From the UKAuthors Collection
Who would a soldier be?
By Bozzz · Originally published 21 October 2013
Let him run thither. David Frost's mock recruiting advert showed a soldier emerging from his trench, going over the top, rifle in hand and pointing a finger at you "Your Nation needs you - to replace me".
Who speaks for the dead?
“I do” said the priest, “I prayed
but nothing happened.
Who speaks for the dead?
“I do” said the politician, “I prated”
but nothing happened.
Who speaks for the dead?
We do said the dead men,
and they spoke
and nobody heard them.
They were dead.
Who speaks for the living?
"We do", said the priest and the politician
and something happened.
More men died.
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Who would a soldier be?
Bozzz
I'm not familiar with the David Frost reference so I may have missed something. However, on it's own there is a powerful message in your words. They reflect the awful continuing news of one death after another, and the apparent inability by those in whom we put our trust, to end it.
We can only hope and pray that, the future will not be a reflection of the past.
Michael
Who would a soldier be?
Hi David,
I really enjoyed this. A bitter message and a biting irony. If I could change one thing it would be to keep the pattern by saying 'more men died' rather than more 'soldiers'. The uber-realists would say that dying was the ultimate business of soldiers. By extension then, not the business of poets, bakers, engineers and colliers. No?
cheers,
Jim
Who would a soldier be?
Poets and philosophers speak for the dead. Thank you for being both a poet and a philosopher.
Ian.
Who would a soldier be?
Am I allowed a PS?
Thanks
I agree with franciman. Than one word change has given your poem a stronger finish.
Michael
Who would a soldier be?
Brilliant, powerful and interesting read David.
Who would a soldier be?
A powerful condemnation of the futility of wars and the phony exhortation that "the nation needs you".
Who would a soldier be?
How very true.Who does speak for the dead?Only the soldiers who were there and often speak for those who were with them but did not return.A very powerful poem David,expressing my sentiments. well done. Pommer.
Who would a soldier be?
Great writing David, read it early and read it again; the change of word makes it flow. Well worth the nib my friend. Mike
Who would a soldier be?
Aye, David! The problem with history is that no one seems to learn from it. The problem with government is that folks usually go in wide-eyed and become corrupt, thereby losing empathy. The problem with religion is that the leaders are spiritually lost after years of soul searching only to discover that they doubt they have one, privately.
Good job!
Greg :-)
Who would a soldier be?
Absolutely, my friend! To "borrow" Pia's quote, "Good poets borrow, great poets steal."
Greg :-)
Who would a soldier be?
What can I say that hasn't already been said. A great read.
Who would a soldier be?
Priests and politicians rarely do the fighting do they, they just recruit others to do their dirty work ! Good one Bozzz.
Val
Who would a soldier be?
great read indeed, and hidden gem of a funny, 'and nobody heard them. They were dead.'
Who would a soldier be?
Loved it, strong and hard hitting just what I like. I felt that the layout could have been altered for more effect but that's just me. (I have a thing about layouts:) ) I also felt the inverted commas were a tiny bit of a hit and a miss.
I have taken the liberty of showing you how I would have set it out just to demonstrate what I mean but really good David. Well done on the nib
Alison x
PS This is just one way, it could have been broken up differently but felt the killer last line deserved to stand alone.
Who speaks for the dead?
“I do” said the priest, “I prayed
but nothing happened."
Who speaks for the dead?
“I do” said the politician, “I prated
but nothing happened."
Who speaks for the dead?
"We do!" said the dead men,
and they spoke
and (but) nobody heard them.
They were dead.
Who speaks for the living?
"We do", said the priest and the politician
and something happened.
More men died.
Alison x
Who would a soldier be?
It can't be said often enough David- so well done.
Pia