From the UKAuthors Collection
..Something to Your Advantage
By sirat · Originally published 4 January 2013
This is my story in response to the prompt in the Prose Workshop Challenge forum. It's a very simple little piece, but I know that some of you like that sort of thing. Fingers crossed that you'll like this one.
‘We’re closed for the wet season!’ I shouted it through the insect screen, sounding more fierce, perhaps, than I had intended. The tropical rainstorm was making such a clatter on the tin roof I doubted if the old man would be able to hear me. At least I didn’t have to feel guilty about turning him away – he had a perfectly good Land Rover to shelter in. If he had been on foot I would probably have felt duty bound to let him in.
But he persisted. ‘I don’t need a cabin or a tour. I just want to talk to you.’ At least I think that was what he was trying to say. He was wearing a dark-coloured plastic mac with a hood, but it wasn’t coping with the storm very successfully. There was just enough light from the paraffin lamp behind me to let me see the water that was beginning to run down from his chin and the tip of his nose. He didn’t seem to care.
It was more than I could bear to look at his discomfort. I relented and pushed the screen open. ‘You’d better come in!’ He stepped forward and started to remove his coat. His grey hair was thin and sprang into a ragged halo as soon as it was released from the hood. ‘What brings you out here at this time of the year – and this time of the night?’ My voice was still raised, but standing next to him it probably wasn’t necessary.
‘Just doing my job. Are you Benjamin Foley, originally from Balinclare in the county Tyrone?’
It was a shock to hear anybody mention Balinclare after so many decades, so many lifetimes that had passed since I left it. I nodded dumbly, noticing for the first time that he was carrying a black leather briefcase. I motioned towards the dinner table and he sat down. The rain was subsiding a bit. He looked me straight in the eye for a moment before I remembered my manners. ‘Sorry, I should have offered you a drink. I’ve just got the local rice whiskey, but it’s not bad if you have it with a bit of tonic or coke.’
‘Not for me, Mr Foley.’ He put his case on the table and undid the catch. I realised now that his accent was Irish, not American, like ninety per cent of the dry season visitors to the National Park. He had an ageless face, the kind that you can’t imagine ever being younger, ever looking any different. ‘My name is Patrick Culthorne, of the solicitors Culthorne, Hartland and Moran. You may remember us.”
‘Of course I do.’ I was surprised at how vivid my memory was of the outside of their premises. ‘Just across the street from the Erne Cinema. I’m surprised that…’
‘That I’m still alive? Patrick senior, my father, died shortly after you left the town. Mr Hartland is gone as well now. But the firm’s still there. It’s really just my brother Cahill, Moran’s daughter and me these days. They’re all dying in Balinclare, one after the other. That’s why I’m here – as you may have guessed.’
‘Is it… an inheritance?’ He nodded, arranging some papers on the table and moving the paraffin lamp a bit closer to illuminate them. ‘I thought all my relations there were already dead, or at least moved away. Surely you didn’t need to come all this way. Couldn’t you have written a letter?’
‘In view of the sum involved, and the conditions of the will, no. I think this can only be done face to face.’
Intrigued, I joined him at the table. ‘Can you tell me who the deceased is?’
‘In a little while. First, I need to see some documents, and there are a few questions I need to ask you, to establish that you are indeed Benjamin Foley, formerly of Cranfada Farm, Balinclare, and that you satisfy one or two other conditions that the deceased has laid down.’
‘Just how big an inheritance are we talking about here? Maybe I’m the one who needs the whiskey.’
‘We’ll get to that in a little while. If it’s all right with you, Mr Foley, I’ll need about ten or fifteen minutes of your time. If it isn’t convenient right now, I can come back later.”
‘Carry on, please, I’ve got all the time in the world out here in the wet season. Time and rain are the only things in good supply. Take as long as you want.’
He started by asking for some papers. I had to light the second lamp to search for them in the chest of drawers. Passport, Birth Certificate (which I couldn’t find), Certificate of Naturalisation as a citizen of Costa Rica, old bank statements, drivers’ licence, wage slips, letters from the tax office. But I could tell that he couldn’t read Spanish, and most of the documents meant very little to him. He quickly moved on to the questions.
‘Some of the things I’m going to ask you may seem silly, off the wall, but there’s a good reason for every question. Are you happy to answer anything that I ask you?’
‘Certainly. I don’t think I’ve got anything to hide.’
‘Very well. First question. What was the name of your teacher when you went to the Balinclare Primary School?”
A picture came into my mind. Lines of desks facing a blackboard on a wooden easel, an open hearth burning logs behind it. The smell produced by decomposing splashes of school milk rising from beneath ancient floorboards. The chatter of little voices and the shrill shout of the woman teacher telling us to be quiet. ‘The first one was Miss Munsen. I think her full name was Hilary Munsen.’
‘No, that was the Infant School. Later than that. Balinclare Primary.’
