!!

Alison x

ValDohren

Shot At Dawn - Victims Of War. Part One

No-one should ever have been executed for so-called cowardice, and its a disgrace that they were. Posthumous pardons are better than nothing, but it should not have been necessry to have to award them. To accuse these men of cowardice is abominable. Congrats on the well deserved nib.

Val x

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…