From the UKAuthors Collection
The Early Morning Fisherboy
By WCHull · Originally published 17 October 2003
Just a little scene at the wharf...
I saw him stroll to the edge of the wharf
And while setting up his fishing gear
Look hopefully over the planks
Down into gray water
Draped in early morning fog.
Set, he sat, feet hanging over the edge
And cast his line into the deep,
An experienced angler,
Not more than ten years old.
I watched him there an hour long
As he tossed flounders caught
Into his plastic salt beef pail
Until the sun arose chasing fog away,
Whereupon, he took his fishing pole and left,
To return again someday-
I assumed,
As a fishing boat left port.
W.C.Hull 2003 rev. #1
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Re: The Early Morning Fisherboy
I am not sure if you will welcome this. But this is a site very much focused on comments. As you have posted many works, I feel I wish to comment, so I will make them here, once. I know from past comments that you feel strongly that you wish to write in a certain way, and maybe you don't welcome too much contradiction of your set path. Nevertheless.... this is meant kindly and to be helpful.
I read your work often. I see some merit in it, you have a feel for words, you have some nice phrases... BUT, let's take this poem as an example.
- the first five lines were fine, evocative, setting the scene admirably. then we had 'Set he sat' - what? Did you mean 'Set, he sat' as in 'All set, he sat' ? I don't know. Maybe it made sense to others- but not to me. Maybe it's an author's indulgence and therefore a no-no if you want to respect your audience.
Then we get 'o'er' -- dear , dear. As many people on this site have informed me, archaic poetry habits are not welcome today.
And then.....
I watched him there an hour long
As fish he caught tossing them up
what? ----- marginally excusable, but then followed by the absolutely dreadful (I make no excuse)
Onto the wharf where they squirmed like hell
Until no more life in them did dwell.
'squirmed like hell' is rough,
the next line is a crime - an inelegant, reversed-grammar line jammed into the poem to justify a rhyme. Surely you can do better? (you can, I've seen you do it) then why? Some kind of aping of past style that you find pleasing? (read one Ebeneezer Cooke, Poet Laureate of MARYLAND)
The reason I say this is not to attack you, or 'have a go' .
I think you can write good poetry, but while you place archaic, contorted lines in to almost every poem you write, you will not please the reader, in my opinion.
Never mind me.... what do others think? Perhaps a debate might help?
I'd like to see you cure these ills , and unveil this poem as what it could be, what you meant it to be, not what it is now.
And I would not even bother to comment if I did not think there was something here worth digging for.
Re: The Early Morning Fisherboy
I was going to comment that in places you seem to have twisted words to force a rhyme, but I see that griff has already done so, and with far better explanation than I could have given you. Whilst I agree that there is some merit in this, I'm afraid that I also agree with griff's comments.
Lastly, I don't really think you need the question mark after 'Not more than ten years old,' as it's an observation on your part rather than an actual question.
Kind regards,
Romany
Re: The Early Morning Fisherboy
Re: The Early Morning Fisherboy critiqued by egriff Oct. 17, 2003 17:14:39 GMT and Romany on Oct. 18, 2003 15:26:42 GMT.
Please, never assume anything in the poetic arena.
I welcome any critique of what I write that will be helpful and while I do feel strongly about the way in which I write, my written words and formatting of those words, the phrases that I use, can always be changed to achieve an improved poetic product.
Do remember, however, that I not only write from a Newfoundland, Canadian and American world of conceptualism, but also I “think” in those daily living formats. Thus, while a phrase may not be acceptable in your “British English” it may be acceptable in some other linguistic variations. Still, I am willing to be taught as well as write and am honored (honoured) that you would, as well as others, take the time to critique what I write. Critique on, please. While Webster classes the word “critique” as a noun, it is being used also as a verb in some circles.
As to “The Early Morning Fisherman” I respond as follows:
Agreed, it should be as noted… “Set, he sat…. A typo can drain even the best of quills…..no comma in the submitted version, although in the original. I, agree that a little extra time could have been well spent.
“O’er…”
While Webster does claim it to be archaic, I still use it in some poems where I wish to express “over” but, not with two syllables. It has the one syllable and has a soft sound in most cases. In retrospect I could have used "over" without any beat interference in that line at all. Good point.
The question mark after the “Not more than ten years old” as noted by Romany is indeed, not necessary. Another case of time not well spent. Sorry.
The scene was at a wharf where I watched the young lad sitting on the edge of the wharf’s planks casting his line and baited hook out into the waters below his perch. I sat in my car, as I do often at the wharf watching, for hours, the activities that are always occurring there. His being there, fishing, was one of those activities and I watched him, off and on, as I did other “at the wharf” activities for the best part of an hour. Thus:
I watched him there an hour long
The rest is revisable –
As he tossed flounders caught
Into his plastic salt beef pail
Until the sun arose chasing fog away,
Whereupon, he took his fishing pole and left,
To return again someday-
I assumed,
As a fishing boat left port.
Might the following, then, be an improved version?
The Early Morning Fisherboy
I saw him stroll to the edge of the wharf
And while setting up his gear
Look hopefully over the planks
Down into gray water
Draped in early morning fog.
Set, he sat, feet hanging over the edge
And cast his line into the deep,
An experienced angler,
Not more than ten years old.
I watched him there a hour long
As he tossed flounders caught
Into his plastic salt beef pail
Until the sun arose chasing fog away,
Whereupon, he took his fishing pole and left,
To return again some day-
I assumed,
As a fishing boat left port.
W.C.Hull © 2003 Rev.#1
The poem’s ending does leave one hanging. However, it is but one scene in the continuation of all the events that make up a day and those that create a lifetime of experiences.
Please continue to comment. I love to write and I am certainly not above learning. I appreciate all who take the time to do so. Thank you and …cheers.
W.C.Hull
Re: The Early Morning Fisherboy
Where it says "The Early Morning Fisherman" it should read " The Early Morning Fisherboy". Fisherman was the word used in the origional poem, subsquently changed to Fisherboy. Thanks.
Re: The Early Morning Fisherboy
OK, good. I'm always a bit nervous as being honest with someone I don't really know on the site some people can be touchy :-)
PS: I do read all kinds of language, North American included, so no, it wasn't that. I've even written some of my stories in 'American' so no, I'm not being a 'true brit' on this one....