From the UKAuthors Collection

Colley Farnon

By e-griff · Originally published 26 July 2013

For sirat's Prose Challenge.

A man doubts his sanity.

(now edited slightly for those who didn't 'get it' - but only slightly as 50pc of commenters did.)

Colley Farnon

I was sure it was him. We sat at opposite ends of the restaurant, one of the best in town, but with a tendency towards too much nouvelle, nouvelle cuisine. I didn’t really appreciate the smears of nameless sauces that usually decorated the plates, nor the lack of any substantial fresh vegetables. But the tastes were heavenly, and today, the duck with gooseberry was to die for.

He glanced towards me. I tried to catch his eye, but his glance moved on without a flicker of recognition. I stared. People are usually aware when you stare at them, but he seemed oblivious, turning back to his dining companion, a silver-haired man of undoubted wealth. It shone from him, as it does with wealthy people: the clothes, coiffeur, general appearance, manners. I didn’t want to interrupt what must be an important and private lunch.

His face was different. That was the first glimmer of doubt that hit me. He didn’t look like Colley at all. What made me think ... ?

I watched his body language, gestures, the twist of his shoulders, the quirk at the side of his mouth. They were the same, the same as my Colley.

He’d disappeared from my life after Oxford. I’d arrived two years later than him, and we went around together in his final year. The last time we met, he’d said he’d got a job with the Foreign Office, a ‘plum job’ as he put it. The next day, he was gone, no forwarding address, no trace. I hadn’t seen him since, until today.

But what about his face? Had he had some kind of accident? It was flawless, but not quite right, as if he had some kind of mild paralysis. But he was still Colley, I knew that.

I was bullied at school, at first, until Colley became my protector. An older boy, he let it be known that anyone hassling me would have to deal with him, and even in the lower years, he was a force to be reckoned with: eloquent, clever, fit and not afraid to engage if he thought wrong was being done. He was a champion for us younger boys, and of course, later, when he was a prefect, everything got much better for us.

I suppose I had a crush on him – no, no matter what you read about public schools, not that kind of physical relationship. Just one of admiration. I copied his hairstyle and mannerisms, and vied with others to run errands for him. I wasn’t the only one. He was someone who you aspire to be, someone you want to admire you, praise you, even simply acknowledge you. And he took me under his wing. He was kind to me. I lived being Colley Farnon, he was my ideal. I knew every gesture, every nuance of his voice. Kindness. That’s what he had.

I was once hauled up on a serious charge of stealing from another boy. He told me not to worry, he knew me well enough to know it couldn’t be me. He spoke to the Headmaster. I was exonerated, and eventually the culprit was found. He was believed and respected by the masters. They could see what I saw in him, a perfect human being.

And there he was, in this restaurant. It rather spoiled the rest of my meal, wondering how he hadn’t recognised me. Or maybe he had, but didn’t want to acknowledge me. That would be worse.

I settled my bill, and waited, drinking water. Eventually, both men rose, shook hands over the table, and the silver-haired gentleman left.

He took his time, finishing his brandy. He never looked in my direction. Never.

I didn’t want to confront him in the dining room. It might not be Colley, despite my firm belief. He might have some reason to wish to remain inconspicuous. He might be a spy, I thought, an agent. I chuckled. My Colley could never be that: dishonest, devious.

*

I'm following him. I catch him in the street outside.

‘Colley! Colley Farnon!’

He turns from the door of a large black car that has just slid to a halt.

‘I beg your pardon?’

‘Colley, it’s me, Jason. Don’t you remember?’

His face has a look of puzzlement. ‘My name is David, David Percival.’

‘But I know you Colley, I know you. Your face has changed, but everything else is the same,your mannerisms. What happened after Oxford? Did you join the Foreign Office as you said? You disappeared.’

He seems to relax. ‘Well, your friend Culley may well have, but I’m a Cambridge man, and I am a director of Universal Trade, a large conglomerate. ‘

I begin to wonder.

‘But Colley ... ‘

‘ Look, old man, you’ve made a mistake. If I was this Culley fellow, I’d say so. I’d have recognised you when you were staring at me in the restaurant, wouldn’t I? Don’t think I didn’t notice. I find it’s best to ignore such behaviour, I get followed by journalists a lot. ‘

‘But ... you are so similar in every way.’

‘Dear fellow, it’s the laws of chance. You say I don’t even look like your friend. My mannerisms may be similar, but that must be coincidence. I think you’re an honest chap, but you’ve simply made a mistake.’

'If you say so, Colley. But I don't believe you. I have contacts. I'm going to find out why.'

I don't know what makes me say it. I have no 'contacts', no way of finding the truth.

His smile slips a little and a flash of some emotion crosses his face, but only for an instant. Then once again he is sweetness and light, his face calm, relaxed, smiling. He shakes his head slightly. 'You must do what you feel is right. But I assure you, your search will be fruitless.'

There is nothing more I can say. I leave him, walking off down the street.

At the corner, I glance back. He hasn’t got into the car. He's staring after me. His face is expressionless and he's talking quickly into his phone. It must be his work. I hope he can sort out his problem soon.

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

sirat

Colley Farnon

It's a perfectly respectable piece of writing, flows well, kept my attention, and the shift from past to present tense was well handled – so I feel a bit churlish in saying that I was waiting for something more. It seemed to build up to some kind of climax or revalation that didn't come. When we get to the end it really does seem to be just a case of mistaken identity. Or maybe I missed some clue that would have shown me why Colley was pretending to be (or had actually changed into) somebody else.

There's nothing wrong with a bit of open-endedness, but I'm not sure that was what we got here. A conclusion did seem to emerge. It wasn't Colley. Maybe some small extra element would complete the story. What about if the narrator turns out to be obsessed with finding Colley. Fifty metres down the street he thinks he's spotted him again, giving out a parking ticket. Something a bit preposterous or surreal. Or maybe his phone rings and the man says: 'Yes, I am Colley, and if you ever mention it again I'll have to have you killed." Just some kind of additional element to intrigue the reader. Otherwise, no complaints.

bluepootle

Colley Farnon

I liked the change from past to present, and the reminiscences of the past are very well done.

I think maybe I've missed something, some subtle clue, as to whether this man is Colley or not. I wanted something more. Am I missing it or is it meant to be simply a case of mistaken identity?

Nomenklatura

Colley Farnon

Universal Trade? Almost Bond's Universal Import Export... A clue? Perhaps not.

I think I've got it anyway, but I won't say here in case you want to spell it out yourself later.

I liked it by the way.

SirClip

Colley Farnon

I liked this, it was an easy read and as said previously, I thought the transition to present tense was well done.

I get the punch line and I know you don't always need to spoon feed the reader but I think a little more could be made of it. Maybe rather than shouting into his phone, Colley and his driver/bodyguard could be calmly watching the narrator leave from behind their sun glasses, talking into their phones in true secret agent style!

But as it stands, I thought it was great.

e-griff

Colley Farnon

okay, I've edited this a little for those who didn't 'get it'. I really don't want to go any further or it will be a flat giveaway. I'll have to accept that some just won't see it. (except David actually did, but clearly didn't know it - that's what I meant by 'funny' :-) )

SirClip

Colley Farnon

That is cool. The smile slipping for an instant is just enough.

TheBigBadG

Colley Farnon

Well now it's been edited I don't know if I'm observant or if you cleared it all up but I figured it was Colley. Lots of clues there, the deliberate mistake with the name, the phone call, the smile and the cagey reply that wasn't quite a 'you'll find out you're wrong'. All there.

Neatly told though, as recognised above. No particular niggles or complaints with the writing - are you getting back into your stride, perhaps?

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…