The picture in my mind jumped to a baked-mud school playground in the early summer sun, children running about and shouting, a shallow lifeless pond with a wooden fence around it, another higher fence beyond it with a gate, and the main road beyond that; in the opposite direction fields visible here and there between the line of low trees that formed the school boundary. ‘I can remember two of the teachers there,’ I said after a moment’s thought. ‘There was Fergus O’Shea, and his wife. I think she was called Virginia – or Veronica or something.’ Culthorne didn’t react. ‘Am I right?’
He answered with another question. ‘Did you have a best friend at that school?’
I bowed my head in concentration. ‘It’s not easy, you know,’ I pleaded. ‘We’re talking about more than thirty years ago.’
‘Humour me. Please. It’s important.’
‘There was the local minister’s son. Barnie something-or-other. And the barber’s son – Bilshie, I think they used to call him. Bilshie Travers. And Robin McKey. He used to come to school in a pony and trap. I remember that.’
‘What I asked you was, did you have a special friend?’
‘You’re looking for a particular name, aren’t you? And it wasn’t any of those.’ Again, Culthorne did not react. I tried to drag my mind back to those distant times. There must have been someone else. Someone who, in his own recollection, considered me a best friend. Who could that have been?
‘On, wait a minute. I think I know who you mean. He was quite a sickly little boy. Thin. Pale. He used to get bullied a lot before he linked-up with me. Blond hair, almost white. Very thin fingers. He used to play the piano at the school concerts. He was bright – a bit of a swat…’
‘But you accepted that, didn’t you? You didn’t tease him or make fun of him.’
‘No. I liked him. He was okay. But I’m damned if I can remember his name now… oh, wait a minute. It was Ernie, wasn’t it? Ernie Regan or Reagan. Something like that.’
‘It doesn’t matter. Let’s move on a bit. Who was your first girlfriend?’
‘The first girl I fancied? The first girl I kissed? The first girl I thought I was in love with?’ Culthorne remained silent, unwilling to make the question any more specific. ‘To be honest, I think I know who you mean. It was when I went off to agricultural college in Derry, wasn’t it? I would have been about seventeen. So would she. Her name was Rose Cunningham. Is that the one?’
Culthorne retained eye contact but said nothing. The rain had almost stopped now. I lowered my voice. ‘I was crazy about Rose. I wanted to spend the rest of my life with her. I think I came on a bit too strong. Frightened her off in the end. That’s the way it goes, isn’t it? Sometimes people don’t show enough interest, sometimes they show too much and overdo it. We might be together even now, if I’d known how to handle things. All I needed to do was to give her a bit of space. Loosen the reins a bit. We were very good for each other – or at least she was very good for me. There’s so much you have to learn about life, about relationships, and by the time you’ve learned it, well, at least in my case, you’ve made so many mistakes and messed-up so many opportunities, your whole love life is pretty much screwed-up. Anyway, that’s what happened with Rose and me. I screwed everything up.’
‘Maybe you shouldn’t be so hard on yourself, Mr Foley. Do you know what happened to her after she split up with you?’
‘We graduated. Went our separate ways. I heard afterwards that she’d married, but I didn’t hear any of the details. I hope it worked out for her. I hope she was happy.’
‘Would it surprise you to learn that she became Rose Regan? Somewhat… alliterative, isn’t it?’
‘Rose Regan? You mean …she married Ernie?’
Culthorne took up the story. ‘Ernie studied chemical engineering at Queens University. He got a job with one of the big multi-nationals. They put him to work on a major government contract – all very hush-hush. He needed top level clearance to do it. He never told Rose what it was all about. They had to move to Wiltshire, so that he could work at a place called Porton Down. Does the name mean anything to you?’
‘Isn’t that something to do with nerve gas?’
‘Among other things. It’s where they do research into chemical and biological weapons. Strictly for the purpose of defending the nation against them, so the story goes. Those kinds of things are totally banned by international agreement. Even though it’s common knowledge that Britain sells them to foreign governments – including some very questionable ones.’
‘And Rose went along with that?’
Culthorne shrugged. ‘It took her a while to understand what it was all about. But the marriage did start to go wrong. Maybe it was her conscience, maybe it was other more ordinary things. Who knows? We do know that Rose’s family ostracised her. Stopped talking to her. And that the couple were definitely planning to separate. Then, one day, Ernie didn’t come home from work.’
‘Some kind of accident?’
‘Nobody ever said. The MOD didn’t want a fuss – or an investigation. They offered her a very generous out-of-court compensation settlement, on condition, basically, that she kept her mouth shut. She took it.’
‘I see.’
‘And that could well have been the end of the story.’ He paused. ‘Let me ask you one or two more questions before we go on. How did you end up here, in this place, renting out cabins and taking parties into the rainforest?’
‘That’s a hell of a question. Do you want me to tell you my whole life story?’
‘Just the rough outline.’
‘I was pretty miserable, after Rose left. I did what millions of others did later, took a gap year, tried to see the world on a shoestring. Everywhere I went, I tried to sell the few skills I had. Agricultural science – a bit of forestry. The gift of the gab. I always liked animals. It was no effort to learn about them. I just slotted-in here very comfortably. The hard bit was learning enough Spanish to get by, but the people I was guiding were practically always English speakers. It wasn’t so difficult.’
