From the UKAuthors Collection
If old raincoats could talk
By Savvi · Originally published 28 January 2013
If old raincoats could talk
Once, drunk and out dancing
I slid off a bar stool
he didn’t even notice, I was carried home
and left to dry out; on a chair.
We used to stride on Lakeland fells
wind lashed lake side paths,
keeping close we kept each other warm,
I held mint cake he had the guide map.
Now if we go walking it’s late at night,
he’s ashamed to be seen with me
and feels the cold rain passing through thin skin,
I hold dog biscuits and scented bags.
A cig in the garden if I’m lucky
we never really go out any more,
when we do it always seems to rain,
anyway that mirror in the hall makes me look tired.
Ohhh but one more chance to feel
sun softening my shoulders,
thrown down in long grass,
picnic blanket pillow talk,
too hot to walk, dusty tracks
arms wrapped round his neck,
piggyback.
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
Grey Regatta
'passing through thin skin' - that's what this did to me, super
Grey Regatta
Thanks for this Savvi, gave me a good smile..D
Grey Regatta
the end creates a perfect contrast with the very british beginning - has it all come to this? dog biscuits and scented bags?
slid off, not of
i feel the punctuation choices could use some looking at, Savvi - they come across as a bit sporadic in places, seasoned a bit heavily elsewhere.
yearning for things gone is such a human trait - don't let it get in the way of what the future could be, given the right direction :)
why regatta? the serried ranks of clouds sailing the sky?
that final image, though, is what stays with me - it's such a happy one.
Grey Regatta
I am left feeling responsible for a ladies regrets.
Maybe I am wrong but that is what this says to me.
Well written but I cannot in all honesty feel your pain. Sorry!
cheers,
Jim
Grey Regatta
Not going to crit. this, just going to say I liked it a lot. Mike
Grey Regatta
Liked it a lot too, Savvi :)
Grey Regatta
savvi: lot of emotion, and need. last line first stanza reads awkardly, perhaps, last 2 lines of the stanza
......
......
when we do it seems to rain.
the hall mirror makes me look tired.
the above the idea and not necessarily a final phraseology, a finger pointing to the moon, not the moon itself.
perhaps cut "even" 3rd line 2nd stanza.
3rd line, 3rd stanza perhaps, "keeping close to keep each other warm."
not sure how much of your last stanza, the emotion, you want to go on with i.e. 2 or 3, or even 4, well chosen lines might be more effective.
all in all, despite the suggestions, your piece communicates what you came to paper to say. good job wrestling it into lines. swep
Grey Regatta
blimey, Savvi - i entirely missed that this was the voice of the raincoat :eek: i honestly thought it a feminine voice, but as soon as i read your reply it all jumped into sharp-focus. please acept my apologies for dense-headedness :D
Grey Regatta
savvi: reading jan's remarks, i too missed the speaker was the raincoat. reads much differently, clears up a few things.
swep
Grey Regatta
I really wondered where people would take this subject, trying to find them all. The coat's pov idea is neat and developed in this, appreciated greatly. Not a crit as such - don't have any, well handled by you with more care than the poem's raincoat. (FranK)
Grey Regatta
Savvi, when it clicks into place it finds me a different person.
I now feel dense, and positively heel-like in my earlier churlish response.
This is very clever. Wonderful modern allegory. Like it very much.
cheers,
Jim (a faded cagoule)
Grey Regatta
perhaps Grey Regatta: from a raincoat, darkly...
? :D might give us who didn't see the pov a pointer
Grey Regatta
Hi Savvy
As a late-comer to this poem all the work has been done for me ;-)
I have to say that when I read it I also thought it was a woman's voice ;-(
When I see it was the raincoat talking it becomes a really, really good poem which I feel needs changing in some way or everyone who ever reads it will miss the pouint. I mean, what's the point in having a good poem when the real meaning is too easily mis-read?
Maybe a change in the title? I don't know but to me at least, this misunderstanding really goes against how good the poem really is. I am giving it an8 but it would have been a nine if it had been clearer.
It can be hard to remember that just because we (the writer) understands the poem, we cannot take it as given that the reader does as well.
Alison x
If old raincoats could talk
Thank you to every one for the help and pointers I've had a re jig to improve the opening and to try and set up the last Stanza a bit better, and added the obvious title. Hope it works. S
If old raincoats could talk
I too did not rea;ise it was the raincoat's voice. Much better once I knew that. Maybe could do with a little tidying but basically very good poem, especially last verse.
If old raincoats could talk
Much better with different title *thumbs up*
If old raincoats could talk
A "talking" raincoat, the whole poem is a great and amazing idea and makes such an enjoyable read. Thanks for sharing this delightful little story. Purple
If old raincoats could talk
Others have given views on how this might be improved, so I won't repeat them.
Despite the title, I didn't immediately recognise that the speaker was a raincoat. Nevertheless, it stood on its own as a picture of a woman grown tired of, which only heightened my admiration when I did realise. I can't immediately see how a clue could be given in the body of the poem, but it would be remarkably effective if it WAS kept quiet until the end and not given away in the title (for some). The kind of trick that makes someone reread with fresh,appreciative eyes-which can only be good.