From the UKAuthors Collection
A Raincoat? In August?
By franciman · Originally published 28 January 2013
For the Poetry Workshop Challenge - RAINCOAT
Edinburgh in the rain; what else?
Giggling rainwater gathers its strength
and shape-shifts dancing debris.
It brims over the rims and runnels
of furrowed cobbles,
in response to the ancient,
gravitational pull of Castle Esplanade.
The Firth of Forth,
cloud shrouded ‘neath Leith Walk
takes shallow, flat, grey breaths.
Their navigation,hit or miss;
cars and taxis spit and hiss
at sandal-shod Orientals.
Bubble-wrapped in plastic Macs
they look for Deacon Brodie,
with their backs turned to St Giles.
Whiles bigger, brash Americans
begin the endless search
for tartan cloth.
More polished Europeans
queue behind steaming glass
at Ensign Ewart’s Chip shop.
One common bond
a washed pale sun,
returned beyond Haymarket;
artful gilds Auld Reekie’s stone.
And sodden, cloying cotton
chills the Summer tourist.
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
A Raincoat? In August?
and I bet your heart breaks for those in sodden cotton ;O) a top trip
A Raincoat? In August?
I've only been to Edinburgh once as yet, and guess what - it rained, so I feel at least a tiny bit qualified to say that this paints a vivid and entertaining picture of the city. Love the descriptions of the tourists! John.
A Raincoat? In August?
Ahhh, lovely, never been to Edinburgh, but I feel I have now :) Some lovely onomatopoeia going on, and I won't even mention the alliteration :)
A Raincoat? In August?
well Andrea might not mention it, but i 'ent skeered to go there :D
lovely, lovely sound-work in V1:
Giggling rainwater gathers its strength
and shape-shifts dancing debris.
It brims over the rims and runnels
of furrowed cobbles,
in response to the ancient,
gravitational pull of Castle Esplanade.
The Firth of Forth,
cloud shrouded ‘neath Leith Walk
takes shallow, flat, grey breaths.
do you think you really need both 'ancient' and 'gravitational'? personally, i'd drop 'gravitational' - the reader understands water find the lowest point to run to but now i guess you're going to educate me further about why this particular place has that specific pull :D imma list'nin' :D
would
It brims over the rims and runnels
of furrowed cobbles,
to the pull of ancient Castle Esplanade
lose too much of what you wanted to show?
might i suggest 'cloud-shrouded'? and an additional comma after 'Walk', but i believe you could afford to cut the one after 'flat'? for me, it smoothes what is a superb image/concept.
you continue the sound-play but now turn the natural imagery towards that odd creature - the tourist. i very much like how the different surface nationality traits are depicted by their choices of points of interest and clothing. You've a missed space after that first comma and 'Whiles'? colloquial? i'm thinking so. i hope so, as it adds what this southerner hears as a regional accent belonging to the observer. :) 'Whiles bigger, brash Americans/begin the (howabout 'their' or 'that'?) endless search/for tartan cloth.'
Their navigation,hit or miss;
cars and taxis spit and hiss
at sandal-shod Orientals.
Bubble-wrapped in plastic Macs
they look for Deacon Brodie,
with their backs turned to St Giles.
Whiles bigger, brash Americans
begin the endless search
for tartan cloth
the final verse leaves the impression of a smiling observer who'll no be sorry ta see them gone.
i really, really like this piece, Jim. x
as usual, all suggestions made with best intentions and no expectations.
A Raincoat? In August?
Jim. You grabbed me with the first two lines and continued that momentum. This is very clever writing. 'Bubble-wrapped in plastic macs' and 'Giggling rainwater', priceless. You could, perhaps, lose the 's' in 'whiles'.
Cheers.
A Raincoat? In August?
Never been to Scotland so the place names mean little too me; but I love the way you tell a tail! Mike
A Raincoat? In August?
Ahh Edinburgh in the rain brings back fond memories, this roles off the tongue like water down a drain pipe, well crafted as ever.
A Raincoat? In August?
Never been to Edinborough but it is the tourists that really make the poem. Also like the giggling water.
A Raincoat? In August?
There are some very effective descriptions that brought clear images to my mind. In that sense, this was well done. However...
I rather shudder at 'neath' ;-) In these days it's something of an unnecessary pretension.
There were a couple of places where the meaning was obscure (such as 'artful gild').
The sudden unexpected internal rhyming in verse two (which I think I have noted before) to me is out of place and appears to be an indulgence on your part rather than a device demanded by the poem.
The ' shopping list ' of place names is rather overwhelming, especially as they are padding and contribute little to the effectiveness of the poem. Sure, they have some meaning for those who know Edinburgh, but for those who don't, they mean little. A few mentions add colour, yes, but here too many I think.
Best, John G