‘You’ve worked other places, I know that. Why settle here in particular?’
‘There was a girl. There’s always a girl, isn’t there? We had a few good years, but guess what, I screwed up again. I’m good at that. After she left, I just stayed here. I’d got tired of moving on. There didn’t seem to be very much point.’
‘Well, let me just tell you that Rose never forgot you. And the things she heard about you from Ernie impressed her as well. After she came into that compensation money, she started thinking about old times – about how she’d maybe made a big mistake. When the money came, everybody wanted to be friends with her again. But she knew it wasn’t real. She knew that she’d only had one real friend – ever.’
‘I think I understand what you’re telling me now. That compensation money – that’s the inheritance you’re talking about. Rose is dead and she left her money to me…’ Culthorne’s face became blurred by the tears that were filling my eyes. ‘You’re telling me that Rose is gone and there’s nothing left but this… blood money…’
‘No, the inheritance was something of an invention. But the compensation money is real. You may get it one day of course, but women have a tendency to outlive us delicate men-folk. It allowed her to pay for my services. You were quite difficult to locate. I think you need to put on your coat now. There’s somebody in the Land Rover that I would like you to meet.’
Archived reader comments
These comments are preserved as part of the historical archive and are read-only.
..Something to Your Advantage
Love the end point of this one, and the build-up to it. I think this story really kicks up a gear when we get to the reminiscences of the schools, the friends - then you began to draw pictures that I could really get involved in. I think the first four or five paragraphs are a bit too concerned with who's shouting at who, who can hear it, how loud the rain is... details that aren't adding a lot. I think it's the right start point for the story but maybe it needs refining to be as good as the rest of it.
It's a lot of conversation but it works for me. I like the moment where he starts to talk more, open up about his first girlfriend; it seems a very natural progression of thoughts, and nicely done.
..Something to Your Advantage
It's a very sweet story, and the end is touching. It's not the kind of thing I would normally be drawn to I confess, perhaps because it's a whimsical tune, but the nostalgia is well balanced.
Perhaps the dialogue could be tweaked a bit to help it flow a bit more naturally in places? For instance the para, when Foley starts saying 'I was crazy about Rose...' there are moments when it feels like he's talking to someone younger than him, not a lawyer who may well be older. I'm thinking just little tweaks really, like rephrasing the sentence around, 'There’s so much you have to learn about life'.
As you say though, it's a simple piece and it certainly achieves what it intended. The set up works and his hazy recollections are well drawn so that you aren't caught up on the mechanics. As Blue says, it is a lot of conversation which isn't a problem but a tiny bit more balancing of the exposition and natural tones would improve it IMHO.
And as I said to Blue, odd how all three of us have written stories of pasts drawing people back in, via the literal setting of a forest. Maybe Neruda has made nostalgics of us all?
..Something to Your Advantage
Well paced dialogue in this piece, the conversation progressively revealing more layers. As a casual reader though, I would not have reached the dialogue. The intro did not contain a hook and I lost interest. It was almost as if it had been written by two different authors. The first half was extremely passive, the use of qualifying adverbs and general over description making it clunky and stodgy.
The second half engaged me and had me metaphorically turning pages.
I failed to see the relevance of the oft repeated 'wet season'. Such a reminder was an intrusion. I wondered if, in the real world, the hero would sit alone in the Costa Rican jungle, in the wet season and not welcome a well to do stranger?
Please don't get me wrong, this was a really well written piece. Unfortunately, the premise that a former lover might travel to the Costa Rica rainforest, out of season, and then sit in her solicitor's Land Rover, still not convinced he is the real Mr Right, is asking the reader to take too much on spec.
Like my piece, I think this needs more work.
cheers,
Jim
..Something to Your Advantage
Maybe I am easy to please, but I loved it. Yes, it needs a bit of tweaking here and there...so what; its great! Mike
..Something to Your Advantage
Aye! I used to cross my toes too, but kept falling down. You may uncross and shake the feeling back into your hands. Really good story and had me going through to your surprising end.
Greg :-)
..Something to Your Advantage
A great story, I really enjoyed the opening very vivid and intriguing, didn't see the ending so for me an excellent well written piece. S
..Something to Your Advantage
No significant comments on the writing, plot progress and completeness overall.
One small thing - as the lawyer recognised he had accurately identified his infants teacher, why would he insist on the Primary school one? Assuming the lawyer would know the school, the second question should be dropped. I wonder what age the lawyer is and if they knew each other in the past? (which would change the tone of the conversation). If the lawyer is much younger, he would probably not recognise the infants teacher and have to stick to his brief (the Primary school one).
I realise this is a tiny point, but you know me :-)
Overall though, the thought of a woman travelling to the rainforest on spec was fairly unconvincing. And depending on the time passed, the connection between them would likely have faded (I myself have never had any desire to get back with the. 'love of my life' except to talk about old times and what she was up to). She sounds a bit of a nut case if we are to accept the premise (and he should be careful! :-)
Best, JohnG