From the UKAuthors Collection
Sonnet - III (O love, thou art but as a fleeting dream)
By ValDohren · Originally published 8 March 2013
Sonnet time again ....
O love, thou art but as a fleeting dream
That passeth in the stillness of the night
To capture souls and fill with vain esteem
Then carry them above on wing’ed flight
Enraptured be those caught in your domain
With eyes that see naught but the one beloved
Extolling ever with a sweet refrain
Such passions, glowing warm like bosoms gloved
O love, thou art a trickster of the mind
All reason thus be gone and ever lost
So clouding sight, yet furthermore to blind
And then to onwards likely count the cost
..... True love must thence be sought with open eyes
..... Lest that beloved, one ever shall despise
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Sonnet - III (O love, thou art but as a fleeting dream)
Perfect, faultless. *BRAVO!*
You should have a bash at reciting these. If anyone wants to see how to display perfect rhyme and metre they need never look further than your page.
Alsion x
Sonnet - III (O love, thou art but as a fleeting dream)
Absolutely Val.
Love is blind and blinded, cares not a jot.
Weefatfella.x
http://youtu.be/DRIgpdNZEvA
Sonnet - III (O love, thou art but as a fleeting dream)
Val, I have no idea what the message in this sonnet is. For a sonnet, or any other form of verse to work, surely it must engage the reader, not the writer?
What is a bosom gloved? and what are souls that are captured and then filled with vain esteem?
I am happy to leave your verse alone, but you ask for critique. And so I give you that.
Having done so I will now leave your submissions well alone, as my intent is not to be malicious, simply to give an honest and one off opinion.
Good Luck Val. Many people will find your verse beautiful and I leave you to that fulsome praise.
cheers,
Jim
Sonnet - III (O love, thou art but as a fleeting dream)
I like this.The line " Oh love,thou art a trickster of the mind" is brilliant and that will do for me.
Sonnet - III (O love, thou art but as a fleeting dream)
-On 2013-03-08 23:49, ValDohren wrote:
Having now received two, what I consider to be very unkind and hurtful comments from you, I have decided to terminate my account with UK Authors. I am sure you will be delighted about this, as you will no longer have to suffer reading my apparently pathetic attempts at writing. When one asks for critiques, they should be constructive and helpful rather than soul-destroying. Well done Jim, you have succeeded !!
[/quote]
Hi Val,
I have commented on more than two of your pieces. Whenever I have commented you have taken umbrage and decried my crit. Let me be honest here, I have no problem with anyone writing poetry. Poetry is a very personal thing, not of itself open to criticism, not of itself open to debate. Poetry posted on UKA is no different, except when you elect to have comment and critique. I have no personal act to grind. If you simply wish to showcase your work then it is a great site for that; but then why ask for comment and critique? If you tell me it is a sonnet and ask for comment, then I can hardly be blamed for giving my opinion on sonnets and your interpretation.
I love phonic poetry. Lyric poetry doesn't need meaning to make it meaningful, of itself. But good poetry imho does have to have the integrity of its parts. You cannot use words simply because they sound right, they have to mean something. If you cannot see that then maybe you shouldn't be trying to write sonnets. And you certainly shouldn't be asking me for an opinion.
I am sorry you have decided to leave. I am angry that you are using me as an excuse for leaving; and I am even more irate that you have pm'd me. Given my 'hurtful' comment, I would much rather you engaged me in public. At least that way other members would be able to judge for themselves whether my comments were untoward or hurtful.
Lastly, I would urge you to look at the timescale of my two 'hurtful' comments. I suggest to you that it is scant reason for leaving. I will not encourage you to stay, which is, I believe, what you are after. You must simply make up your own mind. I did foresee a reaction from you, which is why I said I would not visit your subs again. I feel that should be enough even for a fragile ego.
I do wish you well Val,
cheers,
Jim
Sonnet - III (O love, thou art but as a fleeting dream)
Oh Dear, well you cant please all of the people all of the time. As always opinions differ and I loved it. Mike
Sonnet - III (O love, thou art but as a fleeting dream)
Val, I would just like to say that being "tactful" is very hard when trying to give an honest post to an authors poem, you may have seen recently that I decided to
delete my post last week to a poem where my honesty was taken for something else entirely, I wanted to comment on your poem above for instance but feared doing so because my thoughts would be the same as Francimans and in all honesty would have gone way beyond them, how I would have done that with "tact" is beyond me, In reality Francimans questioning is like
gold dust to us.
I hope that if you look at Francimans post with fresh eyes you will see its value....with respect...David
Sonnet - III (O love, thou art but as a fleeting dream)
See forum JW :-)
http://ukauthors.com/phorum5/read.php?11,212587
Sonnet - III (O love, thou art but as a fleeting dream)
http://youtu.be/DRIgpdNZEvA
weefatfella.
Sonnet - III (O love, thou art but as a fleeting dream)
Awwwwwwwwwwwwwwww