From the UKAuthors Collection
The Man in the Next Bed
By e-griff · Originally published 28 January 2013
For the prose workshop challenge. 'Observations from a hospital bed'
(edited 12.00 and 1400 Monday and finally 10 feb)
The Man in the Next Bed
He was larger than life. Sitting up high in the bed as they wheeled it in, he looked around him, giving no sign of acknowledgement to the rest of us. It was normal for arriving patients to be greeted with a ‘hello’ and to respond. He took no notice.
I saw a look in his eye I couldn’t place. I’d seen it before, but couldn’t put my finger on it.
We were in the Cardiac Care Unit. On this ward, we were subject to twenty-four monitoring. It was where patients waiting for a ‘procedure’ were kept, and where they recovered afterwards. ‘Procedure’ could mean many things – from a quick insertion of a stent to a replacement heart valve. The stent people were in one day, done the next and out the following day. I was amazed at the speed, and the relatively minor effect apparent with such patients.
The man spoke to the nurses in a peremptory way, once calling for them to bring him a cup of tea when they were attending to other patients. He seemed oblivious to other people’s feelings.
He began to get on my nerves.
He was in the next bed to me – in the corner. Later, he sat in a chair on my side of his bed. He pushed his table right up to my bed so I couldn't close my curtains and ate grapes. He exchanged no pleasantries, never looked at me even though he was just feet away.
I’ve said he was peremptory with the nurses. All except one. It seemed he liked her. He spoke to her politely and in a soft tone.
That evening, his family came to visit. He was charm itself, and you could tell they loved him. It puzzled me. What could explain this split personality?
The next day, I heard him say to his favourite nurse, ‘I’m going to die’. She pooh-poohed him and set about cheering him up, telling him his problem would be solved and there was nothing to worry about. That evening, as she left by the doors on the far side of the ward, I heard him say, ‘Please don’t go’ in an uncharacteristically quiet tone. She could not possibly have heard him.
I was quietly reading my book when the duty nurse came around the corner of the six-bed bay, stopped, and then ran towards his bed, shouting, ‘Don’t get out of bed!’ The side curtains of my bed were drawn so I couldn’t see what he was up to.
Another nurse ran up and told the first nurse to get the crash trolley, which was stationed on the ward. I could hear them doing something and an alarm was going off.
The nurse closed all our curtains and in what seemed like seconds a stream of people came running. I could see their feet passing by under my curtain. There must have been about seven or eight of them.
I recognised the sound of electric shock activity, then the inevitable ... ‘Are we agreed?’
They all left, leaving me beside him with only a curtain between us.
Ten minutes later, a nurse came past on the way to his bed and I asked what was going on. ‘Just cleaning him up,’ she said.
*
In only another twenty minutes, his family arrived. His wife and two sons. One son swore, shouted and raged, while the wife was calm – I could hear her speaking to both of them soothingly.
More family arrived and there was more crying.
They didn’t take the body away until two o’clock in the morning, some five hours later. The curtains at the foot of my bed were now slightly open and I saw the black trolley with the cover passing by.
The next day, some patients left and new ones arrived. One was put in the man’s bed. They didn’t broadcast the news about him, and I had to tell his favourite nurse myself when she came on duty and asked me where he was. I think she was fond of him.
Sad? Yes. I was torn. I didn’t like him, but felt guilty because he had died. I could have tried harder, talked to him, smiled ... perhaps if he had been relaxed and more comfortable whatever happened wouldn’t have happened. Was I in any way responsible for his fate? Even in the tiniest way ... ?
Then my mind went back to his arrival. I remembered the look in his eyes. It wasn’t superiority, disdain, selfishness, I realised.
It was fear.
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
The Man in the Next Bed
On technicalities first of all, I'd be inclined to lose the inverted commas around the final 'favourite', it makes it insincere as it is which doesn't seem fair. Also, there are a few cases where sentences would work better without early commas, like 'That evening, his family came to visit, including the children.'
That aside, the short sentences and clipped, occasionally perfunctory, tone suit the piece really well. There's that Chekovian sense that it's all happening off-stage, that the narrator is adjacent to tragedy more than part of it. The other man's larger than life front playing against that inevitable (I assume?) sense of culpability for witnessing, even obliquely, death and its aftermath works as a comment on mortality and perceptions of it. Ultimately, it all comes down to the unknowable and how we handle, it doesn't it.
The Man in the Next Bed
I liked the premise behind this story. The voice is authentic in that the narrator is not au fait with the functioning of such a unit. It adds to the fear factor and so to the moral of the story. Because it is faction, I think you have fallen into the trap of providing accurate description. There is no real need to place the bed, to put times and durations to the collection of the body. I think I recognise this from a recent challenge, the opening certainly?
I found this sentence grated on me, the reader, on a number of counts:
When she went off duty that evening, I heard him, in an uncharacteristically quiet tone, say very quietly under his breath, ‘Please don’t go’. She did not hear him.
Overall a good story but not written with your usual skill, nor your eye for detail.
The Man in the Next Bed
The straightforward approach of the narration gives this an edge of realism that makes it quite a powerful piece.
If it was me I would chop the reference to the Vicar of Dibley which makes me think it's going to be more light-hearted than it is. There's some good details, like the eating of the grapes. Maybe I would have liked a bit more of these details of annoyance as a build-up but really it's a very compact and effective piece as it is. Good last line.
