From the UKAuthors Collection

The Art Critic

By Pronto · Originally published 19 April 2013

This never happened, it's just a figment of my "Imagineering" however there is, I believe, a germ of reality and truth in it. Enjoy!

The colour’s wrong the sky’s too big
What’s it supposed to be?
I’ll never be accepted
Far too vague you see
And ships don’t ever look like that
And what’s that there? A tree?
The sun’s too bold the sea’s too pale
It don’t look right to me

If you’re ever to succeed my boy
I feel I ought to mention
You’ve got to paint more like the rest
By sticking to convention
No, I’m afraid it just won’t do
You’re obviously still a learner
Do you have a name young man?
Who? JMW Turner?

Archived reader comments

These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.

Bandersnatch

The Art Critic

This was really good! It made me smile which is something I feel I don't do enough! Thank you, it was a pleasure to read.

Rupe

The Art Critic

Very entertaining and plenty of truth in it - there's many a talented and successful artist who has initially met with rejection (I read somewhere that the Beatles were turned down by Decca on the grounds that 'groups with guitars are on the way out', for instance).

Rupe

teifii

The Art Critic

Very good. All too true very often. Love the twist at the end.

OldPeculier

The Art Critic

Very good. Same goes for budding writers too I believe!

Andrea

The Art Critic

Ooooh, I love Turner, he's one of my faves! Jolly good pome, too :)

Ionicus

The Art Critic

A good one, Pronto, and a clever ending.

ValDohren

The Art Critic

Really like this one Pronto, and so true - many talented people have experienced rejection - even the fantastic stage show Les Miserables had its critics. Very well written.

Val

Savvi

The Art Critic

Very much enjoyed pronto especially the reveal in the last line, very clever. S

Around the UKAuthors table

Member Shoutbox

Say hello, share a thought, or tell fellow members what you’re working on.

Active in the last 30 minutes Checking…

Loading the conversation…