From the UKAuthors Collection

After Seeing Thomas Hood's Poem on the Underground

By Nemo · Originally published 6 May 2013

I remember, yes, I too remember
the house where I was born,
and the only photograph I remember
is the one I do not have
of the front, taken before the war
which commandeered for bombs
the railings and the wrought-iron gate.

I remember the jagged stumps,
the missing gate like a loss of face;
the absurdity of the cloche hats
of my mother sadly smiling sadly;
of my kind aunt, too, with no kids to spoil,
who kindly spoilt me with plums till I was sick,
and saved up her suicide for her retirement.

I remember the dining-room,
agony of long evenings, wind howling
under floor-boards, lino lifting,
reek of smoke filling the air,
the Bakelite wireless in the corner,
wheezing and spluttering in and out of life,
my father causing friction twiddling dials.

I remember the air-raid shelter
my parents shared with old Mrs Weaver
till the last all-clear, the cat that sulked
in the cherry-tree if left for a day;
flour-faced Mrs Weaver, my first death at eight;
the cat at ten, just a whiff of gas,
after his trouble in the coal-shed.

I remember the landing,
where I stood and it was always cold,
and I’d call that I couldn’t sleep,
as they niggled away downstairs,
the one coal fire petering out,
a smouldering rumble of a row
she would miss when he’d gone.

I remember the front room,
conserved for special occasions and never used,
icy as a monk’s cell, my Meccano retreat.
I google and see new railings, a new gate -
I imagine phantoms gliding from room to room,
trampling over the boy on the landing
as they traipse through the man on the train.

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

stormwolf

On the Underground

Hi Nemo

I thought this was excellent. Very atmospheric and reminiscent of those days that those of the certain age will identify with. (a bit before my time ;-) )

The only bit that got me was this...

' taken before the war

which took away for bombs the railings

and the gate my father loved to paint.'

I know what you are saying but the grammar is a bit clumsy I think.

What about

is the one I do not have

taken at the front,

before the war effort

stripped away the railings

and the gate my father loved to paint

I got the first two lines and funny enough was only reciting that poem in my head this very morning!

loved Thomas Hood and that is one of my personal favourites.

Alison x

teifii

On the Underground

A very atmospheric autobiography. I don't think there is anything wrong with those 3 lines - and I'm a bit of agrammar pedant.

Bozzz

On the Underground

I tend to agree that the 'taken' and the 'took' are too close and hence confusing. Alison's 'Stripped away' is better than 'took' for the railings. Correct grammar is not the issue. It can bring clumsy sentences as easily as bad grammar can !?.....Bozzz

stormwolf

On the Underground

Oh dear. :-(((

Seems my suggestion grated and people are 'pulling rank' re grammar but I am afraid I stand by what I said, totally and the 'stripped away' was just off the top of my head in an instant to try to put across what I was saying. Honest feedback is crucial.

Our ratings are to do with personal opinion Nemo and many times a poem rated 8 gets nibbed. Anyway, congrats on the nib.

stormwolf

On the Underground

Yes, fully understand but if you wanted to keep bombs then it would have read better (to me)

which took the railings away for bombs ;/

the inference was in both your comment and Teifii's that a lifetime of grammar rendered 'my' opinion worthless. I am not as old as you but I do posses an A pass in A level English for what it's worth;-(

As you know, I recite all my work and this would have stood out in recitation. just explaining my viewpoint for posterity lol

Anyway, I noticed you have changed it and it reads better now.

Rupe

On the Underground

I thought this was very good - a sturdy and powerfully affecting piece which makes good use of telling detail throughout.

That said, I think it could do with a thorough edit. Obviously where you go with it is entirely up to you - but the following stuck out for me:

- the whole of the first verse seemed unnecessary. The poem really gets going in the second. So this could either be reworked or discarded.

- 'mother sadly smiling sadly'. Why repeat 'sadly' here? I can see the logic in repetition of 'kindly' in the line below, but I felt the repetition of 'sadly' doesn't really achieve anything.

- 'conserved for special occasions'. I'd go with 'reserved'. Perhaps 'conserved' can be used legitimately in this context, but it always makes me think of jam.

- the last two lines of the last verse. I don't understand how the phantoms can simultaneously trample the boy on the landing and traipse through the man on the train. Do phantoms 'traipse' in any case? This might of course just be me being thick, having missed a vital clue in the rest of the poem - in which case it wouldn't be the first time.

Feel free to ignore, of course, but there's my tuppence worth.

Rupe

freya

On the Underground

Well, Gerald, you wanted more feed-back! This wholly deserves the nib, with far too many fine lines and images, one after another, to quote.

Must say, on my first reading yesterday, I was slightly tripped up by the wording in some of the places mentioned by Alison, Bozz and Rupe, though I got the meaning, throughout. I know I mentally and briefly considered whether a well placed comma here and there might resolve the hitches. But since then you've decided on an edit, it seems, and it now reads pretty smoothly. However not in the repeated sadly sadly phrase. I happen to delight in this play on words and meaning that I've seen in your work before, so what about a comma to separate one meaning from the other?

Tend to think Rupe has a point on at least the first line of your opening stanza. Don't understand why your narrator is telling us he 'too remembers'. It is as if he is addressing either someone else, or perhaps looking at something seen depicted in the subway which triggers memories of the childhood home. Perhaps the poem would benefit from cutting this reference out.

Absolutely blown away by your resolution. Understand it completely and find it extremely effective. Excellent poem. Shelagh

freya

On the Underground

So Gerald, this is like the oil spill in another poem - how can a reader get what you've just told me? Either, tell us in the body of your poem, or put it in your heading:

"I remember, I remember..." Inspired by/from a poem read on the walls of the underground

Or some such. Shelagh

orangedream

On the Underground

Just to say I really enjoyed this. Brilliant writing.

Tina;-)

Andrea

On the Underground

Loved it. I remember too :)

rcc

After Reading Thomas Hood on the Underground

I liked it very much...the lines that seem to be the topic of your comments caught me "computer reading" aka skimming-- but I had to go back because it didn't flow. When I slowed down and read the thing out loud it was perfect. I expected the SOV (subject-object-verb) in my skim (and I apologize for skimming, nasty habit) and when you flip-flopped the order it was like a record skipping in my head.... very good poem about a time almost forgotten. Imagine, today's wars, same as the old wars to the ones fighting, but the rest of the world hardly misses a beat. They don't commandeer your front porch, or your bicycle tires, or your copper...they ask no sacrifice anymore...they don't want to call attention to their deadly but profitable enterprise, war. thanks for the read..........peace-robert

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…