The Man in the Next Bed
realism! liked it. hi Griffy! would you like a surrealistic version of your story with abstract elements? *rubs hands*
The Man in the Next Bed
Hi John,
To explain:
When she went off duty that evening, I heard him, in an uncharacteristically quiet tone, say very quietly under his breath, ‘Please don’t go’. She did not hear him.
When she went off duty, I heard him say very quietly, ‘Please don’t go’. I don't know if she heard him.
The original is padded. That evening is unnecessary and either quietly, or under his breath, not both. The quiet tone was not uncharacteristic for the nurse; nor in reality for you? She did not hear him seems a godlike assertion and an assumption on your part. But it is the punctuation and phrasing that grate the most. It is at best inelegant and is uncharacteristic for you. In your editorial hat, you would have a field day with this John. C'mon!
The Man in the Next Bed
I liked it. I do agree with Jim, though, re some of the (imo) extraneous commas. A nice slice of (hospital) life, though.
The Man in the Next Bed
pedestrian! canoe your stories! join the adventurous surrealistic mind! waterfall ahead!
The Man in the Next Bed
Sorry, it was actually BBG I was agreeing with (although I do agree with Jim to some extent as well). For example, in this sentence (as BBG said):
'That evening, his family came to visit, including the children.' I do think the sentence would flow better if the first comma was left out.
Just my opinion.
The Man in the Next Bed
okay, fair enough. The sentence Jim commented on was correctly punctuated. However, as I said ... so I have recast it.
The Man in the Next Bed
Just to say I enjoyed the read, having spent time in hospital myself I recognised the scene a little too well. I don't feel qualified to critique as my work is always under the cosh! but safe to say it was great IMO. Mike
The Man in the Next Bed
a most human voice, with human responses to input under difficult circumstances - no-one wants to be in a hospital bed waiting to discover what their particular 'procedure' might be. well, not unless they've been waiting a long time and want it over with.
I digress.
for me, the little things add to the scene - I had no issue with the bed-placement or other details. I think you've managed to make this a) easily readable, b) a story from a pov we can buy into without much difficulty as it's all too easy to place ourselves in the narrator's position, and c) interesting!
my only issues lay with certain punctuation in three phrases - some of which have already been addressed but here're my two-pennies' worth:
That evening, his family came to visit, including some children.
I'd agree with dropping the first comma. I can hear the smaller pause after 'evening' without needing the comma, whereas the second is required to denote the slightly longer pause.
The nurse closed all our curtains, and in what seemed like seconds, a stream of people came running
Here I don't believe the comma before 'and' works as it stands because that creates a clause of what comes after 'curtains' and before 'a' ... if you need that first comma, then you also need one after 'and' for it to read correctly, imho.
It wasn’t superiority, disdain, selfishness, I realised.
perhaps 'or selfishness, I realised.'?
The Man in the Next Bed
Ok, commaphobics,
Will have another go at it
The Man in the Next Bed
I'd recognise the opening as a griff-voice if this was an anonymous submission. Not a criticism, just an observation.:-)
Commas aside (I'm an old-school punk-tualist as well), I thought the writing was a little stiff in places but I'm sure it would have been smoother without time constraints.
A good effort and believable because it was true (I've seen similar behaviour first-hand) and it made me wonder how I'd behave in the same circumstances.
The Man in the Next Bed
You capture the feel of the day ward extremely well, I enjoyed the whole piece but mostly the detail, I agree with some of the crit but I,m afraid to say its not something I would of picked up, I was totally engaged by the read. Savvi
The Man in the Next Bed
What a lot of fuss over a few commas !! I found the content of the story to be very touching and true to life, and was captivated to its conclusion. IMO there is far too much nit-picking going on and not enough concentration on the actual storyline. But I am no expert and not in a position to criticize anyone's work other than to point out the odd spelling error - 'spelling' was always my strong point at school! For me, it is a good write and a good read.
Val
The Man in the Next Bed
Loved this write, John...the curtain seemed to be so important here just like the invisible ones we put up in our lives...
Regds,
niece
The Man in the Next Bed
Rings very true. I like the inclusion of details. In a hospital ward they are mostly all there is to comment on and they make the author seem plausible
on punctuation --
The nurse closed all our curtains, and in what seemed like seconds, a stream of people came running.
This really needs neither comma. If one loses the phrase the sentence makes no sense, so either neither comma or put first comma after 'and'. Then the clause reads as a non-defining clause.
The Man in the Next Bed
Can people please stop talking about commas. Perhaps Val Doren has a point.
Regardless of that, I have said above I will have another go, regarding the commas. Let's wait for that, eh?
The Man in the Next Bed
Now about those commas...:)
The Man in the Next Bed
I just loved this, it was simply told with one subject, the man in the next bed. There weren't any answers as such, just the way you finished it. So touching. They say fear can be misinterpreted.
The Man in the Next Bed
I liked this, especially the last sentence. However, knowing you,I am surprised that you never made the effort to talk to him.
The Man in the Next Bed
Well, it's a good story JohnG. It moved me.
The Man in the Next Bed
Piece now edited and de-comma'd insofar as I think it justified.
Thanks all for your comments. :-)
Thanks whoever nommed it!